Looking good Mac... Thanks for working on this
ukewarrior wrote:First, I would like to see the board rotated 90 degrees in order to have the terminal blocks on the bottom of the board facing the enclosure openings. There is no rhyme or reason why the mounting holes can't be any two of the mounting studs if that helps with the arrangement.
Second, I am positive the RJ45 connector shell will interfere with the resistor just to the bottom of it. A paper print test fit should verify this.
Third, I would shift the TIL199 to the right a smidge. It's good to plan for the outline of a socket, not just the chip. I think with a socket you would begin to cover the resistor pads to the left of the chip location.
Fourth, If you don't rotate the board and keep the terminal blocks on the right, then I would move the capacitor just below them elsewhere. All of the wires will be bunched up and will pull against that capacitor like its a pole and could very well pull the capacitor out. I suggest moving it to the middle of the board.
Finally, I think you could shift the design to the left and tighten if up, especially if you move the capacitor. Having every smidgen of space in the TA-200 for wire management is worth the board layout work. (This assumes you don't move the terminal blocks.)This is given in the spirit of constructive feedback. Believe me, I know how it is to get group feedback; but my work has always been better as a result.
I do appreciate what you are doing !!! Good work .
I moved things around a bit and it is now setup somewhat like your G2 Neon board, same size and same mounting hole positions.
Some additional observations (I'm more awake this morning).
Traditionally we try and avoid traces beneath the OPTO isolator.
I wanted to mention the reason I had intentionally placed the terminals blocks facing the "side" (versus the 'bottom') of the enclosure. This was so that I could then add the extra hole for a 'strain relief' cable tie. I have always been concerned about boards that have cables going straight down and out, due to the possibility of the cables pulling out.
Just explaining the logic. Take what you like, ignore the rest.
Afterthought - what cable are you going to use with the RJ12 jacks? Is it easily sourced?
D'Oh.. an after/after thought : ground plane should probably not be present in the "upper half" of the board, in order to maintain the isolation.
LabRat wrote:Some additional observations (I'm more awake this morning).Traditionally we try and avoid traces beneath the OPTO isolator.
I wanted to mention the reason I had intentionally placed the terminals blocks facing the "side" (versus the 'bottom') of the enclosure. This was so that I could then add the extra hole for a 'strain relief' cable tie. I have always been concerned about boards that have cables going straight down and out, due to the possibility of the cables pulling out.
Just explaining the logic. Take what you like, ignore the rest.
Afterthought - what cable are you going to use with the RJ12 jacks? Is it easily sourced?
D'Oh.. an after/after thought : ground plane should probably not be present in the "upper half" of the board, in order to maintain the isolation.
I am with Andrew on this.....
LabRat wrote:Traditionally we try and avoid traces beneath the OPTO isolator.
Does that really matter at low dc voltages?
LabRat wrote:ground plane should probably not be present in the "upper half" of the board, in order to maintain the isolation.
From a noise perspective, I would think a ground plane would help?
Ground plane under the MOSFETS.. yes.
Ground plane under the "PC connected" side of the board... yes
Connect the two? That's where I get nervous. I thought of it as trying to handle "when something goes horribly wrong", some type of back surge perhaps a result of a short circuit down stream of the controller. Or perhaps a lightening strike nearby (direct strike? Forget it.. it's all going PFFffffththt).
Have I had it happen? Nope.
Am I just being paranoid? Yes.. probably. But just because you are paranoid does not mean that it can't/won't ever happen. :biggrin:
It's an opinion.. everyone has one. I was simply detailing what went through my mind when I did my layout.
For the sake of completeness other things that went through my mind included: I wonder if there is an SMD version of this part? Why can't the holes be just a bit further over "there"? and .. They will probably make them "red", I wonder if they could do purple?
jklingert wrote:Does that really matter at low dc voltages?From a noise perspective, I would think a ground plane would help?
I don't see the "clapper" interface on the board.
(Looks nice, Mac!)
dirknerkle wrote:I don't see the "clapper" interface on the board.(Looks nice, Mac!)
do mean this :biggrin2: http://www.drugstore.com/popups/largerphoto/default.asp?pid=172425&catid=184264&size=500&trx=29888&trxp1=172425&trxp2=1
I see you referenced a website "www.renard-plus.com"..is this for future use? I could not go to it


