Pixel brightness qu...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Pixel brightness question

15 Posts
4 Users
0 Reactions
4,314 Views
Posts: 215
Topic starter
(@reelpilot)
Reputable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
[#37573]

I have kind of a generic question here. The only pixels that I have to date are 12 volt WS2811's that I have in both the bullet and square node styles. My question is, keeping the voltage and protocol constant, do the various form factors that pixels come in have any noticeable difference in overall brightness? For instance for a specific application I need brighter output and was wondering if the 5050 style LEDs are any brighter than the bullet or square style nodes. Since my current pixels have the dome shaped diffuser on them and the 5050's I'm looking at are fully exposed, I suspect they might be brighter, but have not come across any information that quantifies that.


14 Replies
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Yes and no. Different pixels do have different apparent brightnesses. But it has more to do with focus than actual brightness. The 8mm nodes focus more light forward. The 5050s are fairly even over a hemispherical pattern. If you look at them straight on from the same distance, the 8mm style will look brighter. If you're looking at it from 45 degrees off axis the 5050 will look brighter. If you look at it from 80 degrees off axis, the 5050 will probably still win. If you go to 90 degrees or beyond, you'll still see the diffuser on the 8mm glowing but probably nothing at all from the 5050.
That diffuser has nothing to do with how much light comes out. It's all about where that light goes.
There are LEDs out there with more or less brightness but between those two that are the most common for pixels, they're roughly the same in actual light output.

--Jon Chuchla--

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 215
Topic starter
(@reelpilot)
Reputable Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Thanks for explaining it well. I wish pixels were measured in lumens as that would make comparison a little easier. For this project I'm working on I am very limited in space and was hoping a 3 LED module would be bright enough, but I think for my needs it's best to go with a 6 LED module and make changes to the design to accommodate a slightly bigger module. In a worst case scenario if it turns out a little too bright I could dim the lights in the sequencing.


Reply
Posts: 4092
(@skunberg)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Order a bunch of different types and voltages and play with them. I think you'll find different types work better for different things.


Reply
Posts: 215
Topic starter
(@reelpilot)
Reputable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Skunberg wrote:Order a bunch of different types and voltages and play with them. I think you'll find different types work better for different things.

Unfortunately I'm pretty limited with my options at this point. I'm retrofitting my low voltage landscape lights to pixels and as a result of this I am committed with 12 volts and extremely limited on size. I initially thought my 12mm bullet style pixels could be bundled into groups of 3 and placed inside the existing light structure, but my tests showed the brightness was only about half compared to the existing lights. Ideally I would like to keep the profile as small as possible with a max size of a 30mm circle, so I was looking at these pixels from Ray Wu. Link to 26mm modules. I was hopeful they might be brighter that my bullet pixels, but after Jon's answer I doubt this will be a viable option. My only choice I see at this point is milling away some material inside my existing landscape lights so that I can fit these 35mm modules from Ray. Link to 35mm modules. With 6 LED's these pixels are a slightly higher wattage compared to my current landscape lights and the brightness should be sufficient. I could order both lights and see what works best, but I would be wasting a lot of lights that would never be used, not to mention $$. Because of my very tight space constraints, I don't see many options available to me. If anyone has other suggestions or vendors to look at I'm certainly open to ideas.


Reply
Page 1 / 3
Share: