Equalizer Effect - ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Equalizer Effect - Single Strand

19 Posts
6 Users
0 Reactions
6,628 Views
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago

There is absolutely nothing stopping you from using both sequencers. Assuming you will be running the show in FPP. Vixen can output a fseq file just as xlights can. And there is nothing wrong with uploading fseq files from both vixen and xlights to FPP and running them in a single show.

I don't want to degrade this into a Vixen vs xLights. There are differences. I have gotten to meet the devs from both xLights and Vixen teams. Like any individuals every one of them is a unique personality. I irritated the crap out of Jon last year. This year its Gil. They all are defensive of their baby as I would be had I put the time into the projects they have. Despite what they may think of me, I respect and appreciate what they have done and what they have provided to the community. None of us would be doing what we do without them and the hard work these incredibly intelligent and giving people have laid before us as tools for the hobby. So I won't insult either and say either one is better. There are some things Vixen does quite well and xLights does not. And there are things xLights does quite well and Vixen does not. They are clearly different. They have different design goals. Different development paths. And different management styles. And thats fine. Frankly I see the difference as a good thing. Its good that they are different. Its good that they think different and took different paths. We, the users, are different. Each of us have different views and desires. That means one or the other (and HLS and LOR should not be excluded here either) will suit us as a person better than the other. And that fit will differ for each and every one of us.

I have experienced both. I ran Vixen 100% last year. I am running xLights 100% this year. Its not a diss on Vixen. I chose one over the other last year as the one I thought was the fastest to get started with. I still don't think it was a bad choice. Since I was not in chaos mode of a noob trying to figure out where the bear sits this year, I chose to dedicate this year to xLights. To learn it and experience it as I had given Vixen that opportunity last year. At the end if this season, I will evaluate which one is the best fit for ME to continue into next year with. And it may very well be both. As I started out saying, nothing wrong with combining fseqs from both into one show. There are things I love about Vixen. And there are things I hate about it too. And right now xLights has some loves and hates too.

My biggest wish is that the two sequencers would talk to each other. Being able to export from one and into the other would really help a large number of people. And I mean both ways. Vixen > xLights. xLights > Vixen. It would be nice if they could agree on a common file type both could read and write, say a SXF (Sequencer eXchage File). Each could export to that file and each could read it. Thats a big dream and not likely to ever bear fruit. Unfortunately. Then the user could combine the strengths of both programs into a sequence. The two teams are very entrenched. And I don't see any cross flow happening any time soon. If ever. Thats a big dream and not likely to ever bear fruit. Unfortunately. From personal observations, the two teams seem to be at opposite ends of a tug-o-war rope. Which is a shame. It would be nice to see them on the same end of the rope together pulling the users up rather than trying to drag them apart.


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

If there was a way to go from one sequencer to another easily, "Vixen > xLights. xLights > Vixen", then why would there be a reason to use both? If they both "understand" each other then they both essentially do the same thing. I guess I'm just not seeing the benefit.


Reply
Posts: 259
(@cmschleich)
Reputable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Wolfie wrote:I don't want to degrade this into a Vixen vs xLights.

My comment somewhat invites that but its not my intent. I have been shouting at the top of my lungs how cool Vixen is, but I have largely been unable to use the advanced effects due to my elements for this year and I assumed that was normal up until last night. Now I see equivalents of those advanced effects working on my elements. Part of the reason I chose Vixen is the grouping, I saw some thread where someone (who was pro xLights) said there was grouping, but inadvertently implied it required a lot of jury rigging. Looks like grouping concept is plenty strong in xLights. I don't see enough to do a comparison yet, other than more effects work and they appear to have deeper configuration options in xLights.

I will be using both.

As for developers what can one really say? These are people putting their free time into working on something often because it's serves not just technical interest, but some communal big picture purpose. Not to mention I can't believe how much help some of them have been with daily/hourly responses to a ton of posts during their programming season.


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Grouping is plenty strong in xlights. With the addition of sub models as well as sub buffers, in my opinion it's better.

My comment on developers wasn't meant to go to a personal level. What I meant is that I like what's done more on the xlights side then vixen. For example, I still don't think all effects are location based. I think they made a release that made some location based, but to me that should have been priority one.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk


Reply
Page 4 / 4
Share: