Will this PCB desig...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Will this PCB design work okay?

26 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
10.9 K Views
Posts: 2168
Topic starter
(@djulien)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
n1ist wrote:As for vias vs. holes, there's no difference as far as ExpressPCB is considered, so you can use the already-existing 0.029 via with an 0.050 pad.

I noticed that the vias vs. plated-thru holes looked the same within ExpressPCB, but I didn't know what a board fabricator would do with those if I order a single-sided board - would they convert it (possibly automatically), or would the hole/via be dropped since the order would be single-sided but the via was a double-sided feature?

I tried to incorporate everyone's recommended changes and I played around with the PCB layout some more. I got the board size down to about what I had on stripboard, so I think I'm happy with it. Here is what I came up with.

One further question - is it considered bad practice to use the ring around a hole as a trace? When I compressed the PCB layout, a mounting hole fell on top of a trace, but if there's copper around the hole anyway, I figured I might as well make use of that copper (ExpressPCB didn't have an option for a hole without a pad around it).

thanks

don


Reply
Posts: 1041
(@n1ist)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago

One thing to check - I don't have any expressPCB boards handy right now, but as for other vendors, the main difference between a via and pth is that the via usually ends up with solder mask on the pad, so you can't solder to it. I think ExpressPCB doesn't do this; certainly on the maskless boards, its a non-issue.

As for using the hole as a trace, electrically that's fine. The problem is that your mounting screw is now connected to the trace, and that may be a problem. If your case is metal, it will connect all of those mounting screws together. Also, I wouldn't do that on a high-voltage or high-frequency trace. The proper way to do this is to not connect the mounting holes to anything, or connect them to circuit ground if that is appropriate for your design. You also need to keep other traces or vias far enough away from the mounting hole so they don't get shorted together by the screw head. Been there, and it's a pain to debug the problem since it will only show up when the board is mounted in the case 🙂 For example, the one on your zc/rect board would likely short (or allow an arc) the 110v input.

/mike


Reply
Posts: 2168
Topic starter
(@djulien)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
n1ist wrote:As for using the hole as a trace, electrically that's fine. The problem is that your mounting screw is now connected to the trace, and that may be a problem. If your case is metal, it will connect all of those mounting screws together.

Hmmm, sort of a second layer without jumpers. 🙂

I hadn't considered a metal housing; I was thinking of plastic or wood mounting initially. Looking it over again, it looks like most of the mounting holes would be okay if they were connected (via metal housing). The only problem area would be the little "extra" strip along the bottom. I think I would need to enlarge it or use smaller holes because there is not much clearance in that area.

Is it poor style to require a "non-metalic housing", or some kind of insulation on the mounts?

n1ist wrote:You also need to keep other traces or vias far enough away from the mounting hole so they don't get shorted together by the screw head. Been there, and it's a pain to debug the problem since it will only show up when the board is mounted in the case 🙂 For example, the one on your zc/rect board would likely short (or allow an arc) the 110v input.

Electrically, how much clearance should there be between 110VAC traces?

I was thinking that the parts and screw heads would all be on the "top" and the traces themselves would all be on the "bottom" of the PCB (single-sided), so the screw heads themselves could not short anything unless they actually touched some of the parts. So would this only be a problem if a single-sided PCB design was printed by a double-sided shop (so that holes ended up with copper on both sides of the board)?

Or, maybe I could just skip the mounts within the extra strip along the bottom. How much should a PCB "overhang" the mounting holes?

don


Reply
David_AVD
Posts: 991
(@david-avd)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
djulien wrote:Is it poor style to require a "non-metalic housing", or some kind of insulation on the mounts?

IMO yes. Letting the mounting points become live (with any signal) and relying on the case material to isolate that point is not the way to go.

The only exceptions really are if your are intentionally connecting the mounting point to ground, or if the mounting method is inherently insulated. (nylon bolts or snap-in posts)

Signals on mounting holes is only asking for trouble. Is the board size critical? Can you make it a little bigger to allow for the track?

Even if the screw head was on the top and the pad in question was only on the bottom, you'd need to make sure the spacer between the PCB and case was non-metallic too. You'd also need to make sure the ID of the bottom pad was larger than the hole.


Reply
Posts: 604
(@aussiephil)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
djulien wrote:Hmmm, sort of a second layer without jumpers. 🙂

Electrically, how much clearance should there be between 110VAC traces?

don

In my opinion, if you have opto isolation onboard, in your case the ZC chip then all spacing from 110v to the low voltage traces should match the 0.300 spacing under that chip.

Actual spacing between high voltage traces is dependant on a number of things such as solder masks, board coatings etc and were a board may be home etched should be worked out for a oncoated copper board and the peak AC voltage plus a bit for safety.

at the bottom of the page in the link there is a table that is good to know
http://www.pcbwizards.com/faq.htm

Cheers


Reply
Page 4 / 6
Share: