I've searched the forum and didn't really find an answer to this: Which would be better for someone just starting out, Vixen or Xlights? I've been toying around with Vixen 3 since last December and currently just have some Renard AC controllers, but eventually I do plan on upgrading to pixels. I guess the point of asking this question: if I'm going to learn a new program, I'd like to learn the one that will be the best long term and won't limit future capabilities. I realize this might be pretty subjective, but any opinions are appreciated.
jasonsuper50 wrote:I've searched the forum and didn't really find an answer to this: Which would be better for someone just starting out, Vixen or Xlights? I've been toying around with Vixen 3 since last December and currently just have some Renard AC controllers, but eventually I do plan on upgrading to pixels. I guess the point of asking this question: if I'm going to learn a new program, I'd like to learn the one that will be the best long term and won't limit future capabilities. I realize this might be pretty subjective, but any opinions are appreciated.
You are going to get plenty of biased replies to this question however they both effectively do the same thing, there will be advantages and disadvantages to both. You really need to check them both out and use the one that you feel more comfortable with.
When I started out I did try both but that was when xlights was in the early stages and just loved Vixen 3 much more. After using Vixen 3 for a year I started developing for them and never looked back. Although biased I feel Vixen is more polished and easier to use.
In the end though the difference between xlights and Vixen sequence will be minor and done correctly you won't be able to tell the difference.
Jason,
You are going to get people posting for both sequencers. Both are excellent and you cannot make a bad choice. The typical recommendation when this question is asked is to try both and see which is most intuitive for you. Both programs have an Outstanding support system both here and on their respective websites. Both are in active development and are responsive to requests for changes from the community.
All that being said, I went with xLights. I found it easier to setup for my array of controllers and lights. I am still learning and new capabilities are being constantly added.
Good Luck, and welcome to the community.
I myself played with all the programs when I started xlights at time wasn't what it is today so I went with vixen 3 but I did keep up on what xlights was doing I can sequence with either but I prefer vixen 3 but some people will find 1 easier than the other so it is all what you find the easiest for your brain to figure out
How "artistically challenged" are you? If you are planning on doing all of your own sequencing, then either will do well. Try both and figure out which works best for you. They are both excellent sequences with their own strengths and weekneses.
If you don't think you can do all the sequencing yourself and plan on augmenting it with sequences obtained elsewhere, xLights is likely the better option. Likewise, if you plan to share your work with others, xLights is likely a better option as well.
I was confused with Vixen 3 and found Xlights was easier for me when I started with pixels. I still like Vixen 2,1 but I used it for 9 years. I went to school on vacuum tubes, boy has electronics and christmas lights change over the years.Just use one and change as it changes.
you can actually share your vixen 3 sequences pretty easy I do it all the time
dkulp wrote:How "artistically challenged" are you? If you are planning on doing all of your own sequencing, then either will do well. Try both and figure out which works best for you. They are both excellent sequences with their own strengths and weekneses.If you don't think you can do all the sequencing yourself and plan on augmenting it with sequences obtained elsewhere, xLights is likely the better option. Likewise, if you plan to share your work with others, xLights is likely a better option as well.
I am so happy to see that the general consensus is that both are excellent sequencers. I live in both camps. Those that help me by providing sequences for our shows tend to go with Vixen. The reason is history. We have used it since it came out.
On the other hand, there are things in xLights that are quite amazing. To tell the truth, if the two camps ever got together, the combined product would be untouchable.
The other thing that you need to consider is how YOU work. Some can understand xLights' way of doing things and not Vixen. Others are the other way around.
Check out both. Which one appeals to you is the one to go with.
I started with xLights and found it a frustrating model to work with. When I tried Vixen, I found the model worked the way I thought things should work so I have stayed with vixen. A friend of mine started with Vixen and switched to xLights because the model made more sense to him. The point here is that they are both great programs that see the show in different ways. Go with the one that "clicks" for YOU.
Kind of like the good old "Ford vs Chevy " debate. Its whatever you're comfortable with. Me... I like Xlights and my Chevy. I used LOR for ages... tried Xlights, Vixen and LSP when I got into pixels. Xlights just felt right and was the easiest for me to learn. Its all about what you're comfortable with.

