Hi,
Nope - i got your idea the first time, personally i think the firewire is just overkill unless you want to lock people into your propriety protocol... and i don't think that is the case.
Streaming DMX does not need it's own ethernet port on the machine and opens you up to sending data to standard devices from the industry plus some forthcoming hardware in the scene.
It's not the individual channel current that will hurt you when you get into high channel count controllers, it's the total current and pure board space for output connectors.
I already have 120ch controllers for my Megatree this year running standard DMX, essentially in the config you are talking about but as a standard dmx device.
The tree will be at least 876 channels and maybe the full 1752 that it could use.
i have 4200 RGb leds at 24V that will draw close to 40A all on.
Next years plan will see current draws well over 100A at low voltage DC.
Again i love the idea, the decision is yours on direction as it was mine when i did my own hardware, all i'm suggesting is that the standards from the commercial/music lighting world are there because they work and are already supported.
I'm already playing the extreme channel count area... though not as extreme as MPH.
🙂
Cheers
Aussiephil
lol.. extreeeeeeme channels!!!
Well.. in that case i suppose the next step for me is to try and get hold of some hardware and see if i can't get the mac to start talking to it... then i'll look at integrating iTunes into the main software for the music side of things. i've already coded a beat timer that you can tap out your main beat points.. just have to now do something with the code file that it generates.. lol
Don't suppose anyone out there has any old dmx hardware they no longer use? lol 😀
Hi:
First, congratulations on the decision to stop smoking. You will Never regret it, once you get free of them. I quit 30 years ago and have NEVER wanted a smoke since. Keep your head about you and don't give in to the temptation that you can have just one more. Break old habits and form new ones, like reaching for a glass of water when the phone rings, instead of lighting a cigarette. GOOD LUCK.
Second, I have a new 27" iMac and I like the machine very much, but I still like Windows machines. Yes, they do have their problems, but they are much more versatile than the iMac when coming to controlling external devices. This Mac also has Windows 7 running under Parallels 5 with no problems so far, but I am not trying to use it as the controlling device for my blinky-flashy.
That said, I don't want to get into the Mac/Windows argument. Like politics and religion, no one ever wins or changes their mind.
If you want to develop software for the Mac, I think that is great. We could use it. The lack of blinky-flashy software is sadly lacking and if you have the ability and knowledge to do it like K.C. has done, have at it and welcome and thanks.
I have to agree with MPH and Aussiephil, though. Stick with what works. While I have no objection to change, in fact I welcome it, in some cases it is better not to reinvent the wheel.
One thing you might keep in mind while you are developing the interface protocol, is the wireless modules (Renard-W) that Dirknerkle came up with. This is a Cat5 cable substitute and works very well. Development is continuing on this welcome addition to the blinky-flashy world.
I have never used DMX and even though I have looked at it, I don't fully understand it. This upcoming Christmas season will be my second, so I'm a "newbie" too.
Thanks in advance for the offer. There are quite a number of DIYers here who will welcome your efforts with open arms, me included.
If I can help from the electronics end, I will be glad to lend a hand anytime.
AND DON'T REACH FOR THAT CIGARETTE.
I WOULD LOVE A MAC SOLUTION FOR RUNNING MY CHRISTMAS LIGHTS!!!!!
I have been an apple user my whole life (first computer was an Apple IIgs) and I was going to have to use windows under protest to run my show, if I can get it together 😉 I am one of those people whose channel count is going to be pretty high (4,008) and, ignorantly, was planning on using Vixen and the Renard protocol to control it all. But the reality of hand coding all those channels in Vixen really started to bum me out and I got real discouraged. I started reexamining my whole approach to controlling this so I started looking at what the veterans had done already and that's when I stumbled upon MPH's solution he used to control the pixels he had installed on his roof. In hindsight I should have done more research from the get go but I'm kind of thick headed 😀
Anyway, what MPH had, and I hope I get this right!, was a grid of 160 pixels (16 x 10) that he could control with Quartz Composer. From what I have been able to figure out essentially he created a work area where he could move around shapes, graphics, etc. and within this space was a grid that corresponded to each pixel on the roof. Quartz Composer would determine what color was over each grid element and generate the correct channel info and send it via Art-Net to Linux running virtually on the same machine which would translate the Art-Net to DMX and output it over an Enttec Pro. I probably got some of this wrong and MPH could explain it better but it got me really excited again especially with the prospect of potentially being able to run my show from a Mac 🙂
Because of this revelation I started looking at using DMX instead of the Renard protocol to control my LED's. I have been trying to come up with a board that can control 16 rgb leds here and it was really starting to stress me out. But with DMX and moving the PWM for the leds off of the pic and onto another chip it is really starting to come together... I think 😉
If I need to use Quartz Composer to control my lights then I will either need to either find a less expensive Art-Net to DMX node or figure out how MPH did it, either way I would be pretty tough for me. Also, Quartz Composer is not really setup to do sequencing and I believe that MPH was was using Logic Studio to generate MIDI calls to Quartz Composer, but I'm probably wrong again.
Now with your software (OH PLEASE MAKE IT SO!!!) this would be easier and the idea of a Firewire based breakout box, while at first seems like just another protocol, would actually be a pretty cool thing. If, like you said, this unit could connect to your Mac with 1 Firewire cable and then breakout into multiple DMX universes this would be really cool. It would solve a lot of issues (i.e multiple DMX dongles and/or multiple Art-Net nodes). I am planning to try and get Quartz Composer working to control everything this year and then was actually going to start looking into what it would take to make a more robust control program for next year. Both of these are real long shots as I don't have any real Mac programming background and I'm still trying to get the boards finalized.
I don't know what help I could offer but anything that I could do I would be very eager to help! I will be following this thread with much interest I assure you !
cypress1138 wrote:
Now with your software (OH PLEASE MAKE IT SO!!!) this would be easier and the idea of a Firewire based breakout box, while at first seems like just another protocol, would actually be a pretty cool thing. If, like you said, this unit could connect to your Mac with 1 Firewire cable and then breakout into multiple DMX universes this would be really cool. It would solve a lot of issues (i.e multiple DMX dongles and/or multiple Art-Net nodes). I am planning to try and get Quartz Composer working to control everything this year and then was actually going to start looking into what it would take to make a more robust control program for next year. Both of these are real long shots as I don't have any real Mac programming background and I'm still trying to get the boards finalized.
You hit the nail on the head there with the firewire idea cypress.. thanks.. I knew what i meant, but like most programmers in the distance between brain and fingers to describe the concept, it loses complete coherance.. lol
I was thinking of poss making it one firewire input with (hopefully) self powering from the mac, then i'm not sure if it should be just one DMX output socket, or if it should be complete with two sets of DMX-OUT and DMX-IN..
I know with the DMX return to the controller, you have more feedback response from the hardware should it support it.. e.g. you'll be able to tell when you have strings gone or your expensive Mac500 has a pan error or something.. Either that or we could just do multiple dmx outputs from the breakout box.
I know alot of you will be thinking why not use USB-to-DMX as its already on the market.. well i can tell you from experiance in the theatre that although they are pretty good, they do have a limit on the amount of channels they can support due to the overheads of the low level cpu calls. Firewire doesn't have ANY overheads as it uses its own IO interface chip that handles the lot hence why its alot faster and can handle more data. If you're running the firewire in half-duplex full throttle mode, the maths says you should have no problems really running multiple universes and your channel limit is going to be something stupid like 1 million channels or something mad...
I defy anyone to have that many channels at home!! lol
If there's anyone that wants to attempt to design and create a firewire to dmx breakout box.. please please feel free 🙂 i'll get to work on creating a simple DMX control program through firewire to test the theorys out.
If whoever takes up this challenge lets me know how much they have to spend out on parts to make one, i'll sort out helping them out with enough to build a couple to beta test software.
This is starting to get interesting!
*EDIT:*
just found this 1 channel DMX controlled power dimmer kit.. this is the idea i was thinking about for the single nodes on a universe... but instead of handling all that power for anything, we could in theory scale it down for christmas lights and thus make it smaller.. ooo.. here's a thought... if we could get it small enough.. inline dimmer.. just daisy chain the dmx!
http://www.esr.co.uk/velleman/k8039.htm
