Renard-WC Wireless ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Renard-WC Wireless Controller

266 Posts
47 Users
0 Reactions
119.3 K Views
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Jrd wrote:Sunday morning I was testing my display (which had lost power overnight due to a GFCI tripping) and it seemed to lag behind until it tripped again. (GRRR!)

Are the XBees less stable when cold?

I am considering adding a night light bulb to my controller box for warmth when the triacs aren't going.

XBees should be okay down to about -40C (or -40F, same temp). The MAX232IN chip is good down to those temps, too but the MAX232N chip is good only down to 0C (32F) and it can choke and be inconsistent below that. If you have the 232N chip instead of the 232IN chip then the heater bulb will probably solve inconsistent performance in cold temps.

A 7w night light bulb should help, but they don't put out very much heat. I've found a small, 15w tubular bulb really warms it up nicely. In my case, mounted it so that it's just above the RS485 chips on my SS boards with the thought that the radiant heat might be beneficial to the communication section of the board, too.

I don't know whether the issue was the Ren-W or the SS board but within 5 minutes after turning the heater bulb "on" the controller snapped in and has worked perfectly every since. Bear in mind that my working temps were all below zero...


Reply
tweist
Posts: 394
(@tweist)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Thank God some of us live in Southern California where all it does is rain. No temp problems here 🙂


Reply
IdunBenhad
Posts: 1603
(@idunbenhad)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Hi:
Yuma, too, except we don't get the rain. Very often, anyway.

I started to answer his question, but decided to let dirknerkle do it, as he has direct experience with those temperatures and had gone through getting everything to function under Santas' working temps. His part of the country is an extension of the North Pole.


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Had to laugh after reading Tweist and Idun's posts 😆

Tweist has been trying to keep his system from drowning this year and Idun's concern is likely steam... of course, Idun had a 12 inch rain this year... wasn't that 12 drops of rain spread out over 12 hours (or 12 days?) 12 inches apart??? :mrgreen:


Reply
Posts: 3277
 Jrd
(@jrd)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
dirknerkle wrote:XBees should be okay down to about -40C (or -40F, same temp). The MAX232IN chip is good down to those temps, too but the MAX232N chip is good only down to 0C (32F) and it can choke and be inconsistent below that. If you have the 232N chip instead of the 232IN chip then the heater bulb will probably solve inconsistent performance in cold temps.

A 7w night light bulb should help, but they don't put out very much heat. I've found a small, 15w tubular bulb really warms it up nicely. In my case, mounted it so that it's just above the RS485 chips on my SS boards with the thought that the radiant heat might be beneficial to the communication section of the board, too.

I don't know whether the issue was the Ren-W or the SS board but within 5 minutes after turning the heater bulb "on" the controller snapped in and has worked perfectly every since. Bear in mind that my working temps were all below zero...

The bag says it is the "IN" chip but I may open up the enclosure when I go out in a little bit to check it for sure, the temps were near or below freezing that morning.

It's probably possible that something on the Ren 24 HC isn't stable at those temps also.


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Yes, it's possible that other components could be adversely affected by temperature, too -- either too high or too low. All components have acceptable working temperature parameters and trying to make them work outside their tolerances would likely affect performance.

I have not tested the Ren24HC, but other than the heavier-duty PCB traces and perhaps the on-board triacs, I believe it uses the same parts as the Ren24 and ought to work fine.


Reply
ErnieHorning
Posts: 4434
(@erniehorning)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

It's also possible that a less than optimal solder joint would cause issues at low temperatures. Circuit boards also contract as the temperature drops.

In my environmental testing at work, I find that IC's work outside of their published working temperature range. I find with transceivers, the oscillator changes frequency enough that it's outside of the channel. Different types of oscillators will operate at lower or higher temperatures.


Reply
Posts: 3277
 Jrd
(@jrd)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Thanks, it all seems to be working now, I didn't bother to open up the box since it had snow on it and it was working fine. I'll trust that Mouser sent me the right part.

Could have been a joint since I am new to this although they all looked pretty good to me. (not that I've been doing this before a few months ago)


Reply
IdunBenhad
Posts: 1603
(@idunbenhad)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Hi:
Glad you got everything going, Ricky.

That's really great that you got your brother going. One to sequence and one to do the hardware. COOL, man.


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
IdunBenhad wrote:
That's really great that you got your brother going. One to sequence and one to do the hardware. COOL, man.

Hmmmm.... a real future in management! 😎


Reply
Page 22 / 27
Share: