CaptKirk wrote:Two questions:1. Any possibility of DMX operation with this board?
2. Any way to slip in an option for channel status LEDs (like 3mm ones that indicate when a channel is on)? I've seen some designs that use the LED as the signal carrier from the MOC to the triac (might be between the PIC and the moc- not sure right now)- any way that could work where an LED was put in with another value reisitor in place of the 180ohm?This design could fit in very nicely with my setup...
Kirk
Capt Kirk,
We are looking into both options...1 and 2
SWEET!!! I am VERY interested!! I will give up fighting for on-board 7 seg and diag capabilities as long as there is at least channel indicators!!
One other idea might be a button that could cause the board to turn all on, or cycle through the channels, or turn them on one at a time leaving them on until they are all lit then turn off and start over. Maybe the button could pick each option with the last button push being all-off/run mode where it goes back to listenening to control? I also hear that toast making is a popular option also... :huh:
CaptKirk wrote:I also hear that toast making is a popular option also...
Well, that option is already there depending on how you wire it. You can easily turn your board into toast. :rolleyes:
CaptKirk wrote:I also hear that toast making is a popular option also... :huh:
I would much prefer the WalkDogs plugin to be implemented... would give me more time to tinker with blinky stuffs! 😉
CaptKirk wrote:SWEET!!! I am VERY interested!! I will give up fighting for on-board 7 seg and diag capabilities as long as there is at least channel indicators!!One other idea might be a button that could cause the board to turn all on, or cycle through the channels, or turn them on one at a time leaving them on until they are all lit then turn off and start over. Maybe the button could pick each option with the last button push being all-off/run mode where it goes back to listenening to control? I also hear that toast making is a popular option also... :huh:
I can see you are an "Idea Man" 🙂 No doubt management. Buttons, Status indicators, LEDs, the different Firrmware required, and the change in designs and manufacturing all lead to more complex and more expensive builds. At what point do we have to remove the "Simple" moniker. When it was first started and then later picked up by the focus was on minimizing the cost and complexity.
Once your board is running you rarely touch it. At that point all of this complicated stuff becomes useless. Well, other than to look cool and have LEDs flashing away in your enclosure. During testing and setup you can use diag firmware to do what you seek a "button" for. If you want to test the output of a Simple board, build a SSR/Cable tester.
Well I looked a the board layout again this morning and there is just not enough room to add more stuff to the board after adding the RenW header and PIC Bypass header. Another thing is that the power transformer would be getting closer to the maximum current output by adding a bunch of LED's, it probably would not make that much difference unless every channel were full on for a long length of time. I also considered using the Power Phototriac that is being talked about in another thread to make space but that requires a 10ma LED trigger current and that would put a 150ma transformer over the edge. So since nothing is final yet we are still looking at different ways to accomplish this at a very low cost and as KY said still try to keep it Simple.
I think it would be a mistake to add the LEDs to the Simple - as KY said, it goes against the principal of the thing. It isn't working? Get a voltmeter and watch for 5v coming out - easy enough.
budude wrote:I think it would be a mistake to add the LEDs to the Simple - as KY said, it goes against the principal of the thing. It isn't working? Get a voltmeter and watch for 5v coming out - easy enough.
Yep I agree. I will still have to go to the next size transformer up if someone wants to pop a RenW on the board that little 100ma transformer just won't cut it.
Even faster would be to slap a cable in, and plug it into an SSR test board (which oddly enough has 4 leds on it). :biggrin2:
Mactayl wrote:Yep I agree. I will still have to go to the next size transformer up if someone wants to pop a RenW on the board that little 100ma transformer just won't cut it.
I’ve never been a fan of status lights. They really don’t tell you much that you don’t already know and they’re just another point of failure. They’re typically connected to the output of the micro so they won’t tell you if the opto-coupler is bad or the TRIAC. Once it’s working, it’s working. If there’s a failure, it’s still broke and you’ll have to trouble shoot it with a voltmeter anyway.
In my view, simple should be simple, otherwise what’s the point. :hmm:
