Voltage Drop Confus...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Voltage Drop Confusion

7 Posts
6 Users
0 Reactions
2,118 Views
Posts: 13
Topic starter
(@gavspac)
Eminent Member
Joined: 15 years ago
[#31295]

One thing which has been confusing me for a while:

I've read that you have to inject power into long lengths of pixels because of Voltage Drop. Indeed I can see that this is true - 'white' pixels dim if I don't do this.

But with last years technicolor pixels I read that I should run them at around 10V if possible to minimise the problems which were occurring. I also read that whilst the pixels were 12V, the led's ran at 5V so lowering the voltage (to around 8V IIRC) shouldn't affect the brightness.

I ran the pixels at 10.6V and the brightness didn't seem to be affected.

But I don't understand it! How come Voltage Drop causes browning out but running at a lower voltage doesn't?

Can someone please explain this to me? Its confusing!


6 Replies
Posts: 2229
(@plasmadrive)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago

On regular pixels the voltage in pretty much decides the current the LEDs will run at when full on because they only have a resistor for voltage drop.

On the Technicolor Pixels they have an internal voltage regulator. That means that whatever voltage comes it is not fed to the LEDs directly but rather regulated to a specific voltage (5v in this case i believe). So the reason to turn down the incoming voltage was to lower the amount of power (heat) that needed to be dissipate by the regulator. The higher the differential between input and output voltages, the more power the regulator has to dissipate given the same output current.

So the reason I started telling everyone to lower the voltage was to lower the heat.


Reply
Posts: 1133
(@toozie21)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I am slightly speaking out of turn here, but one of the things that helped things make more sense to me was that chips like the WS2811 are constant current devices. That means that they will take the same amount of current no matter the voltage. This is why when there is voltage drop, the color gets off kilter (pink) since it is strugging to output all three colors at the same time, causing the pinkish color to be output. (take this with a grain of salt since I am learning as well, but this does seem to make sense to me)


Reply
Posts: 3650
(@jhinkle)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Your question about "voltage drop" has two parts associated with it.

The pixel in question has an internal voltage regulator which sets the current to the leds that form the pixel as long as the voltage TO THAT regulator is above a specified amount.

So if you where only powering a single pixel (3 leds) with color white -- you could lower the supply voltage until the color started to change from white -- indicating that sufficient current was not being supplied to each led.

So --- THAT is the supply voltage level you were referring to in your question -- 12 to 10.6 to 8.

When you have more than a single pixel in your string - there is a section of wire between each pixel that. THAT little wire has resistance associated with it.

All of the pixels are fed in parallel from the power supply with a little resistor (connecting power wire) between them. These little wires (resistors) have the current of ALL of the pixels down stream of them flowing through them -- hence effectively lowering the "supply voltage" seen by any specific pixel downstream from the power supply.

As an example -- your power supply is 10.6v.

These numbers are NOT correct but are for illustration purposes only.

With 1 pixel ... the effect supply voltage seen by the last (only one in this case) pixel is 10.6v ... and assuming the pixel requires 8.0 volts to produce WHITE -- all is well.

You add 99 pixels to the string. You now have 100 pixels - each drawing a specific amount of current. All of that current is going through all of the connecting wires between pixels (think resistors) resulting in voltage drops. Assume (number not correct) that the current required by the 100 pixels all on WHITE require a total current that results in the "effective" supply voltage seen by the LAST pixel to be 8.0 volts. Again - all is well.

Now add 1 more pixel to the string. The additional current demanded by that pixel runs through all those inline resistors (little wires between pixels) and results in an "effective" voltage at that LAST pixel of 7.9v. --- THAT LAST pixel will now NOT be WHITE but an off color. In reality -- the last 2 or 3 pixels will start to show color shift because of the progressing decrease in "effective" supply voltage at their pixel.

So -- in your question --- you can lower the power supply voltage level and NOT effect pixel colors in the string as long as the number of pixels in the string does not lower the "effect" supply voltage to the last pixel below its WHITE level.

By injecting a power feed into multiple points along your pixel string - you are reducing the current through those inline resistors - hence keeping the "effective" supply level seen by any one pixel above its minimum white level.

Hope that helps.

Joe


Reply
DrNeutron
Posts: 2018
(@drneutron)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago

I always liked this Pic to help clarify Ohm's law and put things in perspective:

Ohms Law

:biggrin:


Reply
Posts: 1133
(@toozie21)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
DrNeutron wrote:I always liked this Pic to help clarify Ohm's law and put things in perspective:

:biggrin:

That's good, I like it.

One other thing to keep in mind if you start calculating losses over a cable or length of trace is that you have losses on both the voltage rail and the ground. So if you are doing calculation of an 18awg piece of wire run, you need to account for the drop on both the voltage going out to the device as well as the return voltage on ground (some online calculators will do this for you automatically, but if you do the math by hand, keep it in mind).


Reply
kingofkya
Posts: 2165
(@kingofkya)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Also if you use 12v pixels you have the benefit of having a vary large range of voltage before you see the effects of voltage drop. in my testing you can run 13v to around 6.5v (diyledexpress pixelbulbes)If you look at my youtube video my roofline has 150 pixels on the roof line over the entire string i have a voltage drop from 12v to 9.5v at the other end.

Also high voltage = less drop over the wires.

I would stay away from any 5v pixels because they basically run all the chips right off the 5v feed so you have very little tolerance for voltage drop, unlike the 12v ones that have a regulator in every pixel.


Reply
Share: