Which Pixel Control...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Which Pixel Controller is Best?

41 Posts
25 Users
0 Reactions
21.4 K Views
codec101
Posts: 355
(@codec101)
Reputable Member
Joined: 13 years ago

I have only used the Sans Devices E682. One reason is SanDevices is right here in Carmel, IN which is only 2 hrs south of me.


Reply
smeighan
Posts: 2595
(@smeighan)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago
RGB_Mixer wrote:Hi - saw some good info. For what it is worth, I offer my two cents.

I am an electrician, still working, 25+ years with a heavy electronics background in controls and designs. Designed and built many control panels for - well - anything that needs one.

I have two SanDevices controllers. A E682 and a E6804. I also have a Advatek Pixlite 16. I have my own application for long distance props - TTL to RS485 senders and receivers that are optically isolated >2.5kv and use an on-board isolated power supply - super low chance of anything going sideways.

I use SanDevices for my GE Color Effects lights - no one else supports these pixels. I have had several mishaps with both the E682 and E6804 controllers. These have all been testing errors on my part. However, both the controllers have survived - these are more like a Sherman Tank in respect.

All the controllers support all sorts of pixels - my choice is WS2811/12/13 series as they are inexpensive and rather reliable (3 years and going strong). Sure, there are always pros and cons - so I choose what will work for me. All three controllers can act as a DMX bridge - however the Pixlite 16 handles 32 universes plus 4 more universes (1 for each DMX output). I have maxed out all three boards and have not noticed any notable degradation in performance.

I had problems with a Pixlite 16 - the support was fantastic. Both products have always provided excellent support.

The one post I noted was the use of DC-DC converters with a high output 24v supply. Albeit this is a good choice for long distance power distribution (I use them too) many are not electrically isolated. Something to keep in mind. Usually the negative is common to both in and out. There are some that are truly isolated - the cost is higher and the supplier usually states 'isolated' too.

I cannot speak on other controllers as I have not had practical hands-on experience with them.

Good Luck & Happy Holidays, 🙂

I see that the falcon controllers support the ge color lights
http://nutcracker123.com/nutcracker/rgb_controllers/


Reply
Posts: 6
(@discorover0)
Active Member
Joined: 12 years ago

I'm running 4 teensyLc's (12.00 each) in vixen lights 3. I'm controlling 7300 rgb ws2811's strips on generic serial from 4 usb ports of single computer. The limitations seem to be 2400 leds per controller in vixen. I run adafruit interface very light weight from the arduino Ide at a port speed of 921600 baud. this is very easy and cheep. I have no idea what total limitations, generic serial controllers are. I do have a single problem that is related to vixen generic serial, one of my ports will disconnect during the day before next show starts. I have to go to the configuration and reassign the port to the controller restart vixen and I have no more problems for the rest of the show night. If anyone has any ideas to fix this I'm all ears. This is only a minor issue.


Reply
Posts: 259
(@cmschleich)
Reputable Member
Joined: 11 years ago

The other thing some of these posts remind me of is standardization and low maintenance. Flexibility is key for people who have a built up collection of lights over years in the hobby which from what I can tell has evolved rather rapidly. I'm year 1, and have some background in industrial automation that sort of translates into the philosophy I've applied to my selections. I wanted to minimize integration work, thus variations, and reduce maintenance of existing functions. As a year 1 person, with fantastic controller options in front of me, no history or legacy light collections, and an expert community established already, I had the benefit of standardizing my lights from the get go (WS2811). This made the flexibility options between the controllers less important.

With that said the Falcon can do so many things that I can't possibly see myself getting stuck as I add new pieces or get creative. Maybe I'll even do some motor control one day and I think the board offers enough communication options to allow me to skin that cat a few different ways. In addition I found zero bugs (within my basic application of 13 directly connnected WS2811 strings) to add to the to-do list with my Falcons, that was not my experience with my E682. There is more tinkering that has to be done to implement the E682, if one enjoys that more, or has a longer history with less reliable controllers, or less sensitivity to user interface nuances, it will not seem like a noteworthy difference. I think that shapes the various opinions.


Reply
jem5136
Posts: 306
Topic starter
(@jem5136)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
deonb wrote:What is the criteria then? I cannot imagine any criteria that would exclude Lynx but include SanDevices or Falcon.

I assume they're concerned about liability, but they're not going to be able to pass any kind of liability that matters (i.e. electrocution) over to SanDevices or Falcon either, since the high voltage connections happens outside of the board.

Not that I'm a specific fan of Lynx, but what quality does it posses that excludes it from consideration?

I cannot say for 100% certainty, but I do believe is has to do with liability. Back in 2011/2012 (when I was using Lynx controllers in my display), I was thinking about moving the display to my church and I had asked a question on the forum and I basically, for lack of better terms, I got thrown up on with all this "you don't do this, you can't do that" BS. I wasn't a huge fan of being told I couldn't move my display to my church, thus one of the reasons I don't use Lynx much anymore.

Gilrock wrote:I have my favorites controllers but instead of talking about that I can't help but wonder as I read the initial post what were all the issues you had with the PixCon16? I thought that card was the same as a Pixlite16 and even though I might like a Falcon better I wouldn't say what you had was a bad card. Without knowing what was really going on you may have the same problems with any controller you choose.

If all it was is a bad card, then I've had about 10 of them! I have had nothing but issues from day 1. Everything from setting the controller up (the software not seeing the controller, but the controller saying it is connected correctly), to ports simply not working (some because of blown fuses, others for reasons I'm still not sure of), to the boards just not turning on every time (like a bad logic fuse, but that not being the issue because the board does turn on sometimes), and most recently I have two board that are running my mega tree that both stopped working the same night with the same issue. LOR usually doesn't give me much help, they try to say something like "well if you would have bought more of our products..." or "I wrote the software, so I know what is happening to the board and you don't"


Reply
Page 6 / 9
Share: