Hey everyone,
Not trying to start any type of war over cost.
I was simply wondering if anyone had taken a hard look at the whole arena of opto-isolation to see if something either better or cheaper was available.
It never hurts to keep re-examining what we have done in the past.
Again, I too am a fan of the simple series and I love the fact that we are keeping the boards through hole and home etchable!
We don’t make the light strings so there’s not much we can do about the cost. We do however make the controllers, so we can be a little more choosey on what we use to make them with. We can also design them so there’s a little leeway in the exact parts that can be substituted.
Sure it may only reduce the total cost by a couple bucks but a couple bucks here and there can eventually add up. It may also make the difference for a newbie on whether they start or not.
If you can, why wouldn’t you.
I was just looking for a smaller alternative for single strands of lights or just those yard Deco's we all have that only have 35 TO 150 Lights attached to them,, it just seemed to be a waste to eat up a controller with 4 to 6 amps per channel for a single strand of lights. Tyler and I discussed this in detail and we were looking for a SIMPLE solution, no pun intended..:D
Well.... the simplest solution may be to go with one of those $8 DMX controllers.
This is especially true now that there is a DMX 'dongle' for only $20 that uses the FTDI chip. (look at holidaycoro's site.)
The only sad/bad part about that is that they are not DIY.
I looked at the components inside one and I don't think we can come close to duplicating it for that price.
Mactayl wrote:I was just looking for a smaller alternative for single strands of lights or just those yard Deco's we all have that only have 35 TO 150 Lights attached to them,, it just seemed to be a waste to eat up a controller with 4 to 6 amps per channel for a single strand of lights. Tyler and I discussed this in detail and we were looking for a SIMPLE solution, no pun intended..:D
Sorry, didn't mean to start a price war.. Just suggesting... I don't think one additional part substitution would be too much, it looked like the part i suggested could be a drop in replacement for the 3023.
Unfortunately as stated, we don't make the light strands... It's not useful.
As for something to take care of the smaller channels. I've made some lower current SSR's using some perfboard, maybe it's a good idea to look at making a lower cost ssr for small loads with the triacs like Mac was using.
My $.02
chilloutdocdoc wrote:Sorry, didn't mean to start a price war.. Just suggesting... I don't think one additional part substitution would be too much, it looked like the part i suggested could be a drop in replacement for the 3023.Unfortunately as stated, we don't make the light strands... It's not useful.
As for something to take care of the smaller channels. I've made some lower current SSR's using some perfboard, maybe it's a good idea to look at making a lower cost ssr for small loads with the triacs like Mac was using.
My $.02
That is also a very good idea,, low cost SSR's, it wouldn't take much to develop something like that...
I completely agree that any chance we get to lower the cost yet retain the same functionality and quality, it's a good idea to lower the cost. Only makes sense. I was speaking (typing?) from the viewpoint that there usually comes a point when the effort to save a buck winds up costing you more in terms of time and development expense that you reap in savings. I more-or-less tried to infer that but I should have been more clear. For old geezers like me, time is our enemy, and spending it trying to shave off a few cents here and there isn't something I'd want to do.
I'm a real fan of the Simple series -- I think they're really terrific boards and hope the development of the concept continues so that others can avail themselves of its simplicity. However, I don't think a basic Renard is very complex, either, and it's incredibly versatile. The Simple32 is, of course, much smaller overall than a Ren32 with four 16F688's, and its compact size is part of the allure the board enjoys.
This is an incredibly great and robust hobby, isn't it?!?!?! 🙂
ukewarrior wrote:Well.... the simplest solution may be to go with one of those $8 DMX controllers.
This is especially true now that there is a DMX 'dongle' for only $20 that uses the FTDI chip. (look at holidaycoro's site.)
The only sad/bad part about that is that they are not DIY.
I looked at the components inside one and I don't think we can come close to duplicating it for that price.
If you were thinking of these $8 controllers, they are DC controllers, not quite what was being discussed.
One option would be to eliminate the optos on the triacs, and use them on the serial port instead. This does, however, give you a board that is all hot, so you would need to be very careful working on it. If you go that route, I would eliminate the ICSP header, since that too would be hot.
Not sure if it is worth it, especially for the DIY community, but it would cut you down to three optos (2 for the serial, one for zero cross, and that one could probably be replaced with a transistor...)
/mike
I had thought about this idea before, but the 485 chips to my knowledge are not isolated. A proper isolated RS-485 signal requires about 10-15 more components, totaling about $8-10 per board, thereby nullifying the effectiveness of eliminating the cost savings. Also the other thing is, if you don't have an opto, and 120/240V starts feeding back, the ENTIRE board could potentially fry itself, instead of 2 components.
I think our best bet is to continue finding better opto-isolation methods. Maybe there's multichannel opto-isolators that we just haven't found?
