Logic Analyzer
 
Notifications
Clear all

Logic Analyzer

32 Posts
9 Users
0 Reactions
16.8 K Views
jeffl
Posts: 250
(@jeffl)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I know it's more money but what about this one?

http://www.pctestinstruments.com/index.htm


Reply
Posts: 844
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
DynamoBen wrote:I ended up going with the Saleae Logic, overall I like the look and feel of the software and the hardware. They are also a start up based in SFO and they are very focused on making the best product they can (read their blog). I suspect over the next year they software is going to get better by leaps and bounds, and I don't have to make any additional purchases. Finally going with the Saleae Logic I was able to apply my SparkFun free day money to the purchase, so it was $40 off the regular price. 🙂

Ben, have you received this yet and had time to play with it? I'm curious as to the ease-of-use of the software (I loaded the ZeroPlus LAP-C s/w and coudn't do much just through intuition. Then I (tried to) read the manual and it got worse. Note that I've not used an LA like this before).

I'm wondering how hard it would be to hack (write) a custom protocol analyzer for the Saleae that understood the proprietary GE ColorEffects single-wire protocol. It sure would be nicer to look at Start & Stop, and Bulb/Intensity/Color values than counting pulses. Of course, if the bit-banging code is bad, chances are the edges are in the wrong place anyway, and the protocol analyzer wouldn't be able to help much. Just thinking, as the GE lights are my personal favorite and the target of my current obsession (as you well know)...


Reply
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
jeffl wrote:I know it's more money but what about this one?

http://www.pctestinstruments.com/index.htm

Someone here does happen to use it - I think jstjohnz? That analyzer was mentioned in one of the recent logic analyzer threads (maybe even this one?)

It depends on if you need the significantly higher samplerate or not.


Reply
Posts: 2630
Topic starter
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Sorry for the delay my email notifications from this forum are a bit sporadic.

ags0000 wrote:Ben, have you received this yet and had time to play with it? I'm curious as to the ease-of-use of the software (I loaded the ZeroPlus LAP-C s/w and coudn't do much just through intuition. Then I (tried to) read the manual and it got worse. Note that I've not used an LA like this before).

Still on back-order, should see it by end of month. I can fill you in more then.

I'm wondering how hard it would be to hack (write) a custom protocol analyzer for the Saleae that understood the proprietary GE ColorEffects single-wire protocol. It sure would be nicer to look at Start & Stop, and Bulb/Intensity/Color values than counting pulses. Of course, if the bit-banging code is bad, chances are the edges are in the wrong place anyway, and the protocol analyzer wouldn't be able to help much. Just thinking, as the GE lights are my personal favorite and the target of my current obsession (as you well know)...

The difficulty of writing an analyzer really depends on your experience. They provide a C++ SDK and this is what they say about how long it would take:

"...implementation of a custom protocol will probably take an experienced c++ developer at least a full day, and possibly up to a week, to complete. You will probably want to have had considerable programming experience, probably significant C++ experience – before taking it on.

That said, you can get away with implementing only a small part of the full capability of the analyzer. For example, you could have only one setting (the input channel(s) to use), you could skip creating simulated data to test against; and not bother providing for data export or tabular display."


Reply
Posts: 844
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
DynamoBen wrote:The difficulty of writing an analyzer really depends on your experience. They provide a C++ SDK and this is what they say about how long it would take:

"...implementation of a custom protocol will probably take an experienced c++ developer at least a full day, and possibly up to a week, to complete. You will probably want to have had considerable programming experience, probably significant C++ experience – before taking it on..."

OK, so I'll wait for you to have the Logic in hand for a day or two - and then you can share your opinions on the unit as well as the new protocol(s) you will have developed by then 🙂


Reply
Page 5 / 7
Share: