Nutcracker 3.0 Rele...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Nutcracker 3.0 Released

60 Posts
26 Users
0 Reactions
21 K Views
smeighan
Posts: 2595
Topic starter
(@smeighan)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago
ptone wrote:There is something not entirely right about the way this is being done - I don't want to make unfounded accusations, but xLights was developed under a license. At a minimum, this license must be applied to Nutcracker, and it is not.

http://sourceforge.net/p/xlights/code/116/tree/trunk/license.txt

These things matter, a lot, in software development. The license must follow the source code.

Second, is this a collaboration? Is Matt involved?

Why no joint announcement? nothing posted here

http://diylightanimation.com/index.php?board=36.0

For a claim of a rewrite, this is a VERY thin wrapper around xLights.

There are a few other odds and ends in the source code that give me some pause.

It would be good to see some clarification of what is going on.

-P

Matt and I have been in communication for months. There is nothing underhanded here. Matt approached me last November if he could port Nutcracker to xLights. I said yes, he did the port. Matt has given me free use of all of xLights. Since i am not very proficient in C++ i did not feel comfortable modifying the sourceforge code tree. I told Matt I would copy xlights into github and in essence branch the code. He was fine with this. We talked about maybe doing periodic updates to the original xlights code in Sourceforge. Matt said he was fine using github.

Think of xlights on sourceforge as the official code tree with maybe 3-4 releases per year. github source tree will get 100-200 releases per year. I have talked about some things i want to add, Matt has offered to code the mp4 movie player, the tree effect, animated gifs. I will work on the nutcracker123.com communication so that all effects people have clready created will show up in xLights/Nutcracker.

In other words we are working together.

There is nothing underhanded here. Matt and I both believe in developing an Open Source tool.

As far as the license.txt file missing, i am still learning how to do Windows releases. I will add it into the release process, it was a simple miss on my part.

thanks for your concern, Matt has invested tremendous amount of work in xLights. In fact, that is why i did not rename the executable to keep reference to all the work he has done.

thanks
sean


Reply
smeighan
Posts: 2595
Topic starter
(@smeighan)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago
bob27350 wrote:The threat name norton gives me is WS.Reputation.1. I have no Idea what that means.

Reputation means Norton has not seen this program running in other places. In other words, the code has no reputation history as being reliable. It doesnt mean that it is a virus, they just have no history about the program.


Reply
Posts: 843
(@captainmurdoch)
Prominent Member
Joined: 14 years ago
smeighan wrote:Matt and I have been in communication for months.

Sean, have you or Matt considered using a xLights organization on github with a single repository? You could have both xLights and Nutcracker branches and easily merge commits back and forth. The subversion history could be imported into github so that no existing history would be lost.

As an aside, I've successfully compiled and run the git clone on Fedora 18.


Reply
smeighan
Posts: 2595
Topic starter
(@smeighan)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago
CaptainMurdoch wrote:Sean, have you or Matt considered using a xLights organization on github with a single repository? You could have both xLights and Nutcracker branches and easily merge commits back and forth. The subversion history could be imported into github so that no existing history would be lost.

As an aside, I've successfully compiled and run the git clone on Fedora 18.

I think Matt has no plans on doing any work on xLights, except for things related to Nutcracker. In other words, xLights has become very stable at what it does:
1) Import different files, convert them to xseq format
2) Play the animations using the extensive scheduler

This has been the goal of xLights since 2010, a scheduler that works, doesnt have lag.
Vixen, LOR users have used it for that purpose.

xLights has these Tabs
SETUP,TEST,CONVERT, SCHEDULE

Now we add Nutcracker as another TAB. This means that xLights now has a new function, create effects. It had never done this before. The Nutcracker portion is going to see LOTS of changes this year.

When I meet with Matt, Ill discuss it with him.

thanks


Reply
Posts: 135
(@ptone)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago

Thanks Sean for the clarifications.

Open source is a great thing, and forks are part of the process, and the licensing can for sure get confusing.

So xLights and Nutcracker will live on in parallel then as forks, then fully merging?

As pointed out by CaptainMurdoch, the git workflow would allow for easier merging of the two forks.

Good luck with the new direction.

-Preston


Reply
Page 5 / 12
Share: