WS2811 node durabil...
 
Notifications
Clear all

WS2811 node durability?

16 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
6,435 Views
Posts: 486
(@uncledan)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
pjones wrote:Who do you get yours from? And what type are you using (bullet, strip, etc )?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

All my square and bullet nodes came from ScottLED. Strip I avoid...


Reply
Posts: 259
(@cmschleich)
Reputable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
jeffl wrote:What is the durability of the nodes as of late? The batch I have was from 2015 and after you get done replacing 10% of them they seam ok. Id like to use more but I don't want to be replacing pixels when its snowing and cold and 20' off the ground.

Thanks

I bought 1200 or so in 2016, probably replaced 5 or 6. None in 2019 thankfully. Most cases for bullets were green LED fails, one or two C9 fails. A majority of mine are Ray Wu sourced, some Holiday Coro, which I am under the impression, but not hard confirmed, are ultimately Ray Wu sourced. I bought a few 50 and 100 stands from Holiday Coro and don't believe I've had to replace any of those. In 2016 I bought ribbon, from Ray Wu, quite flimsy. I bought ribbon from Holiday Coro this year and it was solid, I still fear ribbon some though. If I did it all over again I would go strictly Holiday Coro, he clearly has done background work defining specs and working out quality procedures with his source. Lots of cool labeling and wire marking that makes it harder to make dumb mistakes, 18awg standard. Much easier to find products and confirm specs also. Every extra $ is time saved. Drives me nuts to trying to shop Alibaba product picture mismatches, listed specs in conflict with one another, unclear pinouts if there are pinouts, erroneous documents, store pages with no functional organization, etc.


Reply
Posts: 401
(@kensington)
Reputable Member
Joined: 11 years ago

Neither Ray, nor Paul, nor Holiday Coro, nor ScottLED, nor DIYLedExpress is going to the factory where they dope up the wafer with gallium nitride and phosphide compounds and are insisting on some special process to increase reliability for their products. Nor are they telling Worldsemi to do something special for them with the WS2811 chip to make them more reliable. Nor are they able to influence quality control at the factories which, incidentally, do not inspect every chip or LED that comes off the production line. They take a sample at random from every batch and, based on a statistical function, determine that a certain percentage of the batch is defect-free. They’re likely all buying from the same primary sources, and even if they’re not, they’re all subject to the same component quality control problem. They have zero control over component reliability, and on average, those components will fail at similar rates.

IES TM-26 provides guidance on estimating LED life and reliability, and it measures thousands of failures per billion operating hours. So the 50,000/35,000 figures advertised are estimated mean times before failure based on a statistical model that may not reflect personal experience. Likewise, estimated failure rates we post are anecdotes, not data. I lost two LEDs this year from an order of 2,000 last year, and noticed a couple more not lighting from an order 4 made years ago. But stating definitively that failures predictably occur is a bit like claiming that you never lose in Vegas—in the short term an individual may have winning streaks, but the numbers catch up to someone.

That said, I’ve seen some statements that “industry standard” failure rates are as high as 3% for LEDs alone. That’s a pretty low failure rate when you consider that developing the process to make a blue LED was worthy of a Nobel Prize, and the process starts with growing crystals and proceeds through doping and etching and other steps at which failures can occur.

Where our suppliers can distinguish themselves is wiring and waterproofing and warranty.


Reply
Posts: 2507
(@mrgrumpy)
Famed Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Kensington wrote:Neither Ray, nor Paul, nor Holiday Coro, nor ScottLED, nor DIYLedExpress is going to ………………………...

Where our suppliers can distinguish themselves is wiring and waterproofing and warranty.

No! Where our suppliers can distinguish themselves is by suppling top quality and the product they advertise. Pixels don't all come from the same pot, and the supplier need to know the good factories that are the honest manufacturers.
Don't give me IP61 when I ordered IP67. Don't send me 20 AWG or even 22 AWG when I ordered 18 AWG. Don't send me seconds when I'm paying for top quality, and don't send me PUYA chips that will disrupt the pixel business like it did to the ESP. Know your supplier.

Kensington wrote:That said, I’ve seen some statements that “industry standard” failure rates are as high as 3% for LEDs alone

If I get a 3% failure rate from my supplier, I would demand a full credit return, and work with them to get the right product, or purchase elsewhere. I'm been fortunate with 0% failure of my bullet pixels, and in my book; anything above 0.1% failure rate is too high


Reply
Posts: 188
(@harpster)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

Being around electronic manufacturing for a long time and spending a lot of time in Asia factories that make “electronics stuff” I would be kinda surprised if there wasn’t an end of line test to (at least at a minimum) light up each strand. It’s hard to buy that all these Pixel strands are shipped on a random sample test only.


Reply
Page 3 / 4
Share: