Hey all,
I'm new to the community and working on a new system (Read about it here)
My question concerns PDIP versus SOIC soldering and whether using SOIC in my design would turn any DIY people off.
I solder SOIC all the time but I know some people really don't like doing it. Do many designs board designs here use SOIC or is it frowned upon? I like the flexibility SOIC gives me by using less board space but ultimately I want others to be comfortable using and soldering my PCBs designs. I can even create a video tutoial on how to solder SOIC if that would help (there are already vids out there for it as well)
Since I'm using an ethernet communications IC on the board there are a lot of traces and SOIC is nice for its small footprint but they do make a PDIP version of the IC.
Thanks for your feedback in advance!
The number of people experimenting with SMD components is increasing, but NOT at a particularly high rate. I myself am awaiting PCB's for my first SOIC adventure (darn you Canada Customs (sigh)).
Suit yourself. In general, I think that you'll be far better off designing for your own needs rather than trying to please others.
As far as SMD goes, I think that most people would be able to deal with 1206 discrete parts and .050" pitch SOIC parts, even if they are a bit afraid of it at this moment.
Once people get over the initial fear of SMT, they will realize that it's not too hard. For home-etch, it even saves the tedium of drilling holes. I have made projects here that are SMT (0805 and TQFP32) that others have successfully built. Personally, as long as the parts are 0402 or bigger, I can handle it, but most people will balk at parts smaller than 0805. Still fun soldering the STM32, getting it aligned 🙂
/mike
n1ist wrote:Once people get over the initial fear of SMT, they will realize that it's not too hard.
Fear of SMT is the biggest hurdle here.
I have made projects here that are SMT (0805 and TQFP32) that others have successfully built. Personally, as long as the parts are 0402 or bigger, I can handle it,
Now 0603 and smaller are for young'ns that can see properly. Old farts like me stop at 0805s!
Matt_Edwards wrote:Fear of SMT is the biggest hurdle here.Now 0603 and smaller are for young'ns that can see properly. Old farts like me stop at 0805s!
Those of us with unsteady hands have zero chance with SMD. For us, SMD might as well be WMD.
dirknerkle wrote:Those of us with unsteady hands have zero chance with SMD. For us, SMD might as well be WMD.
I read somewhere that when you use a magnifying glass, it actually helps you to have steadier hands (something about your brain can use finer gained control because it's getting more feedback data related to hand position, etc). I tried it and it seems to work, but of course ymmv.
don
I don't think that unsteady hands are that big a problem. Mine aren't particularly steady anymore, but bracing them against the table seems to work fine. YMMV.
There are several different ways to work with SMD.
Some have converted toaster ovens.
Some use hotplates, or frying pans,
I use an embossing gun.
Or the brave will use a regular soldering iron.
I would draw the line at 0805 and .05 SOIC
I use soldering paste as I find it more forgiving.
You can always nudge the part into final alignment.
And I have still had parts jump into place when heated.
For Dirk. My hands are not that steady, and my eyes are not that good anymore.
My last boards were populated 6in from my face,(nearsighted as a bat)
With the board in one hand, and the tweezers in the other, rest your pinkys against each other to help calm the shakes.
I agree with Phil, design for your self.
If someone else wants to use it they will learn the needed skills.
Joel
There are actually some really easy ways to do SMD soldering that doesn't require much of a steady hand.
1) Put down some flux on two opposite corner pads (it will flow and hit multiple pads, this is fine)
2) Align the IC on the pads with pliers and a magnifying glass. (Since no solder is used yet you can adjust as much as you want until its aligned for those with unsteady hands)
3) "Tack" the IC down by taking your soldering tip and briefly tapping the two pins that are on the pads with flux. This will make the IC stick to the pads.
4) Take a piece of thin solder and lay it down across all of the pins on one side of the IC.
5) Using a flat sided soldering tip, tap each pin with the flat side of the tip to melt the solder. Repeat for every pin on that side.
6) Repeat steps 4 and 5 for the other side.
This method works wonders. It lets you get the IC aligned just right before its soldered down and you get the perfect amount of solder per pin with a good connection almost every time. Should work great for people with unsteady hands. I learned it off a youtube video from several years back and I bet you could find several like it with some searching.
Edit: Check out this video:
