beeiilll wrote:Gee, probably because I have seen people pry off the tie bar on two pole breakers all too many times and wonder why they had to pay me to explain that it was there for a reason! Or the homeowner who hooked up a 220 circuit using two non-adjacent breakers for a heater (wonder why he is still alive after that one actually).
Of course, my outdated training has caused me to not realize how many homeowners out there work on the incoming electrical service prior to the meter can! But I guess you think that is common eh?
I guess Ernie and I will just never be as wonderfully smart as you are but I will still work to keep people safe from bad advice that seems to come easily to others.
Prying off a tie breaker - you are just trying to protect stupidity. Should you need to take away ALL the 240V circuits too?
What would you do if you found the circuit installed, permitted and inspected in a rework you are doing - remove it?
rlemery wrote:I had a problem with a shared neutral set-up a while back. I was changing out a fluorescent light fixture in my garage. I turned off the breaker and started taking the fixture off the ceiling. The next thing you know I was knocked off the latter. Now when I do anything in the garage I turn off the main. I Talked to a friend of mine who is a local inspector and was told that the wiring met local code.As for my Christmas power I have ran 2, 50 amp circuits to my pumphouse and installed 2, 50 amp camper outlets. I then have temporary subpanels that have outdoor rated breaker boxes that feed 4 circuits each with gfi.
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
rlemery, I don't think you need to go back to the main.....for me that is over kill, but a voltmeter tells the store. When not working hot, I voltmeter test every lead to everything......but I also test a live receptacle first to make sure my voltmeter is working.
Sub-panels, temporary or permanent, they are the best, provide you have the space to install it properly.
Normally I double check everything with a volt meter. That was my mistake assuming that the line had no power after turning off the bresker. I've been working with and around industrial power for over 40 years.
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
rlemery wrote:Normally I double check everything with a volt meter. That was my mistake assuming that the line had no power after turning off the bresker. I've been working with and around industrial power for over 40 years.Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
Another good reason why we "usually" don't recommend shared neutral setups in RESIDENTIAL wiring!
mrGrumpy wrote:Prying off a tie breaker - you are just trying to protect stupidity. Should you need to take away ALL the 240V circuits too?
What would you do if you found the circuit installed, permitted and inspected in a rework you are doing - remove it?
Well sorry, but I have seen tie bars removed by people who "thought" that they could get more breakers in a tiny service box by doing so rather than call an electrician and/or install a bigger panel box or sub panel. Even had a guy who did it, took the two wires (the hot leads) off the screws, twist the two hot leads together and then reinstall the wires under one screw! His "thinking" was that since there were two wires, then each one should still have 110 each so that it would end up as 220 out at the appliance and he gained another breaker and circuit to use!
It certainly takes all kinds to do some pretty amazing things and still be around to tell the tale although most of them won't repeat what they did or what I told them I'm sure.
I still work on some very old houses at great camps that have knob and tube wiring in them! Pretty hard to tell people how bad that bill can be when they are trying to use coffee makers, microwaves, and the likes in a house that has 4 or 6 - 20 amp screw in fuses in a box that is as old as I am or older. But these are historic old houses and exempt from some things. Most people will consent to do small upgrades over time as they rework the homes which is allowed but some of these homes are in a constant state of remodeling while working to maintain the historical value.
I have refused jobs that people want to be done illegally before and I may not remove an illegal circuit but I will inform my inspector about it as well as the other two people around here who do electrical work! There is only so much one can do if a homeowner wants to live dangerously but I am not going to encourage it or bend the rules I go by for them if it is a hazard. I would remove any circuit that is a hazard though and explain why I did it. Most homeowners are not that bad to deal with and will accept a change if it is a hazard.
