jchuchla wrote:I'm going to try to be delicate. But the bottom line is that someone came along who thought there was room for improvements/expansion in the renard product line. And those people made some assumptions about (at least certain aspects of) the open source/public domain nature of the renard project. When the newer versions were released, large portions of the existing code and documentation were included with those new boards. There was disagreement about whether or not this was ok. I was only on the sidelines of the issue, but from what I could tell, I think it was more an issue of permission/credit than anything else.
Thanks Jon. Maybe I just don't understand open source the way I should, But I do understand feeling like getting your toes stepped on (or worse). Seems like a Waste and a shame everybody can't work together, IMHO.
jchuchla wrote:I'm going to try to be delicate. But the bottom line is that someone came along who thought there was room for improvements/expansion in the renard product line. And those people made some assumptions about (at least certain aspects of) the open source/public domain nature of the renard project. When the newer versions were released, large portions of the existing code and documentation were included with those new boards. There was disagreement about whether or not this was ok. I was only on the sidelines of the issue, but from what I could tell, I think it was more an issue of permission/credit than anything else.
and none of those were what caused the "riff", it was coming into private messages (that no one would see), cussing and making threats. Three warnings were given, and all three were ignored. But of course, no one saw that side, so things were played out as they did, as we stayed quiet.
Wayne J wrote:and none of those were what caused the "riff", it was coming into private messages (that no one would see), cussing and making threats. Three warnings were given, and all three were ignored. But of course, no one saw that side, so things were played out as they did, as we stayed quiet.
I got a few of those just a while Back. I did not report them to Admins so I doubt any warnings were given, and they were on the other site.
Sorry Wayne, that things worked out the way that they did. I did not mean to dredge up old Bad Feelings, or to make light of the situation at the time. It's just a shame people do the things they do then it ends up Badly (it that's a word, lol) for the chance to work together, instead of against each other.
Thanks for the info Guys.
rayhjr wrote:I got a few of those just a while Back. I did not report them to Admins so I doubt any warnings were given, and they were on the other site.
Sorry Wayne, that things worked out the way that they did. I did not mean to dredge up old Bad Feelings, or to make light of the situation at the time. It's just a shame people do the things they do then it ends up Badly (it that's a word, lol) for the chance to work together, instead of against each other.
Thanks for the info Guys.
If you want know what brought along the SS controllers, here is the original release thread. There is a lot of info in it.
http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?6661-Announcing-The-Renard-SS-8-16-24-channel-controllers
P. Short wrote:I was the one who designed the Ren64 board. Another member named wjohn took the gerbers that I provided and had the board fabricated and ran coops for the board (or outright sold it, I don't remember which). He also did some riffs on the SSR design. I haven't seen him around on this site for quite a while, it looks like his last login was six years ago.
Phil,
I still have 3x Ren64's. It was the 3rd board I bought, after a Kit74 and a 24SS. I love the Ren64 controllers and still use at least one every year. Thank you for bringing it to the community.
-Tony
