Again, I wasn't criticising your efforts. While self-appointed, I consider myself to be a caretaker for the DIYC NOOB. When I see a valid doable NOOB project, I like to protect it. I just said this is a "muddling" and it very well may not be. But for certain, a simple concept that works great was getting confusing due to the mixing. I never said the mixing or the effort to find "Common Ground" wasn't valid, so you shouldn't take offense.
You are clearly a sharp guy and can figure things out. I couldn't even see the relationship between them until you and Phil pointed it out 🙂 However, your Sharp mind is probably why you couldn't be a member of of my DIYC NOOB Caretaker panel 🙂 The shortcomming of simple projects are just too much for you to take, but these shortcommings are what sometimes make these projects great for a beginner or the less engineering minded folks here. Many of us are happy to trade "Slow Build" for simplicity, easy understanding, and low cost of entry.
So I will yield to y'all and with Corey's permission at some point, I will take all of this and put it together in a Simple Snowfall Tube how-to.
Again, please don't take offense. I certainly didn't intend any.
Kelly
CaptKirk wrote:I understand the FAST concept of being affordable and I completely agree with it and want to have that same option. What I was hoping we could accomplish was not to merge this with the Sawer/DMX discussion, but try to get a design that could use the cheap hand solder if desired (original slow to build FAST design), but also make FAST be able to drive the 7 segement strips that Phil is designing so if some wanted a fast to build FAST, you could combine the FAST logic and mate it to the LEDancer strips. That is the only muddling I am talking about. Sorry that confused things but I thought if both projects that need LED strips could use the SAME PCB for the strips, then that would add an economy of scale and give someone flexibility by just stringing more boards together for a long FAST, or seperate them for more dispersed shorter FASTs, or a Sawyer star with THAT logic. My bad for trying to get some common ground. Seemed like a good idea to me...
No offense taken, I did not realize how confusing I was making this thread so I do appreciate the perspective. Although it may be confusing initially, I think with coordination, the design owners could make this much simpler in the long haul and definitely keep it affordable.
By getting a common wiring scheme between these two projects, in the long run, I think it will make this easier to adapt the common part of the designs to do everything anyone might want.
You (and I) will still be able to hand wire using the ultra cheap DIY path. Phil will be able to make Sawyers and his other mind control devices, I will be able to make shorter snowfall tubes in mass quantity, etc.
Phil cracked the modular LED part (as well as the very cool, ultra addressable logic section). chelmuth cracked the snowfall effect on the cheap but did not have the way to go modular. It looks like to me (and the much smarter chelmuth will need to verify) that by slightly changing his output order, his logic section would be able to drive Phil's LED modules if anyone wanted to do that (like me). While this is still young, if a wiring change is needed for the basic FAST design, we definitely want to make that change early.
Make sense? Or as usual, am I just plain nuts?? Sometimes having a bigger picture view loses the critial details up close...
Kirk
Kelly,
Looking forward to the How to
Cheers
I like this idea and The Minister of War and Finance loves it so I might get the funding to build LOL
djulien wrote:If you step through the LEDs slowly, turning only one and off at a time, does the intended LED come on in addition to the ghosts, and how many/which LEDs are ghosted? (do they have an anode or cathode in common to the intended LED?)Also, do you get ghosting for all of the LEDs in the circuit when turned on one at a time, or only for a few selected LEDs?
If it happens on all LEDs, then that seems to point to either a mismatch of the type of LEDs used, a voltage problem, or some other problem with the overall hardware (or maybe software).
If it only happens for a few selected LEDs, then there is some kind of problem with the those specific LEDs (or it could still be a software problem). If you are seeing pairs of ghost LEDs and the intended LED does not come on, then the connection to the target LED is open or that LED itself is bad. If the target LED does come on but it's dim and another LED(s) come on also, then the target LED is okay but there's a bad connection.
I probably did not explain that too well - here is a diagram:
don
In the 'open joint' situation, you would only get ghosting if the Vf of the LEDs is small (less than 2.5V, or so). If the Vf is greater than that, the power supply voltage (5V) won't be able to forward-bias two LEDs in series. White and blue LEDs should not show ghosting due to opens, other color LEDs might have ghosting due to open solder joints (or reversed/missing diodes).
I just did some testing of the superflux LED's from the group buy and 5v will light 2 LED's in series.. Which is why we are having ghosting.. This goes along with my lack of ghosting when I drove the Circuit with a 3.7v battery. So if we want no ghosting we lower the input voltage. I'm not sure how much Cat5 it would take if the tubes were 50-100ft away from the controller the voltage drop might be enough to stop ghosting. other ideas?
Is there any evidence of an open solder joint or a bad LED (i.e. an LED that never comes on)?
Also, I don't think that 100 feet of cable would help. The resistance of 24 awg wire is around 0.5Ω (200' round-trip), which translates to a 10 mV drop with a 20 mA of current.
No, No open joints or bad LED's everything works as expected just a little bit of ghosting. I'm not concerned about it really as I don't feel it's enough to be noticable. As you can see in my videos you can't even see it I don't believe.
YAY!!! Thanks to P.Short and about 5 minutes worth of talk. I made a change to the Firmware in post #39 and have updated it in that post.. Ghosting is gone. Thanks again Phil you are the Ghost Buster and or PIC Guru..
that cool that you find the problem .... now all i need is a wiki or step by step as i have access to 12 sheet of clear lexan 4x8 1/16 and 1/8 thick and ton of white superflux....all i need is time to do it lol cheer
