Since this is all supposed to be DIY, it might be interesting to discuss other alternatives to DMX. There is time, and I thought that one objective of Macrosill's original post was to come up with a method of reducing cable cost (or more likely reduce the cable mess, since he probably already has the cable).
One thing that I've been working on from time to time is a two-wire scheme for controlling lights. The original context was to reduce the cable cost for a chain of RGB pixels, but I think that this scheme might be useful here. The basic idea is to use an H-bridge arrangement to supply power to the controllers (perhaps 1A total), with the polarity of the power used to indicate a '0' or '1'. The baud rate here would be limited to about 38400, since the typical H-bridge wouldn't be able to switch the line any faster. This 38400 limitation corresponds to about 100 channels, figuring a 50 ms update rate and 10 bits/character. The channel limit imposed by power constraints is about this same number, so this design is fairly balanced. My focus on the pixel design was the very lowest cost using a PIC10F202, but that part won't work here (not enough I/O pins). Although my code could be migrated to a PIC12F683 (selected for the higher built-in oscillator frequency), a PIC16F688 might be a good selection.
The main benefit of this approach is that of cost and simplicity of wiring at the SSR. My guess is that it will cost around $5 for providing power at each SSR ($3 for the transformer plus miscellaneous items, even more if a wall-wart is used instead). There will be additional issues in dealing with the weight and bulk of the power supply, as well as weatherproofing.
Phil there is an architectural lighting standard similar to what you are describing called DALI (Digital Addressable Lighting). Not sure if it’s what you were thinking but is worth a look. This would decrease the cable count, seems to be very robust, and is an open standard.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Addressable_Lighting_Interface
DynamoBen wrote:Phil there is an architectural lighting standard similar to what you are describing called DALI (Digital Addressable Lighting). Not sure if it’s what you were thinking but is worth a look. This would decrease the cable count, seems to be very robust, and is an open standard.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Addressable_Lighting_Interface
DALI is great for some stuff, and its robust like a brick outhouse, but unlikely to cut it for Christmas lighting.. Its only supports 64 channels, and it runs at 1200baud, which means significant delay in transistions.. compare that datarate to DMX which runs at 250kHz..
I moved this thread to the development forum as it has turned to more of a research/comparison thread.
I am leaning towards a DMX controller at this time. This is before I have really looked closely at what is required on a DMX controller vs a Renard controller or cost of either. Currently I am thinking I would like the flexibility of placing controllers anywhere on the wiring network and the ability to add effects machine to the same wiring network, such as scanners and laser.
I am also looking at the 512 channel capacity of DMX, per universe, vs the Renard channel capacities per port based on timing intervals.
I have not looked at component requirements nor costs yet.
Do DMX sequences need to be created utilizing variables of 25ms timing? Such as 25ms, 50ms or 75ms?
Macrosill wrote:Do DMX sequences need to be created utilizing variables of 25ms timing? Such as 25ms, 50ms or 75ms?
No special requirments there, however if you want 25ms timing you will need something like a DMXPro dongle to do it. I think RJs dongle might also fit the bill. I have the OpenDMX and the fastest I go with that is 50ms.
Mmm. i have a opendmx dongle.. attached to my Macbook pro, running parrellels and windows xp, i can drive several hundred channels with no problem at 25ms...
Oh cool, some folks here ran into issues when things ran that fast. Personally I've never needed anything that quick.
RavingLunatic wrote:Why is it that everytime a discussion starts about a new design, DMX gets spoken of as some great leap above Renard? Is it because during these discussions people only think of the communication method and discount everything else?
My concern is software compatibility and nothing else. Just in case DMX4Linux becomes more useful, I'm interested in using the same protocols. I see no reason to break away from vixen, but Id like the future flexibility just in case.
Aside from this, I do not see myself ever buying commercial DMX hardware.
I personally LOVE the renard design however. Its very elegant and cost-effective, so my biggest interest is in controllers that can function with either DMX or the simple serial protocol depending on firmware.
Just my newb 2 cents.
