Technicolor quality...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Technicolor quality?

256 Posts
45 Users
0 Reactions
83.4 K Views
Posts: 214
(@gary-martin)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Okay, the other local lighting nut dropped by some of his melted Technicolor pixels. The melted section appears to be *wiring insulation* where the wires enter the pixel base. I noticed one big issue right off. I know Zach was told that the wire being used was "as good as" 18 gauge because it was highly stranded or some other nonsense. Surface area is surface area though and this is a very thin wire even for 20 gauge.

That's not the big issue though. THIS IS ALUMINUM!!!!! Now aluminum wire, as you know, already has almost 60% MORE wire resistance than copper comparing exact size and strand equally. On top of that aluminum wire has a bad issue in that it very quickly oxidizes, thereby adding a very large additional resistance to surface power conductivity. Aluminum also has a property in that it tends to shrink/expand from cold/heat far more than copper. That is a big enough issue with using it in high power situations that connectors get loose so they have to use spring loaded connectors to prevent that.

So for version 2 of these pixels, you've got to get them moved over to copper wire and please, go with 18 gauge so the wire doesn't heat up enough to melt the insulation off it. Yes, it's going to raise the price of them. IMHO it's needed to make them work for more than just a little bit.

I need a mailing address to send these burnt wire TC v1s to. Who was doing the post mortem again?


Reply
Posts: 23
(@steve-gase)
Eminent Member
Joined: 15 years ago

How does green affect UV properties -- as advertised with the original BLACK TC nodes?


Reply
jlowe
Posts: 952
(@jlowe)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Gary Martin wrote:Okay, the other local lighting nut dropped by some of his melted Technicolor pixels. The melted section appears to be *wiring insulation* where the wires enter the pixel base. I noticed one big issue right off. I know Zach was told that the wire being used was "as good as" 18 gauge because it was highly stranded or some other nonsense. Surface area is surface area though and this is a very thin wire even for 20 gauge.

That's not the big issue though. THIS IS ALUMINUM!!!!! Now aluminum wire, as you know, already has almost 60% MORE wire resistance than copper comparing exact size and strand equally. On top of that aluminum wire has a bad issue in that it very quickly oxidizes, thereby adding a very large additional resistance to surface power conductivity. Aluminum also has a property in that it tends to shrink/expand from cold/heat far more than copper. That is a big enough issue with using it in high power situations that connectors get loose so they have to use spring loaded connectors to prevent that.

So for version 2 of these pixels, you've got to get them moved over to copper wire and please, go with 18 gauge so the wire doesn't heat up enough to melt the insulation off it. Yes, it's going to raise the price of them. IMHO it's needed to make them work for more than just a little bit.

I need a mailing address to send these burnt wire TC v1s to. Who was doing the post mortem again?

If these are wired with aluminum, and knowing not only the history of aluminum wiring, but the fact that these are used outdoors..... that is a pretty serious issue. Plus, as you mention, the resistance issue with aluminum. The general rule of thumb would be to go two sizes larger when using aluminum when compared to copper. So, if 18 gauge wire was needed in copper, aluminum would have to be 16. But it would be a horrible choice for wiring in general.


Reply
Posts: 1076
 Zeph
(@zeph)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Gary Martin wrote: this is a very thin wire even for 20 gauge.

That's not the big issue though. THIS IS ALUMINUM!!!!!

That would be a show stopper if confirmed for other TC's.

Did you find the wires to be CCA? (Copper Clad Aluminum) or pure aluminum? CCA is easier to work with than pure Aluminum, but is still a poor substitute for copper.

(I can imagine Timon burning up the phone wires to check this out with Ray!)

Small corrective - I think it's the cross section that matters rather then the surface area (at 120VAC 60 Hz anyway), and so I agree that being "highly stranded" would not matter to current capacity, only to flexibility. I think AL is less ductile than CO as well, so there could be mechanical issues with a lot of bending.


Reply
Posts: 853
(@roterhead)
Prominent Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Have to be careful about current flows in the DC vs AC world.

AC flows only in the outer circumference of a wire (called skin effect), something to do with actual electron flow and migration. In very high frequency systems hollow tubes (waveguides) are used as current is only flowing in the skin of the conductor.

DC flows throughout the conductor thus cross section area needs to be looked at.


Reply
Posts: 352
(@pmscientist)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago

From my experience w/pixels in general, not just those from Ray, this is a valid question. I don't have any TC pixels, but the strings I've taken apart have all been a mixture of copper and aluminum.

I've noticed that copper wire is always used on the ends, while the wire in the middle varies. It hasn't bothered me so far from an operational perspective, but it does make me suspicious. All in all, I find them fine for personal use, but some assurance that copper was used end to end is a good thing.


Reply
Posts: 95
(@danolgb)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Gary Martin wrote:That's not the big issue though. THIS IS ALUMINUM!!!!!

How did you determine it was aluminum and not tinned copper? It's quite common to see wire of this gauge to be tinned copper, but I don't think I've ever encountered aluminum wiring for electronics.


Reply
Posts: 13
(@gavspac)
Eminent Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Here are a couple of pictures of the boards in the new and old technicolor pixels.

The smaller one, the old one, had failed but the larger one is unused.

The reason it looks so knackered is because I damaged it when getting it out of the molding!

pixel1
pixel2

Reply
Posts: 214
(@gary-martin)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Yeah, it's not CCA, it's just plain old aluminum. Cheapest wire available.


Reply
Posts: 214
(@gary-martin)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Dan, I'll get some pics up after this weekend. My determination was as follows: The wire is silver, not a bright, shiny silver but a dull (oxidized) silver color. Examining the ends of a freshly cut piece do not show any indication of copper in there at all. Also, I've done a lot of marine wiring in the past. Pre-tinned, stranded copper wire is typically almost twice as expensive as just plain copper.

Which do you think is a more logical assumption considering they were made in China:

1. They used the most expensive 20 gauge wire available. or 2. They used the cheapest 20 gauge wire available. 😉


Reply
Page 19 / 26
Share: