USB vs SerialPort
 
Notifications
Clear all

USB vs SerialPort

11 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
6,129 Views
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
n1ist wrote:USB only works over short distances, and most people have their controllers out in the yard while the computer stays inside. As for USB support, you can use a USB-serial adapter (often USB-RS485) or a USB-DMX dongle, depending on your controllers.

/mike

Yup. Direct USB is length-limited and also is difficult to galvanically isolate since it operates in both directions on the same pair of wires.

USB-to-RS485 or USB-to-DMX is a common approach here

As others have said, there are a few wireless approaches

People are working on Ethernet-to-DMX multichannel bridges, these could easily be made wireless. However, Ethernet is a bit expensive for single controllers unless they have very high channel count.


Reply
Posts: 859
(@smartalec)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago

question with a serial port,
do you have to have a 16550 chip on the serial cards, or will the older chipset work?
the reason i ask , is i have 2x 12port (i think could be more) cards from back in the days of running a dialup internet server, all them ports were connected to modems back in the days.

did i just admit my age there.. shocking..lol

but if someone can help me out, then i will know if i can use them or get more silly usb to serial/rs485 dongles.

thanks alec.


Reply
Posts: 3277
 Jrd
(@jrd)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
fj wrote:I'm not sure if this has been discussed before -searching for USB didn't show up anything, but why hasn't a controller that works off USB rather than an old DB9 COM port been considered?

Are there technical limitations? Does it make a board too expensive? Is USB not fast enough? Does Vixen need a rewrite to be able to do it?

Just wondering 🙂

thanks, fj

Vixen wouldn't need a rewrite, just a plugin.

I know this isn't a USB controller but have you seen the RenUSB yet?


Reply
Matt_Edwards
Posts: 2664
(@matt-edwards)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago
smartalec wrote:question with a serial port,
do you have to have a 16550 chip on the serial cards, or will the older chipset work?

thanks alec.

Alec,
The Wiki has a table showing the number of channels for a given Baud rate and Refresh interval. That should tell you if it is possible.
Are you sure the card will install in an XP OS?


Reply
Posts: 859
(@smartalec)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Matt_Edwards wrote:Alec,
The Wiki has a table showing the number of channels for a given Baud rate and Refresh interval. That should tell you if it is possible.
Are you sure the card will install in an XP OS?

Hmm now thats a realy good question.. i know they used to be used on a linux box an also on a win98 box. but then this is old tecknoligy im wanting to use, so i'll be guessing if xp wants to talk to it.


Reply
Page 2 / 3
Share: