Conversion to Wirel...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Conversion to Wireless

57 Posts
24 Users
0 Reactions
21.5 K Views
Posts: 2128
(@livermore-dad)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago

Man that is uber clean!!!!

Tory


Reply
N7XG
Posts: 480
 N7XG
Guest
(@n7xg)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago

OK, and now for my 100 bucks worth.

This year I ran a mixture of xbee standard and pros's 1 transmitter and 19 receivers and not a problem at all. I have been using a number of Dirks's boards for several years now and this year added some of our new Simple renard with Dirk;s snap in and it worked perfect.

My first year I used about 1000 of cat 5 cable, now I use perhaps 50'.

Finally I think it is exciting that we have so much electronics to choose from and best of all it all works together.


Reply
macebobo
Posts: 1595
Guest
(@macebobo)
Member
Joined: 17 years ago
N7XG wrote:OK, and now for my 100 bucks worth.

I want my money back! 🙂


Reply
Festus
Posts: 508
(@festus)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago

DMX Wireless? Are we there yet?


Reply
baldylox
Posts: 116
(@baldylox)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

im with festus!


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Festus wrote:DMX Wireless? Are we there yet?

I've got the DIGWDF engineers working on it....


Reply
griffixdc
Posts: 2512
(@griffixdc)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago

after reviewing or looking at this thread i was wondering will one xbee pro work to replace the 1 COM rs485 and work the rest of the boards that are in daisy chain via cat5 cable or does each board down the line need a receiver?....additionally i got a pro kit with the little antenna will that receive through a stainless steel enclosure about 50 feet away from the transmitter


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
griffixdc wrote:after reviewing or looking at this thread i was wondering will one xbee pro work to replace the 1 COM rs485 and work the rest of the boards that are in daisy chain via cat5 cable or does each board down the line need a receiver?....additionally i got a pro kit with the little antenna will that receive through a stainless steel enclosure about 50 feet away from the transmitter

Okay... first of all think about what you just said about the xbee replacing the rs485 from the computer to the first controller -- assuming, of course, that you have an Xbee receiver at that first controller... Think about what the XBee link does. Just think about it for a minute... and then you'll realize that it replaces the wired connection to the first controller with a wireless connection to the first controller. Why wouldn't the controllers daisy-chained off the first one work? They will, except most definitely, you'll want to use 57600 baud, Mark parity and 2 stop bits as the setting for the Vixen plugin and the XBee radio communication. This setting effectively slows the Xbee down just a tad to make it operate closer to the 57600 speed -- without it, it runs a little fast and you'll get dropouts downstream from the first controller because it will pump data into the first controller faster than the controller can handle it.

Now let's consider the second question, about whether it will work inside a stainless steel enclosure. First question is, when you step into an elevator with metal walls all around, how well does your cell phone work? Probably not as well as if you're not in the elevator, huh? And let's think about what radio waves are: electromagnetic waves of energy. Why doesn't a magnet stick to an aluminum or plastic enclosure? Because it's not a ferrous (iron) based metal. Is stainless steel based on iron? You bet your kokabonk. Putting the radio inside a stainless steel box means the box could very likely absorb all the electromagnetic energy before it gets to the Xbee's antenna, resulting in either a much, much weaker received signal at best or no received signal at all. Of course, you won't know until you try it. But my guess is that the box will compromise the signal enough so that you might get erratic behavior.

A lot of the issues related to wireless communication are really pretty logical if you just sit back and think about it a little bit. It's not rocket science but rather, a lot of good common sense. It's always been true that the way XBees work the best is when there is nothing but air between the transmitting and receiving antennae. Every little thing you put between them will not help and will always degrade the signal in some way. Whether it degrades it enough so as to make communication inconsistent is unknown until you actually try it. "Will my Xbee work around a corner?" Who knows. It might, might not. It depends on how far around the corner, what the corner is made of, how far the transmitter is from the receiver, what kind of antenna is on the transmitter and what kind on the receiver (it can make a big difference), and whether you're using a regular or a pro radio. A lot of variables there... so we just tell folks the best conditions for them to work and anything you put in between them will degrade the communication. Just how much is what you have to try on your own.


Reply
griffixdc
Posts: 2512
(@griffixdc)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
dirknerkle wrote:use 57600 baud, Mark parity and 2 stop bits as the setting for the Vixen plugin and the XBee radio communication. This setting effectively slows the Xbee down just a tad to make it operate closer to the 57600 speed -- without it, it runs a little fast and you'll get dropouts downstream from the first controller because it will pump data into the first controller faster than the controller can handle it.

Alright, alright some of the questions i had an idea but i was not for certain... so i was asking to see if any body else had success or difficulty say using a stainless steel enclosure...would there be a way to extend the antenna longer than 8 inches or at least long enough to reach outside of the enclosure? the stainless steel enclosure is 12X12 x 6 inch deep and hard to drill wholes in it ...so i was thinking if there was a way to extent the antenna out the logic hole i pre set it could maybe see light to the radio waves ( but the antenna would have to be minimally 8 inches long to even hit the edge where the hole is placed being on the bottom for water proof concept.

i am not sure i under stand how to do this 2 stop bits or if i understand what your saying precisely i am gathering i need to delay something 2 bits but what am i delaying?


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

What are you delaying? Well, when you add a parity bit, and two stop bits to the packets in the data stream, you're making the data stream larger, and larger takes longer to transmit and receive, so it takes the xbee a little longer to transmit and receive, which effectively slows the xbee down because it has more work to do.

It's like a plain hamburger sandwich with only the patty inside a bun. When you add a thick onion, a thick tomato and some strips of bacon, you're making the sandwich thicker which requires a bigger byte.

You set these values in the Plugin for your sequencer that is sending data to the com port where the transmitter is. But you also need to set the XBee radios so they have the same communication parameters as the data being provided to it from the computer. And you set the receiving radio the same way so that it gets all of the wireless data coming from the transmitter.

You can't effectively add length to the 1" mini-whip antenna so it sticks out the side of the box. You'd have to use an XBee radio with the U.FL connector (preferably) or the XBee radio with the SMA antenna connector. Both of these allow connecting an external antenna via a short cable from the antenna's base to the XBee radio. You'd want to keep this cable 8" or less in length. Then you would drill a 1/4" hole in the case and mount the antenna on the OUTSIDE of the case.


Reply
Page 4 / 6
Share: