Logic Analyzer
 
Notifications
Clear all

Logic Analyzer

32 Posts
9 Users
0 Reactions
16.8 K Views
jeffl
Posts: 250
(@jeffl)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

The Saleae looks like a very nice setup, great GUI and support but what about the speed? It looks like it will run up to 24Mhz which from what I understand will suffice most projects. With some of the newer prjojects around isn't it possible for the chips to start running at faster speeds than 24Mhz?

If the speed works the Saleae product looks like a very good value.


Reply
Posts: 2630
Topic starter
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
jeffl wrote:The Saleae looks like a very nice setup, great GUI and support but what about the speed? It looks like it will run up to 24Mhz which from what I understand will suffice most projects. With some of the newer prjojects around isn't it possible for the chips to start running at faster speeds than 24Mhz?

The speed barrier isn't the device or the software, it's the USB buss. They are doing bulk transfers which speeds things up and increases the amount of data that can be sent, but does have its limits. Bulk transfers also have a lower priority than other data so you have to be sensitive to what is already on the USB buss.

Their response on speed:
"Logic samples each channel at up to 24M times per second. A large fraction of practical, real world applications run at less than 10MHz, and Logic is ideal for these."

I suspect this is the fastest I will be able to go with a USB attached device w/o any fancy logic in between (FPGA or other more intelligent device). Most analyzers I've seen that are faster tend to be a lot more expensive or are a bit too rough around the edges for my tastes. This seems pretty solid, made in the USA, so to me it's worth a try.


Reply
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

That's the big difference between the Saleae and the OLS - The Logic can do continuous sampling, but only at 24 MHz.

The OLS can't do continuous sampling, only triggered sampling, but at 100 MHz in all cases and 200 MHz in certain cases (I believe the difference was internal vs. external clock) Sample depth depends on channel count - I think it's 24k in 8-channel mode. There's an RLE compression function that can greatly extend this - it was broken for quite a while but is fixed in some betas (not in official bitstream releases yet).

Jack Gassett's state analysis in his tutorial at http://www.gadgetfactory.net/blog/?p=337 is a great example of where RLE encoding would have been beneficial - long times in many states followed by brief "flurries" of activity. (Unfortunately it wasn't ready at the time he made that tutorial)


Reply
jeffl
Posts: 250
(@jeffl)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

How does this unit compare? I know it's not just a logic analyzer but a scope as well. I think there also more expensive so you could probably purchase a good scope and logic analyzer for the price of this unit.

http://www.bitscope.com/product/BS120/


Reply
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
jeffl wrote:How does this unit compare? I know it's not just a logic analyzer but a scope as well. I think there also more expensive so you could probably purchase a good scope and logic analyzer for the price of this unit.

http://www.bitscope.com/product/BS120/

Yup. A Rigol DS1052E is $400 and has either 1 GS/s or 2 GS/s sampling rate (I forget which) for one-shot signals.

That only does 40 MS/sec for one-shot signals. (The 1 GS spec is when it repeatedly samples a periodic signal with slightly different clock offsets) - So its sample rate is actually LOWER than its specced analog bandwidth, which simply doesn't work. (General rule of thumb for scopes is that sample rate should be 5-10x the analog bandwidth - the Nyquist limit isn't good enough for seeing good waveform detail.)

Similarly only 40 MS/sec for the logic part - the OLS does 100.

The benefit is that the BitScope could behave as an MSO (both analog and digital at once), but it may be possible to do that by tying the trigger output of an OLS to the trigger input of a scope. Or you spend the extra cash to get the MSO option for the Rigol scope, much more capability for not much more than the price of the BitScope.


Reply
Page 4 / 7
Share: