Logic Analyzer
 
Notifications
Clear all

Logic Analyzer

32 Posts
9 Users
0 Reactions
16.8 K Views
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Odd, my biggest issue with it was how long it took them to release a Linux-based loader. Admittedly Ian does not like Windows, but is committed to Windows support - "I only stick with Windows because the majority of our users are on it and support is a must. I’m ready to jump ship any time, and I do make extensive use of VirtualBox VMs when I can :)"

Similarly, until Jawi took over client development, a bunch of hardcoded fugliness in the serial handling routines of the client made using it on non-Windows machines a massive pain.

In general, Mac/Linux support for the OLS has improved drastically without Windows being negatively impacted in terms of support.


Reply
Posts: 114
(@tabor)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I own the OLS board, but also own a Zeroplus LA.
http://www.zeroplus.com.tw/logic-analyzer_en/

I tend to always grab the ZeroPLus unit when i need one.


Reply
Posts: 844
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Tabor wrote:I own the OLS board, but also own a Zeroplus LA.
http://www.zeroplus.com.tw/logic-analyzer_en/

I tend to always grab the ZeroPLus unit when i need one.

Would you elaborate on why? I've heard that the software is rough. How would you compare it to others?
Have you paid the $100 for additional protocol definitions?

I'm not arguing, I'm just hoping to build on and take full advantage of the experience of others that have used any of these offerings.

Thanks.


Reply
Posts: 844
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

I'm still processing this topic in the background. (I typically have a dozen things I'm "processing" at once.) I've spent some time looking at the ZeroPlus LAP-C. It's available here: http://www.nkcelectronics.com/zeroplus-lap16032u-logic-ana16032.html for $120. It seems (by specs) to be superior to the Saleae Logic ($150, 8 channels, 24MHz).

You can go to the ZeroPlus site and download the software here: http://www.zeroplus.com.tw/logic-analyzer_en/technical_support_search.php?model=LAP-C%2816032%29&class1=1 which will run in demo mode (and also you can read the documentation). The docs are pretty rough IMO, but the s/w doesn't look too bad. I haven't played with any other LA s/w, so I can't offer a first-hand comparison. It looks pretty full-featured. I can't comment on how intuitive it is as I've never owned a LA so don't know what a reasonably-knowledgeable user would be looking for.

I also just saw that a Propeller-based LA is being released: http://forums.parallax.com/showthread.php?129310-Preview-of-the-Propeller-Platform-Logic-Analyzer There's been no pricing information provided yet, but someone has already commented on the OLS board being available for $45 so that's at least a valid reference point. The Prop LA is not in the same league as the LAP-C (or Saleae Logic) as it has only a sample depth of 500 w/8 channels. However, it's designed to piggyback directly on a Prop Dev board so it would be convenient for that use.

Finally, I commented ealier in this thread about the cost of protocol analyzers for the ZeroPlus. That was a big concern for me. It turns out that there is a special going on whereby if you purchase the LAP-C, you'll get 30 protocol analyzers included in the price. I'm about the pull the trigger and just get one. Seems like a pretty good deal, although not a full-featured standalone unit (which would be >$500 I suppose).

I hope this helps.


Reply
Posts: 2630
Topic starter
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I ended up going with the Saleae Logic, overall I like the look and feel of the software and the hardware. They are also a start up based in SFO and they are very focused on making the best product they can (read their blog). I suspect over the next year they software is going to get better by leaps and bounds, and I don't have to make any additional purchases. Finally going with the Saleae Logic I was able to apply my SparkFun free day money to the purchase, so it was $40 off the regular price. 🙂


Reply
Page 3 / 7
Share: