That show is awesome! This might be a thread that answers one I just started, I'm using Vixen 3.3 though. I want to get more control over how a "bar of light" behaves on an element, I want a light bar of size of my choosing to walk up/down/left/right on an element per my directional and speed/time choosing. I can't think of a way to do it. My example is as you mentioned, what's seen in a lot of Matt Johnson's effects. I'm looking for more manual control. Is the trick, use Xlights if you want to do this?
Well I downloaded and started playing with xLights... in 45 minutes it has me highly intrigued and seriously questioning my software decision (the one I've already dumped several hundred R&D and sequencing hours into). I created one of my 3 circles groups for testing. It is animating "nutcracker" effects like I haven't seen in Vixen. I've barely even read the Nutcracker manual, I just intuitively did the same setup for my 3 ring circle as I did in Vixen. But if I apply a Vixen 3 butterfly effect for example to my circle group, I get a visual that looks like randomness (which 8 months ago made me presume I had to have a matrix for those effects to work), if I do the equivalent effect in xLights on my circle group, it seems to be able to understand how to animate that effect on my circle group, no differently than on a matrix except the "canvas" is round with a big hole in the middle.
It makes me wonder if either a) I'm not grouping things correctly in vixen to use the "pixel effect" suite (i.e. what were "nutcracker" effects from my understanding, which would be odd because the basic lighting effects work perfectly on my groups), and/or b) xLights has superior effect rendering on elements of varying shapes/sizes?
Another 30 minutes in I can tell xLights has a lot more animation/layering options.
Cmschleich wrote:That show is awesome! This might be a thread that answers one I just started, I'm using Vixen 3.3 though. I want to get more control over how a "bar of light" behaves on an element, I want a light bar of size of my choosing to walk up/down/left/right on an element per my directional and speed/time choosing. I can't think of a way to do it. My example is as you mentioned, what's seen in a lot of Matt Johnson's effects. I'm looking for more manual control. Is the trick, use Xlights if you want to do this?
Yes actually when Matt started using xLights that equalizer bounce type effect was one thing he had trouble accomplishing so I created the "Fill" effect. It was a simple concept it just fills the model from 0% to whatever percentage you dial in on one slider. But the power of it is realized when you apply a value curve to the position parameter. Using that you can create precise controlled pulse motions. Later I added options to allow you to offset the start so it could be positioned on window frames better and also options that allow it to look more like a marquee pattern. You can also have the color change based on time or position.
Gilrock wrote:Yes actually when Matt started using xLights that equalizer bounce type effect was one thing he had trouble accomplishing so I created the "Fill" effect. It was a simple concept it just fills the model from 0% to whatever percentage you dial in on one slider. But the power of it is realized when you apply a value curve to the position parameter. Using that you can create precise controlled pulse motions. Later I added options to allow you to offset the start so it could be positioned on window frames better and also options that allow it to look more like a marquee pattern. You can also have the color change based on time or position.
Man, that, and other things I've seen in a 60 minute play session, would open up big new avenues for me. I read an xLights vs. Vixen posting a ways back, in hindsight I don't think I understood enough, nor saw the right comments to highlight accurate pros/cons from power users. I'm 4 to 8 hours away from finishing my final 2016 song in Vixen, I may take the risk and try to swap to create the .fseq for that track in xLights. One nice thing has been many of the concepts have transferred.
The best pros and cons you will see are from users that have used both vixen and xlights equally. People tend to be brand loyal and will defend their choice simply because someone doesn't agree with them. That doesn't make for useful info in a debate.
I've used both, and xlights is hands down the better choice. I like the developers better as well. Not personally, but they seem to make changes and additions that are useful and functional. Vixen is pretty and has some cool things, but it lacks in real world functionality.
James
Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
