Pixel string wire g...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Pixel string wire gauge

34 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
12.1 K Views
Posts: 1267
(@xmasinvancouver)
Noble Member
Joined: 10 years ago
steve123 wrote:Well, as I have been contemplating this issue I have come to realize there could be a safety matter here among the other performance issues you encountered. The smaller gauge wire is not rated to carry 5A current. But, all the controllers are fused with 5A fuses. I have come to realize that the reason they ship with 5A fuses is because they are configured to protect an 18 gauge wire. So, technically speaking, the 5A fuse rating is too big. 22 gauge wire is rated for 3A current.

So, I am wondering if there is a fire risk. It is like installing a 25A breaker on a 15A circuit in your house wiring ... not a good idea and definitely not compliant with electrical code.

I could be wrong, but from what I have seen, 18 awg is rated at 9.5 amps, 20 awg 6.0 amps, 22 awg 5.0 amps. I don't have the electrical engineering background to tell you "no there's no chance of fire". What I will say however, is that while there is incidents, a TON of people get stuff from Ray and use it with a large amount of different controllers, official and home made. And none to MY knowledge are sparking fires when using the standard fusing with them. When I have heard of a fire, it's been for a short or other structural issue. I can accept not quite hitting full 18 awg specs if they perform well enough and have good build quality. But if you are saying you specifically paid a premium requesting the full 18 awg wire and you got 23 awg.... I would definitely bring that up again. Ray is usually a great guy to deal with. And I've never heard of anyone he didn't try to make it right for when they had an issue. If he says true awg is too large to solder to the pixel pads, you can point out that you paid a premium specifically for that feature by request, and that if it was physically impossible to achieve, then why was the request accepted and charged as such? The reality is, honestly, your going to be ok. Just like everyone else here. I was using his "24 awg" pixels last year that were not close to 24awg and I didn't start a fire or have super hot wiring. Just follow the standard wisdom and don't push stuff to the max. Something people overlook when considering draw and the such. Pixels at 50% power look still blindingly bright and you half the pressure being put on the rig


Reply
Posts: 186
Topic starter
(@steve123)
Estimable Member
Joined: 7 years ago

The ampacity rating for 18 gauge wire is 10A. At this current the temperature of the wire will be 60 degrees C when the ambient temperature is 30 degrees. For 20 gauge wire, the ampacity rating is 5A, 22 gauge wire is 3A and 24 gauge wire it is 2.1A. You can increase the current but you increase the temperature of the wire. For instance, if you put 7A through a 22 gauge wire at 30 degrees C ambient, the temperature of the wire is 75 degrees C.

Here is a reasonably good reference for wire gauge versus temperature:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_wire_gauge

I am not clear what the temperature specification for the insulation used for the pixel wire is. Typically PVC insulation is rated to not degrade when the temperature is below 60 degrees C. That is, above 60 degrees, the insulation begins to degrade and over time looses its ability to insulate the wire. Note, the temperature at which the insulation begins to degrade is not the same as the melting temperature of the insulation. The temperature rise and the insulation ratings inform the National Electrical Code in the US and the Canadian Electrical Code in Canada. I have attached a screen shot of what appears to be the insulation rating for one of Ray's pixel strings with 20 gauge wire that I scraped from his Aliexpress store which shows a rating of 60 degrees C.

So, depending on where you live, the ambient temperature could be considerably higher than 30 degrees. I suspect on a hot day in the southern United States, the ambient temperature on the roof of a residential dwelling could be considerably higher than 30 degrees during the daytime. Thus, the current would have to be reduced to ensure the insulation temperature rating is not exceeded.

Wire rating:

Screen Shot 2020 10 18 at 11.13.41 AM

I made an error regarding the wire gauge of the pigtails in my earlier post. The actual wire size of the pigtails and cables I received is something between 19 and 20 gauge, not 18 gauge as advertised. The actual cross sectional area is about 0.75mm2 as indicated on Aliexpress. However, the AWG is determined by the equivalent diameter of a solid wire. Thus, to calculate the equivalent diameter of a solid wire when using stranded wire to compensate for the air gaps between the strands, the diameter should be reduced by 13%. Doing so results in a cross sectional area of 0.57 mm2 which corresponds to an AWG between 19 and 20.

Screen Shot 2020 10 18 at 11.16.58 AM

Reply
Posts: 186
Topic starter
(@steve123)
Estimable Member
Joined: 7 years ago
angus40 wrote:Will you be ordering 3A fuses from Ray or calling him on his BS pixel wire size ?
If they are not 18awg send them back at his expense and get what you ordered and paid for .

Why settle for typical China garbage ?

I ordered products that Ray says on this website are 18 gauge wire. What I received is 24 gauge wire (0.59mm measure diameter * 0.87 (derating factor for stranded wire) = 0.51mm effective solid wire diameter == 24 AWG) for the pixels. This is not even close to 18 AWG.

Another concerning development in this situation is Ray is has not responded to an email for a more than a week now.

What I ordered:

Screen Shot 2020 10 18 at 11.16.58 AM

Reply
Posts: 1267
(@xmasinvancouver)
Noble Member
Joined: 10 years ago
steve123 wrote:I ordered products that Ray says on this website are 18 gauge wire. What I received is 24 gauge wire (0.59mm measure diameter * 0.87 (derating factor for stranded wire) = 0.51mm effective solid wire diameter == 24 AWG) for the pixels. This is not even close to 18 AWG.

Another concerning development in this situation is Ray is has not responded to an email for a more than a week now.

What I ordered:

I do know he is in the middle of his crazy busy season trying to push out orders. I think he probably does 70-80% of his business in these 3 months. Not that this is an excuse, but I have literally never heard anyone report that he continued to ignore them or didn't make it right or something. I would suggest following up politely, stating that you never heard back from him. People get busy. Everyone kind of expects to maybe get a slightly smaller awg of copper from some of the Chinese stuff, but again, if you specifically paid for 18 AWG and you have confirmed you received 24 awg ( I would recommend adding maybe a picture or two backing your claim and measurements rather than just straight throwing textbook definitions at him of standards), that is far too large a gap. And I'm honestly surprised. He is popular especially because he is smart enough to realize something important...that he has an "in" to the Christmas and holiday lighting community, and his reputation inside of it dictates his livelihood. Therefore, it's a bad idea for him to give someone a reason to stay upset. One last thing, obviously don't be a pushover, but more importantly, be understanding and I've found that he is good about things (ie: throw in something like "I know it's your busy time of year" or "You came highly recommended due to the quality of your products" etc.... I believe that's called buttering the bread lol).

With your previous reply, my assertion stands. You are getting deep into the nitty gritty of the specs. Don't get me wrong, safety first. But the point remains that everyone in this community for years has been using those same kinds of products, and it's worked out fine. The only time I could see the need to get that densely into the specs and ratings would be in extreme conditions. I'm assuming it works out for everyone using the standard collective wisdom because ratings are usually for a worst case scenario. If you can avoid pushing it or keeping it at the upper limit all the time, it should be ok. To be clear, I'm not saying screw safety just do whatever you want without consideration. But the thing I have learned slowly over the years doing this now, is don't overthink it. Do plan, do be safe, but don't fixate on things. Not saying this is your situation at all. Saying that was my situation. Out of curiosity, what the per string pricing for that item listing?


Reply
Posts: 186
Topic starter
(@steve123)
Estimable Member
Joined: 7 years ago

My point in bringing all of this up in this forum is I am now understanding why certain things are the way they are. So for instance, why there is a 5A fuse on the output of a controller port. It is not an arbitrary value and the underlying motivation is safety. I live in Edmonton so it is very unlikely the temperature issue is going to affect me during the winter months. Someone in Southern California though might have cause for concern.


Reply
Posts: 1267
(@xmasinvancouver)
Noble Member
Joined: 10 years ago
steve123 wrote:My point in bringing all of this up in this forum is I am now understanding why certain things are the way they are. So for instance, why there is a 5A fuse on the output of a controller port. It is not an arbitrary value and the underlying motivation is safety. I live in Edmonton so it is very unlikely the temperature issue is going to affect me during the winter months. Someone in Southern California though might have cause for concern.

Heyyyyyyy buddy! Fellow Canuck! Go oilers, screw the flames lol. I'm in Vancouver. Seems like there isn't a lot of us north of the border on here sometimes. And yes, Edmonton, consideration would be extreme cold possibly


Reply
Posts: 186
Topic starter
(@steve123)
Estimable Member
Joined: 7 years ago

I found an Amazon listing for Paul Zhang's US-Direct store where he describes their 18 AWG wire. I have attached a screenshot below. So, using the specifications from the listing (34 strands x 0.11mm diameter per strand), the Circular Mil Area ("CMA") works out to 638. A CMA of 638 corresponds to a wire gauge of 22 AWG. When I counted the wire strands in Ray's pixel wire there were about 34 strands. I measured the strand diameter to be about 0.09 or 0.1mm. So, it appears to me that the two wires are likely very similar.

I ordered a couple strings from ETOP and will confirm this.

This has implications regarding the earlier comment about "US suppliers". I found out from ETOP that several US suppliers use his pixels. So, it is highly likely their pixels are not 18 AWG either.

So, back to my earlier question, has anyone confirmed there is any supplier that sells a string with 18 AWG wire?

Screen Shot 2020 10 21 at 4.53.21 PM

Reply
Posts: 1792
(@barbotte)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago

i am not expert but i have still on the house the first pixel 18 gauge that i bought like 7 or 8 years ago and this year i need to replace a pixel and i can tell you the quality and size is way better than the new pixel i order in the last 3 year and they all suppose to be 18 awg ... not ...cheer


Reply
Posts: 186
Topic starter
(@steve123)
Estimable Member
Joined: 7 years ago
barbotte wrote:the first pixel 18 gauge that i bought like 7 or 8 years ago and this year i need to replace a pixel and i can tell you the quality and size is way better than the new pixel i order in the last 3 year and they all suppose to be 18 awg ... not ...cheer

Thank you for that info. So, there was a time maybe when the pixels actually were 18 AWG? When you get a chance, could you please take a closer look at those old pixels and count the number of strands in the wire and if you have a digital caliper, measure the strand diameter.


Reply
Posts: 186
Topic starter
(@steve123)
Estimable Member
Joined: 7 years ago
XmasinVancouver wrote:Go oilers, screw the flames lol.

Hahaha! Oilers flamed out in the first round 🙁

Canucks did better!!! Yeah!


Reply
Page 2 / 4
Share: