Wired vs Wireless
 
Notifications
Clear all

Wired vs Wireless

38 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
8,989 Views
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Have you heeded the latter part of that statement? Keep all unicast off of the WiFi?

Multicast traffic will always send on the beacon interval and only on the beacon interval. So what can cause it to be delayed? any multicast (or broadcast) traffic to be sent on the WiFi will be queued until the beacon occurs. So a delayed beacon can cause the lag. This means that the beacon can't be transmitted because there's something else going on. It's usually external interference. It can also mean there's too much going on in the network to fit it in between beacons. More commonly is that poor signal strength, or WiFi environment causes unicast packets to retry so many times as to exponentially increase the load on the radios and cuts out available airtime for the multicast traffic to get sent.

Why does unicast work in your case but not multicast? Because you only have very few expixelsticks. Unicast traffic is generally transmitted at a faster rate than multicast. And it will retry until it either arrives successfully or the number of retries is exceeded. So it can often try many times in the time that one multicast packet can go out. But if you had more than just a few, you'd see the same problem as multicast, but likely worse.


Reply
Posts: 2507
(@mrgrumpy)
Famed Member
Joined: 12 years ago

I love wireless, especially since Shelby was able to open up Multicast to multi universe and a fix few bugs too.

Again this year I'm running 100% ESP's; covering all my pixels and several Renard controllers. They have been running virtually hands-off - scheduler, timers and my FPP's do "ALL" the work.

Shelby's & Jon's guidance to run only multicast has been the final fix-all for me. I especially love the fact I can send 1 universe of 1.31, and use a multitude of ESP. My U1 covers 4 Renard locations, and 2 Pixel locations.....6 ESP's total (Actually 8, because I run a couple ESP's in my shop to duplicated what is to happen outside.) I'm also running a 1000 Pixel (200 degree 20x50 strand) mega tree with a 90 pixel star off ESPixelSticks . . (2 @ 500 for the tree and 1 @ 90 for the star.) Working perfectly for the last 30 plus days.

Outdoor AP is also a must do, however I went with the PicoStation (omnidirectional antenna) over Jon's recommended NanoStation (directional) Placement of my antenna was the final factor. I felt directional would not give me the coverage I needed and the omnidirectional would.

To sum it up.....If you take away my ESPixelSticks and Renard Plus ESP adapters, I will quit doing shows.


Reply
Posts: 2507
(@mrgrumpy)
Famed Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Make sure you do not have any unicast channels turned on that you do not have a working receiver. This seems to jam multicast devices. I has that issue last year. Turned off the empty unicast universe and all was well.


Reply
Posts: 115
(@strawberry)
Estimable Member
Joined: 11 years ago

This might be an elementary question. How do I keep unicast off of WiFi?


Reply
Posts: 172
Topic starter
(@rooster519)
Reputable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
mrGrumpy wrote:

Outdoor AP is also a must do, however I went with the PicoStation (omnidirectional antenna) over Jon's recommended NanoStation (directional) Placement of my antenna was the final factor. I felt directional would not give me the coverage I needed and the omnidirectional would.

This is one of my concerns. Some of my show may get blocked by my garage if I use a directional, so I'll take a look at the PicoStation.

You all have given me so much information to digest, but I'm walking away knowing I can make this happen. I appreciate all the information everyone. I'm sure I'll post updates as I go along. Thank you again.


Reply
MartinMueller2003
Posts: 7614
(@martinmueller2003)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Strawberry wrote:This might be an elementary question. How do I keep unicast off of WiFi?

Unicast is data directed at a specific endpoint. If you do not send anything to that endpoint, then the unicast packets are not sent there. However, in this context the intent is to not use unicast to send E1.31 data from the show player to the controllers over WiFi. If the target controller is using WiFi then it is better to use multicast to deliver the E1.31 data. This is due to the way the AP handles unicast data and retransmits when data is inevitably lost. If the target controller is on a wired network, then unicast may reduce the flooding your network experiences.


Reply
Posts: 102
(@rmcgee5)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
jchuchla wrote:pixelsticks are wireless.

HaHa Damn. That's how little I've read on them. I've just seen all the post topics scrolling by.

Ah well. They sound awesome, but I also have overhead powerlines. Maybe I'll try just 1 in the offseason

Thanks for the insight/correction


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago
MartinMueller2003 wrote:Unicast is data directed at a specific endpoint. If you do not send anything to that endpoint, then the unicast packets are not sent there. However, in this context the intent is to not use unicast to send E1.31 data from the show player to the controllers over WiFi. If the target controller is using WiFi then it is better to use multicast to deliver the E1.31 data. This is due to the way the AP handles unicast data and retransmits when data is inevitably lost. If the target controller is on a wired network, then unicast may reduce the flooding your network experiences.

It also means to keep all smartphones, laptops, other computing devices off of the WLAN as well. The source of the sequence data (the show computer or the FPP) should definitely be on the wired part of the network. Another thing that's overlooked is the web interface of the ESPixelStick. That uses unicast data. If your network is already struggling to get the packets to the ESP, the unicast exchange between the web browser and the ESP can be enough to start to fill up those buffers.

Which AP are you using?


Reply
Posts: 115
(@strawberry)
Estimable Member
Joined: 11 years ago

I'm using a linksys wrt160n v3
3 -e682 wired unicast
2 - esp unicast no lag/multicast lag
Rpi3 wired
Router dedicated to show only, using dd-wrt

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

most DD-WRT builds have very broken multicast implementations. That's likely your problem. There are some builds out there for certain hardware where it works better, but you still need to configure most of it manually. I had one working for a bit a few years ago, but it was only working "ok" as it wasn't a very good router anyhow so i dumped it. I haven't gotten another newer one working with multicast ever since. I've since given up on DD-WRT for most things. There's better choices for the same money these days.


Reply
Page 3 / 4
Share: