Renard-WC Wireless ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Renard-WC Wireless Controller

266 Posts
47 Users
0 Reactions
119.3 K Views
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
ErnieHorning wrote:Dirk, it's the Placebo effect. Mark and 1 stop bit is identical to no parity and 2 stop bits.

Ahhhh.... tastes great.... less filling... I was using Mark with 2 stop bits though... And I've never understood why there would be a Mark parity at all. It must do something. Maybe it was invented by one of the Apostles and someday, we'll end up with the Judas parity...

Thanks, Ernie! I keep learning something every day!


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Not sure exactly where to put this, but I thought this might be a good spot. My problem was bad communication between my transmitting Ren-W and the receiving Ren-W inside a CG-2000 case in the front yard. However, for some reason I actually expected this to work and had a total brain freeze on the logic of what I was doing.

The transmitter is inside the garage against the back wall of a cabinet. It's a Rev-6 Ren-W board with an XBPro - SMA version, with an 11" (9db gain) whip antenna, pointed vertically. My house has aluminum siding on all outside walls so I thought maybe the whip antenna would overcome the aluminum siding.

The receiving Ren-W (also a Rev-6 board) was attached to a Ren64 and inside a CG-2000 case, sitting on the ground behind bushes on the front of the house, about 75 feet away (straight line). The XBPro radio inside had the 1" mini-whip antenna, and it was aligned vertically to match the transmitter.

I've attached a photo of the front of the house with notations of where the transmitter and receiver are. I've also attached an outline of what the radio wave had to go through to get to the receiver. Turns out, I was trying to transmit through 4 layers of aluminum siding, 6 walls, through a reinforced concrete front step, through electrical interference caused by at least two of the wreaths on the front of the house and two trees in the entryway, and of course the lights around the windows. Oh, and did I mention that the bushes that it was under are also covered with net lights? The last picture shows the bushes -- the controller was way down there behind the bushes against the house.

WAS I NUTS OR SOMETHING???

I had created a scenario that couldn't possibly work -- and it didn't -- but somehow in my convoluted thinking, I thought the 9db gain on the transmitter would fix it. Check out the attached pictures and you'll see how really dumb this was.

My solution was to mount an 11" wi-fi whip on a corner bracket, and mount the bracket on a 2' piece of PVC so the antenna was at the very top, and pointed vertically, running the wi-fi extension cable back to the controller near the bushes. I positioned the antenna about 20 feet out from the bushes, near the center of the front yard and pushed it into a hole I'd made with a steel pipe (remember, ground is a bit frozen...no pounding PVC in this weather!). Now it works perfectly.

So all of you folks out there who may experience some reception issues, THINK before you decide where to put the controller/Ren-W. Unlike what I did, USE YOUR BRAIN. 😆 😆 😆

EDIT 10/26/11: for some reason, re-uploaded photos aren't appearing. The photos that originally accompanied this posting are part of the ANTENNA page in the WIKI for the Ren-W. However, I have added a new photo here, one that shows the transmitting antenna I use now (covered with ice...). It's outdoors, and the PVC mount works beautifully.


Reply
XmasInGalt
Posts: 526
(@xmasingalt)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Dave,

Don't feel bad. I learned the same way and ordered my wi-fi extension cable yesterday.


Reply
budude
Posts: 10400
(@budude)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago
dirknerkle wrote:WAS I NUTS OR SOMETHING???

My answer is "OR SOMETHING"... :rolleyes:


Reply
IdunBenhad
Posts: 1603
(@idunbenhad)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Hi:

I think line-of-sight means that the fewer obstructions, the better. It's a 2.4ghz RF radio signal, not an infrared or light beam that really would rely on the literal concept of "line-of-sight." My next testing (hopefully next week) will include testing for transmission range through windows, from inside enclosures, and your idea about PVC pipe is a good one -- I'll try that too. My instincts tell me that anytime you have zero obstructions (other than air) you'll get better performance than when you put things inside enclosures. That must be why they build television and radio antennas outdoors

I hate to do this, but this is from your post of September 15, 2009. I think the "OR SOMETHING" applies here, as I can't remember my own name anymore without looking at my wallet. The other day, I told someone my name was "Genuine Leather". I put "See Photo ID" on the back of credit cards so I know how to sign the slips.


Reply
tweist
Posts: 394
(@tweist)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Dave

Don't feel to bad. I had some what of the same problem, but mine was leaves on the trees. Last year at this time all the leaves were gone. This is the first year with the Ren-W so I put the TX antenna on the outside of the second floor eve. Its a +9db gain WiFi antenna with an extension cable running to the underside of the eve (for weather protection) and connected to the XBee Pro on an explorer. I put the explorer inside a plastic J Box on the underside of the eve. Line of sight was great for all the houses. But the leaves on the trees would kill the signal. So on the receiving houses that had problems, I lengthened the Cat 5 cable from the Ren-W to the Ren64 and mounted the Ren-W on the outside of the highest eve. The longest run of Cat 5 from the Ren-W to the Ren64 is 20 feet. It all works great now, and not a single miss fire. Oh and to protect the Xbee Pro and the Ren-W from the weather, I wrapped it inside of a baggie and zip tied the bottom of the bag where the cable came out. One last think I forgot to mention, I modified the Ren-W and the Ren64 RJ45 connectors to supply the +5Vdc to the Ren-W. That way I only have to run a Cat 5 cable and not an external power wire. But thats just me. I like the idea of less wires.
As for the bushes and the controllers in the front yard. I left the controllers in the front yard in the line of sight and then wrapped the controller boxes to look like presents in the yard under the tree. Works great for me.


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

More antenna stuff...

I built an external PVC antenna using an USB XBee Explorer board and one of tweist's suggested USB extenders from http://www.monoprice.com (their product # 6042, about $15). The USB extender uses standard cat5 to carry signal and power to the remote USB device, supposedly up to 150 feet away. My cable was only 40' long.

Pic#1: shows the explorer board with an XBee module (with RPSMA connector) zip-tied to it and mounted inside the PVC cap so that the RPSMA connector extends through a hole in the top. The Xbee I experimented with first was the regular one, not the pro model, as I wanted to see what kind of coverage I'll get. I'll let you know later on that... (See note below)

Pic#2: shows how the cap fits down over an elbow, and since it's an USB connection, I looped the wire and used a zip tie to the Explorer board to help prevent it from coming loose.

Pic#3: shows the completed head of the antenna and the remote end of the USB extender. Changing the radio out (if need be) will be easy since it's in the head.

Pic #4: shows a long 3" PVC tube that goes through the wall into my main control box in the garage and along the driveway, curling around the corner of the house with a 90 degree bend and exiting behind the bushes. Any cables I need to run outside go through this tube. The tube protects cables from the voracious teeth of the snowblower but also makes it easy to fish wires in/out as necessary. There's another tube going down into my basement workshop, which is right below that corner of the house. I fished a cat5 from the workshop up to the garage and then outside.

Pic #5: shows the antenna, mounted about 24" out from the side of the house and about 8' high. A couple pipe clamps hold it to some wood trim. It's barely visible from the street, and the 11" wi-fi antenna I used provides about 9db gain to the signal. The antenna now has direct, line-of-sight access to each of my controllers in the front yard, and none is more than 75 feet away. I can't imagine how I can improve on this any more other than using an XBPro radio instead of the regular one, but that'll be easy to swap out if the need arises after I test this tonight. A cursory test during the daylight indicated everything was working, but it was quite a bright day and after a new 6" snowfall, very hard to see lights.

I could have used an antenna cable extension and put the explorer board inside the house, but I wanted to get as much transmitter power as I could directly to the antenna instead of being attenuated by an extension cable, and that's why I decided to mount the USB Explorer board inside the PVC pipe.

Total cost of construction supplies: about $10. Total cost of a successful project: priceless

Edit 5:25 pm: The show is running perfectly, zero misfires, everything tracks and synchronizes just right. I'm a happy camper. I don't see a reason to exchange the regular XBee with a pro version. I believe that the 9db antenna makes all the difference.


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
Topic starter
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I recently received an email that asked about the XBee Pro series 2 Modules because the person had a "great buy" on a half-dozen of them.

They "may" work, but it's EXTREMELY IMPORTANT that you know that Series 2 modules use different firmware and ARE NOT compatible with the normal, OEM version of the XBee module that is in the Ren-W BOM. Series 2 modules have different internal hardware components and you cannot reflash them with anything other than series 2 firmware. Buy them at your own risk...


Reply
XmasInGalt
Posts: 526
(@xmasingalt)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I did some testing with the Series 2 and could only get them to work in a point to point configuration. You need to set up the SH/SL and DH/DL of the router and coordinator so the coordinator will only talk to that router. I did that and it works (for the most part). I was using this on a Olsen595/Ren-C configuration and the Olsen would freeze when there were alot of channels going. I attempted to resolve this a number of times (drop the baud rate to 38.4K, change the parity and # of stop bits). I couldn't fix the problem so I went back to the wired configuration for this year. Here is a web link that talks about Series 2 configuration http://www.robotshop.com/forum/showthread.php?614-Xbee-Series-2-Point-to-Point-Duplex-Configuration


Reply
budude
Posts: 10400
(@budude)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

The Series 2 might be able to support DMX - too bad they don't play with the earlier modules...


Reply
Page 19 / 27
Share: