I was trying to lower the TX rate in case the PixelSticks were getting overwhelmed, and/or up the output power in case the sticks couldn't hear the AP.
With it set higher, the throughput graph shows about 2.2MB of data being passed. It remains pretty constant at that number.
I hope to add 4 more PixelSticks tomorrow for some singing trees. Hopefully that doesn't make the problem worse, but I fear it might.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
The Max TX rate only applies to unicast traffic. It doesn't apply to multicast traffic. So if you're doing your best to keep unicast off your show wifi network, it should have no effect.
The beautiful thing about multicast is that number of ESPixelSticks will have no effect on the performance. They just sit there and listen for data. and as long as you can keep your AP from getting distracted with other data, it'll just keep pumping out the data. Kinda like my daughter, she just keeps talking and talking whether I'm listening or not.
jchuchla wrote:The Max TX rate only applies to unicast traffic. It doesn't apply to multicast traffic. So if you're doing your best to keep unicast off your show wifi network, it should have no effect.The beautiful thing about multicast is that number of ESPixelSticks will have no effect on the performance. They just sit there and listen for data. and as long as you can keep your AP from getting distracted with other data, it'll just keep pumping out the data. Kinda like my daughter, she just keeps talking and talking whether I'm listening or not.
I like this analogy....
Probably the most interesting thread I have read in quite some time. I have 27 ESP's out in my yard. Ask Shelby how many questions I have asked him over the years. Jon you had great luck with the wireless Arduino project years ago, where I had hit and miss luck. Believe it or not I have Unicast and Multicast running over wifi. My trusty GECEs are multicast along with a Renard controller. They are so happy like that. I have 2811's running Unicast and they are dead on with the timing. I have 2 NSLM2's with 2 different SSID's. Had 2 FPP's connected to one of the AP's, ugh. Now hardwired.
Everyone has weird problems from time to time. Monday Santa was coming to visit and low and behold a weird problem that reared itself again. I had 4 bushes all in the same universe that were connected, receiving packets, could use the UI, BUT no light. Other multicast and Unicast wireless attached were working and in sync. Got into each UI and jumped them all over to the other SSID/AP and that saved me. I tried the unplug the NSLM2 for a few minutes and try again, but that didn't work. I'm glad switching to the other AP worked. No mind you these ESP's are BEHIND the AP and they worked flawlessly. Then in the middle of Santa's visit I looked in the garden and there was the working AP face planted in the ground. The storm the night before knocked it off it's mount, which in itself was incredible.
So I would love to see an optimal setup for the ESP. I have a EdgeRouter X with a 24 Port TPLink managed switch and both subnets get internet through the ERX. I have a few daisy chained TPLink 8 port Giga switches on the mix. My desktops (3) all have dual nics.
Want another odd problem? I sequenced "Santa Shark" in xLights, don't judge, and I sequenced at 25ms/40fps which was a mistake since I always pick 50ms. When I played it from the FPP or directly from xLights some Unicast ESP's were exactly 4 seconds behind. Everything else was dead on. Re-Rendered at 50ms and the problem went away. Figured it was more data, but why just a few Unicast wireless props.
So I would love to see us combine our setups of equipment to see what "might" be guaranteed to work with wireless. I have tried to switch some of my Unicast to Multicast and it was just too off for my liking and by all accounts running unicast and multicast over the AP's should be a CF.
Thoughts?
https://www.diychristmas.org/wiki/index.php?title=Streaming_ACN_over_WiFi
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
