ptone wrote:Thanks Sean for the clarifications.Open source is a great thing, and forks are part of the process, and the licensing can for sure get confusing.
So xLights and Nutcracker will live on in parallel then as forks, then fully merging?
As pointed out by CaptainMurdoch, the git workflow would allow for easier merging of the two forks.
Good luck with the new direction.
-Preston
Since Matt has no immediate plans for xLights enhancements, and the current github has the latest xLights sources my guess is that later this year the github will just become the repository of record.
As an aside:
We want to get msq and asq in the supported file types. When this happens, xLights CONVERT tab will be able to convert sequences from Vixen, HLS, LSP and LOR in any mix. It will become the universal converter. The major code i added t github to make the 3.0 release was the ability to export a Vixen *.vir, LOR *.lcb and a HLS *.hlsnc file.
Currently it has
Input
*.vix
*.lms
*.las
*.xseq
*.seq
Output
*.vix
*.vir
*.lms
*.las
*.lcb
*.hlsnc
*.xseq
*.seq
when we add *.msq and *.asq to those two lists, the CONVERT tab will be very powerful. It already is very fast.
We will want multiple developers for the Nutcracker stuff. We have multiple developers for the php version of Nutcracker.
thanks
sean
I'm amazed at some of the posts about this.
It's a free tool that you can use, or not. It's that simple.
I think the new release if great!! I had trouble with the old format and never really got to use it. After a dozen attempts trying to get the animation to load I finally gave up.
I got 3.0 working in under 20 minutes! Since I had no reason to use xlights, I just ignored those tabs. No harm, no foul.
Thank you Sean for all your hard work and dedication to a project that you are sharing with the community.
Scott
Sean,
Out of curiousity, do you have plans to implement an export to Vixen 3.0.4 (or whatever it get too soon) in the near future? given how vixen 3 handles channels (elements) is it even viable?
See it as something that would be useful now, but may end up unused given the direction some of the new effects are headed in vixen. (Don't think they have any plans for video ATM though)
Cheers,
Rowan
Congrats Sean to you and Matt for this huge amount of work. When xlights first added native nutcracker effects, it amazed me at how simple it made things. I was hoping for the ability to eventually export effects directly rather than effects on the fly with an xlights show. So, this is great news!
To those with concerns about xlights, it's a very lightweight program with great features made by someone just as passionate about animated light displays as you are. You can import/export sequences from almost all major vendors! You can use it to schedule and run shows with sequences of different types and with lots of different hardware! You can run various tests on your lights and hardware! And now, you can create and export nutcracker effects right from your desktop! It's a TOOL, use the parts you want. It's not something that threatens your existing setup.
Since Matt has no immediate plans for xLights enhancements, and the current github has the latest xLights sources my guess is that later this year the github will just become the repository of record.As an aside:
We want to get msq and asq in the supported file types. When this happens, xLights CONVERT tab will be able to convert sequences from Vixen, HLS, LSP and LOR in any mix. It will become the universal converter. The major code i added t github to make the 3.0 release was the ability to export a Vixen *.vir, LOR *.lcb and a HLS *.hlsnc file.Currently it has
Input
*.vix
*.lms
*.las
*.xseq
*.seqOutput
*.vix
*.vir
*.lms
*.las
*.lcb
*.hlsnc
*.xseq
*.seqwhen we add *.msq and *.asq to those two lists, the CONVERT tab will be very powerful. It already is very fast.
We will want multiple developers for the Nutcracker stuff. We have multiple developers for the php version of Nutcracker.
thanks
sean
Sean, like I mentioned earlier in the posts, I appreciate all the efforts you have put forth in Nutcracker and making it an almost essential bit of software for us.
Your explanation above makes perfect sense why things are being released in this fashion. Unfortunately in the first post, I either misread or did not fully understand the intent and I was pyssed when I eagerly installed Nutcracker 3.0.0 and instead was presented xLights. To me, it felt like a shell game.
If I need to install xLights in order to make use of the Nutcracker tab, so be it.

