SNUBBER Solutions ?...
 
Notifications
Clear all

SNUBBER Solutions ??

26 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
20.9 K Views
budude
Posts: 10400
(@budude)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Entropy wrote:I think the extra load people have often solved LED strand problems with is not really a snubber - The problem with LED strands is that they are simply a far lower load than most SSRs expect, and a fairly nonlinear one, however not one that is significantly inductive or capacity. Since they have far lower load, it is easier for line noise and transients to false-trigger the triacs. Adding some constant nice linear load solves this problem.

Snubbers are typically the solution used when a triac-based SSR needs to drive a significantly inductive or capacitive load - in these cases the circuit may be linear but have significant phased delay in the I/V curve.

I'm not sure I completely agree. If you read the PC thread by chuckd, you will see where he added multiple strings of LEDs and the overshoot got worse and worse with more strands. This to me supported his case that it was adding capacitance and was not due to lack of load. I'm not saying this is always the case, and I agree with Phil that perhaps some string manufacturers have taken this into account - - but you can't argue with the scope captures he provided - it clearly shows a day and night difference simply by adding the resistor. At a minimum, it certainly won't hurt to add it and it's a cheap fix if it does work.


Reply
griffixdc
Posts: 2512
Topic starter
(@griffixdc)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
budude wrote:I'm not sure I completely agree. If you read the PC thread by chuckd, you will see where he added multiple strings of LEDs and the overshoot got worse and worse with more strands. This to me supported his case that it was adding capacitance and was not due to lack of load. I'm not saying this is always the case, and I agree with Phil that perhaps some string manufacturers have taken this into account - - but you can't argue with the scope captures he provided - it clearly shows a day and night difference simply by adding the resistor. At a minimum, it certainly won't hurt to add it and it's a cheap fix if it does work.

kinda what i was getting at....
but i think if you a add a diode limiting back flow on the other channels of your controller that have leds i think this might solve all or more of this issues in combination with the resister or some voltage drain technique(ie light bulb, resistor, arch probe)


Reply
n8huntsman
Posts: 562
(@n8huntsman)
Honorable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
budude wrote:...it was adding capacitance and was not due to lack of load. ...simply by adding the resistor.

So if I'm thinking correctly, the LED's are wired in parallel so as you add more LED's, main line resistance goes down, (capacitance up). By adding a resistor in series in the main line, you will increase resistance, capacitance down?


Reply
budude
Posts: 10400
(@budude)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
n8huntsman wrote:So if I'm thinking correctly, the LED's are wired in parallel so as you add more LED's, main line resistance goes down, (capacitance up). By adding a resistor in series in the main line, you will increase resistance, capacitance down?

Here's the thread if you are not familiar with it - go through it, paying attention to the scope captures and you can see the benefits.


Reply
ErnieHorning
Posts: 4434
(@erniehorning)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

All diodes have capacitance. Twisting to wires together also has capacitance. Testing showed that adding LED strings together would increase the capacitance and a string that was modified to be an extension cord and twisted, did not increase the capacitance.
Adding a resistor in parallel, is not a snubber but that's what it's being called though in this case, it has the same effect.

The added capacitance, phase shifts the current passing through the TRIAC with respect to the voltage. This seem to keep the TRIAC conducting. The resistor is the cheapest universal fix that appears to work most of the time though the success varies with the string construction.

I think the problem would go away if the output was a FET transistor instead but a TRIAC is more robust to abuse.


Reply
Page 2 / 6
Share: