Looks like Phil figured out a way to handle segmenting the strip into 7 LED segments here:
To do the effects Phil wants to do it seems like you need each LED to be a channel on DMX where as I would like to trigger the various snowfall effects with fewer DMX channels with your design. DO you think your code and top end could be made compatible with Phil's LED segment board design? That way if one wanted the LEDancer, then you plug in Phils logic section, *OR* if you wanted FAST, you would plug in your logic board but the strip design (and frabrication) would be common?
This would give us increadible flexibility on the design (use a PCB or the lens out of rear projection TV for the LEDs).
I also think it would be great if the LED boards could be done to use the Superflux (4 pin jobbies), OR a 5mm LED for greater flexibility. I for one have a good supply of 5mm bright white LEDs but 0 of the superflux
This thread was for simple and inexpensive PIC-based Snow Tube design. It has now become muttled with much more complicated DMX talk and discussions about modular designs. IMO, the beauty of the design was that anyone with a PIC, LEDS and basic soldering skills could make these. Its a bit of work, but its doable.
I believe they moved the discussions to another thread to avoid polluting this thread with the more complicated DMX and Sawyer Star discussions. Cross-Linking makes it even more complicated.
CaptKirk wrote:Looks like Phil figured out a way to handle segmenting the strip into 7 LED segments here:
![]()
To do the effects Phil wants to do it seems like you need each LED to be a channel on DMX where as I would like to trigger the various snowfall effects with fewer DMX channels with your design. DO you think your code and top end could be made compatible with Phil's LED segment board design? That way if one wanted the LEDancer, then you plug in Phils logic section, *OR* if you wanted FAST, you would plug in your logic board but the strip design (and frabrication) would be common?
This would give us increadible flexibility on the design (use a PCB or the lens out of rear projection TV for the LEDs).
I also think it would be great if the LED boards could be done to use the Superflux (4 pin jobbies), OR a 5mm LED for greater flexibility. I for one have a good supply of 5mm bright white LEDs but 0 of the superflux
kychristmas wrote:
I believe they moved the discussions to another thread to avoid polluting this thread with the more complicated DMX and Sawyer Star discussions.
You're right, that was my intention.
I certainly wasn't directing criticism towards anyone in particular. I just wanted to make sure that we keep Simple ideas SIMPLE. This is a very DOABLE project for a noob. I'm not a noob, but I play one in real life 🙂 I don't want someone to be scared away from at least trying this when they start reading about Modular PCBs, LED Segments and DMX. Albeit very Time-Consuming, its a great Cheap Project that almost anyone can do.
It's not pretty, but my own Prototype of Corey's design turned out great. He was very correct that once I started soldering, the concept of the Charlie Plexed LEDS becomes very clear and I was able to move through it. Now, understanding the code was a different story, but that wasn't necessary. I was able to change the speed to my liking.
My Snow Fall curtain is a much more achievable project at $500 DIY as opposed to $1500 purchased. I still may not be able to swing the $500 this year, but I'm going to start building. Worst case, I hang whatever I can afford to get done from the trees in mine and my neighbors yard.
BTW... Thank you Corey (and BobKeyes)
How big is your curtain going to be? I'm curious to see what other people are thinking.
Depends on the budget I can sneak in, but ideally I'm thinking about 25 columns of two 4ft tubes spread out across 30 to 40 ft. So I guess that would make it roughly 8ft x 40 ft, but I think the top of the curtain ill be like 10-12 ft in the air. As soon as a I come up with a system for building these, I hope to make a couple dozen of them and then play around with configurations. Playing around with spacing and mixing falling speeds and start delays. I know I have $250 in the budget to play with these and that should be enough to test.
My other idea to find a way to hang tubes of different lengths randomly above my display elements. If would be easy if my Big trees were integrated with my display, but so far, I have nothing in my big trees and they are away from my core display. As for now, I'm thinking this style would require some sort of artificial trees to support them. May just create a grid of support wires above the display. I could use it to hang more than the snowfall tubes.
Sounds neat.
I'm thinking of an indoor curtain, against one of the living room walls. I would have the columns closer together, perhaps 2-3" apart. Over a 10' wall this would be about 40 columns. The problem here is going to be making them look nice when viewed from relatively close in a interior, lighted situation.
I understand the FAST concept of being affordable and I completely agree with it and want to have that same option. What I was hoping we could accomplish was not to merge this with the Sawer/DMX discussion, but try to get a design that could use the cheap hand solder if desired (original slow to build FAST design), but also make FAST be able to drive the 7 segement strips that Phil is designing so if some wanted a fast to build FAST, you could combine the FAST logic and mate it to the LEDancer strips. That is the only muddling I am talking about. Sorry that confused things but I thought if both projects that need LED strips could use the SAME PCB for the strips, then that would add an economy of scale and give someone flexibility by just stringing more boards together for a long FAST, or seperate them for more dispersed shorter FASTs, or a Sawyer star with THAT logic. My bad for trying to get some common ground. Seemed like a good idea to me...
Just as a side-note, the ledancer central controller (PIC + RS485 + resistors + transistors) is capable of driving the FAST LED strip with a fairly easy change in firmware. What would be lost is the modularity. This also assumes that the FAST LED strip is separate from the processor board.
I could also recode a version of FAST firmware to work with modular boards if they are made I'll order some and make another firmware..
