Just so everyone knows. I received and email from Zach this morning. It appears that Ray is going to replace all of my nodes with nodes that I CAN use. I want it to be clear that I have not been in contact with Ray myself, Zach has done all of the communication. I have not received any shipping notice or know when I will get the replacements, but if all goes as stated I will be satisfied. Time will tell, but I am at least very hopeful at this point!
Roger
Good to hear Roger, keep us posted!
Although I am not as knowledgeable as most people on here I am learning I go. I want to say Thank you to everyone that has attempted to help me solve my issues. I tried to keep it behind the scenes because I did not want it to go negative! I sent Gary a pm and he did his best to help me figure this out and I want to thank Gary for his time! I did not know any history with Zach and Gary and I am sorry that I brought bad feelings back to the surface as that was NOT my intent. I just wanted my lights to work! Anyway Thanks again for the help! I am sure that everyone will be hearing more from me!
Roger
I talked to Ray on and off for about two hours last night. Roger, your pixels were discussed during the conversation. Ray told me he was replacing a lot of pixels.
I suppect, although you should verify, you'll be getting ones based on the WS2811. If you want them for this season I'm guessing you'll get the current production PCB. If you don't then you'll likely get the updated PCB. I'll double check that when I talk to Ray tonight as he may be able to turn the new PCB around faster than I think he can. If he can get boards turned around in a day you may get the revised one.
Before we get into the WS2811 version let's talk about the TM1804. If you got your Technicolor pixels on the group buy you have the TM1804 version. If not and you bought yours up to about Sept you may have the TM1804s. Ray has had a lot of problems with the TM1804's and he's going to be replacing them. I supect all of the replacements will be the WS2811 version which don't have the high failure rate. Knowing how many are out there it's costing Ray a fair number of bucks but he's wanting to do right by his customers.
About the WS2811 version. First the good news. During the design Ray did 48 hour burnins of multiple strings and never had a failure so the design is fairly solid. The failure rate on the WS2811 version has not been that high although there have been failures so this tends to confirm is a better design. However there have been failures and Ray and I suppect the regulator might be an issue so we're going to be running some extensive temperature tests using a probe that will be attached to the regulator and then molded. This way we can measure the temperature when running in a fully encased pixel. We'll be running the same test before molding with the same pixel so we have a reference. Once we've done this we'll know what the operational temperature is inside the case. In the mean time I'm working on a way to get better heat removal should that be required.
In addition I identified two other possible issues but neither of them should be the cause of hard failures although one of the issues may cause a problem when the data line gets on the longer side. Ray is going to make these changes ASAP just to be on the safe side. Hopefully these will go into production quickly.
Moisture issues. Ray and I talked about this. I ask about the conformal coating, although it's not the first line of defense, and conformal coating is to be done. However, I don't think the TM1804 got conformal coated, need to go back and check my notes.
The WS2811 were being conformal coated but Ray went back and talked to his Production Manager about them. I don't think Ray liked the answer he got and I think the Production Manager is in trouble. With things got very busy it looks like the conformal coating may not have been done. This does not mean that the pixels are leaking just that they don't have the second line of defense.
We're also talked about a completely new PCB design that uses a new part that we hope World Semi is releasing shortly. This is a 8mm RGB LED with a built in WS2811. This will be much like the WS2812B and hopefully just as bright. Ray will be asking World Semi when we can get them in production quantities. This will still need the regulator since it's a 5V part but well have more board area for it to transfer heat too.
I know there is something missing so I'll go back and check my Skype log.
So we're on this.
Now back to getting my display up.
rdebolt wrote:Just so everyone knows. I received and email from Zach this morning. It appears that Ray is going to replace all of my nodes with nodes that I CAN use. I want it to be clear that I have not been in contact with Ray myself, Zach has done all of the communication. I have not received any shipping notice or know when I will get the replacements, but if all goes as stated I will be satisfied. Time will tell, but I am at least very hopeful at this point!
Roger
Thanks for the extensive report, Timon.
There was one part I was uncertain about, tho.
"This is a 8mm RGB LED with a built in WS2811. This will be much like the WS2812B and hopefully just as bright."
I'm not understanding why we would expect an 8mm pixel with 2811 controller integrated with the LED would be any brighter than an 8mm pixel with separate 2811 IC (both at the same voltage of course).
I am aware of two main ways to make a single-LED-per-color pixel "brighter". (1) You can get more total light output by putting more current through it (eg: most 5v pixels run 48, 55, or 60ma while most 12v pixels seem to run around 30ma, so the former may put out more light). For 12V pixels the current limit is probably going to be power dissipation, and I'm guessing that an 8mm straw hat is not going to have better dissipation than an 8mm straw hat plus a SMD LED on a PCB - perhaps less.
(2) Or you can focus the light into a smaller region; for the same total light output, a 5050 form factor LED will likely be visually brighter head on (and less bright from the side) compared to an 8mm LED. But we are talking about 8mm vs 8mm here.
And I'm guessing from outside, not in touch with the production designs at the level you are. Is there another factor I'm not considering?
