SNUBBER Solutions ?...
 
Notifications
Clear all

SNUBBER Solutions ??

26 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
20.9 K Views
griffixdc
Posts: 2512
Topic starter
(@griffixdc)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
[#14543]

i have been reading many threads and and even on planet christmas forums it seems some people have some luck with snubbers and most people dont.

The idea of a snubber is to act in opposite to a capacitor and remove extra charge in the channel or string of LED lights....it happened more so than not on LED strings with a four Diodes /(rectifier) in it ...many solutions have been posted but they help but still dont get rid of the annoying problems .

What i am thinking without any equipment to test this is to have a diode limiting current to go back to the controller, then a capacitor, then the rectifier/ or 4 diodes then the light string then the resistor at the end of each series of LEDS...this might completely get rid of all stray current on the lines that inductance or what have you has created...

just an IDEA i may be completely wrong so any feed back critical or good is appreciated 🙂

the next set of ideas is to put 2 resistors inside the rectifier in parallel to the diodes to. it should release any spike voltages/current on each plane of the sine wave

????dunno i could be smoking something lmao


25 Replies
Posts: 6728
(@p-short)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I stopped following those threads about snubbers on planetchristmas.com a long time ago. There was a solution that appeared to work for some number people, but the explanation of what caused the problem (and how the snubber solved it) was never very convincing to me. I think that it takes a deeper, more detailed understanding of the subtleties of the LED strings than the people there possessed, or anyone here for that matter. So, try it, but don't be surprised if it doesn't work or if it only works in limited circumstances. This is especially true because some of the LED string manufacturers have added extra circuitry to the LED in an attempt to reduce flicker, and these affect how the strings interact with various dimmer designs.


Reply
Posts: 216
(@dunnsr)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago

puff puff PASS

sorry too funny to resist... the only thing that i seen that might be worthwhile was the added load of a resistor, i was going to put them right at the board, and only if my led's flicker... i wont have more than 1 or 2 sets per channel, so it might not happen.. i just dont know until i get my dongles, and a board built.

seth


Reply
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I think the extra load people have often solved LED strand problems with is not really a snubber - The problem with LED strands is that they are simply a far lower load than most SSRs expect, and a fairly nonlinear one, however not one that is significantly inductive or capacity. Since they have far lower load, it is easier for line noise and transients to false-trigger the triacs. Adding some constant nice linear load solves this problem.

Snubbers are typically the solution used when a triac-based SSR needs to drive a significantly inductive or capacitive load - in these cases the circuit may be linear but have significant phased delay in the I/V curve.


Reply
griffixdc
Posts: 2512
Topic starter
(@griffixdc)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Entropy wrote:I think the extra load people have often solved LED strand problems with is not really a snubber - The problem with LED strands is that they are simply a far lower load than most SSRs expect, and a fairly nonlinear one, however not one that is significantly inductive or capacity. Since they have far lower load, it is easier for line noise and transients to false-trigger the triacs. Adding some constant nice linear load solves this problem.

Snubbers are typically the solution used when a triac-based SSR needs to drive a significantly inductive or capacitive load - in these cases the circuit may be linear but have significant phased delay in the I/V curve.

so what you do you suggest creates the "load" so the triacs reconize the LED strands....if i have 1 amp of LED's on a channel isn't that enough load for the SSR to recognize?

i have watched LED light shows .....Only LED, and i didn't notice any of the problems that are common to using LED's...but of course those people are un willing to respond back or paid to have some create the display for the.


Reply
Page 1 / 6
Share: