Need help picking a...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Need help picking a controller

39 Posts
18 Users
0 Reactions
13.4 K Views
Posts: 486
(@uncledan)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
dmoore wrote:There is a good reason why it lands at around 5 amps - that is about as much power as can be pushed down a string of lights before power injection is required. Plus, at $99 for a 16 channel unit, that is hard to beat.

A 16 channel unit for $99.00 is $6.18 a channel, F16v2 is less than $.01 a channel. That's pretty easy to beat! Assuming you meant 16 outputs not 16 channels... For twice the cost of a refurbished Alphapix16 you can get a new F16v2 capable of twice the pixels. Same cost per pixel for new product with more features. That's hard to beat!


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

I wouldn't go strictly by price. Even if the Falcon is more I would still by it over anything out there, even if HolidayCoro does release something close to it. You will get better support from David Pitts. Also, any changes, enhancements, etc are done by David Pitts himself. HolidayCoro will not be able to do that in house. Just look at how long firmware releases took on the alphapix.

In the end, you have lots of choices. My advice, don't allow price to be the driving factor. You almost always get what you pay for.

James

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 136
Topic starter
(@blk69)
Estimable Member
Joined: 10 years ago
uncledan wrote:A 16 channel unit for $99.00 is $6.18 a channel, F16v2 is less than $.01 a channel. That's pretty easy to beat! Assuming you meant 16 outputs not 16 channels... For twice the cost of a refurbished Alphapix16 you can get a new F16v2 capable of twice the pixels. Same cost per pixel for new product with more features. That's hard to beat!

Question: isn't your sequence software that is driving the controller? This is the part I would think you want as easy and user friendly as possible? What am I missing.

Question: believe reference to new alphapix is it will contain basically a Ras Pi on the controller, which is good. If controller price increase in line with cost of a Pi sounds fantastic.

Question: what's wrong with power injection? Can't you just lash a #14 conductor (dc power) to your control cable and tap off when ever needed. In looking at everyone controller spec's can control twice as many pixels with injection. Again am I missing something.


Reply
sporadic
Posts: 1199
(@sporadic)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Phrog30 wrote:I wouldn't go strictly by price. Even if the Falcon is more I would still by it over anything out there, even if HolidayCoro does release something close to it. You will get better support from David Pitts. Also, any changes, enhancements, etc are done by David Pitts himself. HolidayCoro will not be able to do that in house. Just look at how long firmware releases took on the alphapix.

In the end, you have lots of choices. My advice, don't allow price to be the driving factor. You almost always get what you pay for.

James

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

This. Plus you'd be buying from someone who supports open source development and has contributed greatly to the community. I don't have a need for a high density controller, but if I did, I'd either roll my own or pick up a Falcon F16.


Reply
RobG
Posts: 1255
 RobG
(@robg)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago

Up until now, I was using my home grown controller, but I want to do something much bigger this year, so I have decided to get one of the ready made controllers.
After looking at the comparison chart, Falcon F16 looks like a winner to me and that's what I will buy.


Reply
Page 4 / 8
Share: