So with a DMX solution I could utilize up to 1500 linear feet of cable with a max of 32 devices. Each ssr would need its own power supply for the control side of things?
If I run DMX over Cat 5 is it then referred to as ACN or is that a completely different protocol?
A lot of the practicality of this depends on the price, and on how many others are interested in whatever solution comes up here.
The basic control electronics (PIC, RS485 chip, PCB, etc) can be fairly cheap. At this point it appears to me that providing power (and possibly extra isolation, which we haven't mentioned yet) in this fairly rugged environment may end up costing several times more than the digital electronics.
Cost will always be a factor in determining which route we take. But I have found that the cheapest way may be the most desirable but not necessarily the best way to go. At this point I have enough hardware to be where I want to be so in the future I want to work more on a bullet proof durable system than fast and cheap.
I want to go this way so I will continue developing a system with the help of others as I can not do it alone, I lack the knowledge. So if anyone wants to share the ride that would be great.
The benefit of Vixen is that I can change over my current system a little at a time as I can run different protocols off the same machine at the same time. So if the new system hardware is expensive I can swap things out over the course of a few years. I am not stuck in a situation where it is either A or B. It can be both for as long as I need.
Macrosill wrote:If I run DMX over Cat 5 is it then referred to as ACN or is that a completely different protocol?
DMX over Cat 5 isn't ACN. ACN is the data protocol used for lighting control on an Ethernet network. DMX over Cat 5 refers to the cable you use to interconnect your devices. See my sticky for details.
1500' + 32 devices + AC at each location (control board needs low voltage supply)
What you are creating is a dimmer pack. Each location needs power and data. Phil is correct in the fact that this model is a bit more expensive. It is however a more "typical" layout outside of this community and one could argue more flexible.
Why is it that everytime a discussion starts about a new design, DMX gets spoken of as some great leap above Renard? Is it because during these discussions people only think of the communication method and discount everything else?
Renard is more than just the communication protocol (IMO), it is also the basic hardware design and Phil's dimming algorithm. That is how the Renard is a "proven system" in DIYC. Renard based systems can be made to communicate via DMX (even tho Phil is reluctant to say that the firmware is ready).
Also a Renard based system (with current firmware) can be used by someone who doesn't have a DMX dongle til they decide they want to go DMX.
Sorry for the break in the design discussion. Now back on topic....
A self-contained unit powered by 115 VAC could easily be done but it would not meet the original requirement (most likely) of fitting into the same enclosure as your current SSRs.
If that requirement isn't critical, you could do something like a Renard8 (DMX capable, of course) with all on-board power and ZC and then run 2 short CAT5 cables to the nearest of your current SSRs. It would probably be able to fit into a small enclosure or PVC tube.
or if you think will want to add more SSRs next year, then you could do a self-contained Renard4p4. Then you could have 4 SSRs on-board and have the capability of running 1 of your current SSR enclosures via a short CAT5.
There are lots of possibilities that could be done. It boils down to what are the real requirements/goals of the project.
Since Brian isn't looking for an immediate solution, there appears to be plenty of time to bounce ideas around.
Just skimming through this thread I saw RJ post about the SSR4 but what
about Aussiephil's DMX adapter.
http://diylightanimation.com/index.php?topic=338.0
Could this be adapted to suite your needs?
Obviously if its ok with Phil to use his design.
Hey Brian,
If we get a chance, i'd be happy to chat to you about dmx stuff.. But heres some real basics...
(1) Its helpful to compare 'DMX' to Computer networks, in order to understand them a little better.. We probably are all familar with 'IP', its the protocol that 'carrys' information across the internet.. And IP packets are carryed across a variety of systems/protocols, such as ethernet, atm, dsl, modems etc etc.. Those protcols are in turn carryed over a variety of differnet physical systems ( fibre optic, UTP, telephone wires, wifi etc etc.. ).. As a packet transverses the internet it may pass through multiple protocols and systems..
DMX512 can be compared to IP.. It can be carried over a number of transports.. Commonly this is a differential serial system called RS485.. .. In turn the RS485 can be carried on a number of physical transports.. The so called 'standard and proper' way, is on a sheilded two pair cable, that looks like microphone cable. ( but is'nt ), it has low capacitance, with 5 Pin XLR connectors. However in all reality, RS484 works pretty well and reliably being sent down UTP, using RJ45 Jacks.. Its very convienent because network patch cables and UTP are cheap! Hense why lots of diy projects use it.. The theatre 'pureists' say you should'nt do it, but they also work to much much bigger budgets than most of us do!
(2) Have a read about RS485 at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EIA-485 .. It will explain about the multi-drop nature of RS485...
(3) One of the things that has'nt been talked about here, is isolation.. You really really want to keep the 'drive' circuitry of any of your SSR's/Dimmers etc isolated from the rs485 bus, and the thing thats driving it ( your dmx interface/pc ).. Everyone will already be familar with the need to isolate the triacs with opto-isolators..
Again there are lots of 'standards' with isolation, Some of the reasons for them are for safety reasons.. And some for relaiblity.. Isolation is a good way of breaking earth loops.. (a cause of very hard to diagnose problems). In good pro-systems there is two stages of isolation..
-----dmx----> [ device receiver ] --> [ isolation ] ---> [ control electronics ] ---> [isolation] ---> [ drive electronics ]
in many diy and cheap dmx implementations they will dispose of the first set of isolation..
Anyway theres heaps too talk about..
If you used power from the mains side to drive your
"Isolation is a good way of breaking earth loops.."
This isn't an issue with a properly designed DMX device. It is common practice to lift the shield on all DMX receving devices and tie the shield to AC ground on the transmitter.
With that being said I think this discussion is getting into the weeds. Brian if you want detail about the why and how of DMX you will find my wiki entry on the topic help, in addition there is plenty on the topic on the web.
DynamoBen wrote:
With that being said I think this discussion is getting into the weeds. Brian if you want detail about the why and how of DMX you will find my wiki entry on the topic help, in addition there is plenty on the topic on the web.
Hang on.. Are you trying to shut down a thread here? Sure looks like it... If you dont' want to read teh thread thats fine.. don't,, but don't stop or suggesting others top from posting on what was becoming one of the only interesting threads left.
mrpackethead wrote:Hang on.. Are you trying to shut down a thread here? Sure looks like it... If you dont' want to read teh thread thats fine.. don't,, but don't stop or suggesting others top from posting on what was becoming one of the only interesting threads left.
RELAX! I never said I was closing the thread, past history shows thats not how I work. With that being said I want threads to stay on topic for those that started them and those that read them later.
The point of my post was that discussing the why/how of DMX in detail might be more appropriate in its own thread (split the existing thread in two), so this one doesn't end up in the weeds.
BTW as a moderator I am obligated and responsible for reading all threads.
