There are a lot of discussions around power requirements. The specs on most pixels are about 50ma - 60ma on full white. I decided to take some measurements of the current draw for the 12 VDC pixels and the current draw of the power supply at the same time. I have some from DIYLED Express and some from Ray Wu.
Just thought I would share what I measured. I used a Fluke 29 meter.
Do you notice any difference in brightness between the two vendors? Just curious if the higher current draw from rays pixels are justified.
yes they seemed a little brighter.
Well done. Pretty much confirms RGB currents are about the same for most pixels. Due to the differences in effeciency, this would explain why white has such a high color temperature like Cool White.
It may also be possible that Ray Wu uses .75mm2 wire and DIYLE uses .50mm2 wire.
Both are advertised as being "18awg" but in reality they are somewhere between 18awg-20awg, with the .75mm2 wire being thicker, it will have slightly less resistance allowing slightly higher current.
I have not been able to find wire size markings on my pixel strings, but I have seen pigtails from both vendors with markings that show one is .75mm2 and another is .50mm2
The data on the low voltage side is good info. Something left out are actual test conditions. Was the voltage measured at the first pixel or did you have wire leads? If leads, what length and size? Not picking this apart, just trying to fill in the technical information gaps.
The current draw on the AC side is really not relevant. Different supplies will have different current draws on the primary for both the Qcurrent and efficiency of conversion. When you get up into the 10s or 100s of amps on primaries it is relevant.. but not with something like this. If you reference your power supply make and model, then it might be relevant to others that have the same, but generically not so much.
plasmadrive wrote:The data on the low voltage side is good info. Something left out are actual test conditions. Was the voltage measured at the first pixel or did you have wire leads? If leads, what length and size? Not picking this apart, just trying to fill in the technical information gaps.The current draw on the AC side is really not relevant. Different supplies will have different current draws on the primary for both the Qcurrent and efficiency of conversion. When you get up into the 10s or 100s of amps on primaries it is relevant.. but not with something like this. If you reference your power supply make and model, then it might be relevant to others that have the same, but generically not so much.
I'm not seeing where any voltage was measured, only current draw.
Since most use similar power supplies I think the AC load is good info to post. It will show what to expect. He probably could have posted what power supply he used. It definitely can't hurt to include the info.
I like and appreciate this post.
Phrog30 wrote:I'm not seeing where any voltage was measured, only current draw.Since most use similar power supplies I think the AC load is good info to post. It will show what to expect. He probably could have posted what power supply he used. It definitely can't hurt to include the info.
I like and appreciate this post.
I believe he said they are 12v pixels. So my question was where did the 12v get measured if it even got measured? When doing a comparison it is always good to have a reference. If for example he used 20' of #18 wire lead from the power supply to the first pixel and the 12v was at the power supply, what was the voltage at the first pixel? If he connected them directly to the supply without an extension, then it is less relevant. (don't know.. he didn't say) Since Ray's drew more current than the others voltage drop might be significant.. or it might not. Don't know.. not enough information (which is what I am getting at)
With the cheaper Chinese power supplies, the Qcurrent (standby) can vary a lot on the input side, so can the conversion efficiency. That is why I say it is not really relevant without the model number. Could actually be double this amount on a given supply because the numbers are so low. Most of you don't use more than a couple of supplies on a single circuit anyway, so again, probably not that important in the scheme of things, but good to have if referenced.
I like the post also.. but would be nice to get the missing information. I am guessing he has it and that is what I would encourage him to include.
The low voltage data however is "where it's at". That is surely good info, especially given the differences he found between the two. But the conditions of the measurements could be helpful.
Craig
plasmadrive wrote:I believe he said they are 12v pixels. So my question was where did the 12v get measured if it even got measured?
Ummm, perhaps I'm just not getting it... but he said they are 12V pixels, because they are 12V pixels. He didn't post the voltage measurement at all (at least from the chart I saw).
Phrog30 wrote:Ummm, perhaps I'm just not getting it... but he said they are 12V pixels, because they are 12V pixels. He didn't post the voltage measurement at all (at least from the chart I saw).
True he did not post any voltage measurements... This is some of the info I was hoping he would subsequently post. Yes.. they are 12v pixels.. but that does not mean he had 12v going into the first pixel. If for example due to the higher current draw on Ray's pixels he may have had 11v at the input pixel, and due to the lower current draw on the others, maybe he had 11.5v at the input pixel.. (just numbers I made up).. That can happen with long or small lead wires due to the voltage drop and actually skew the resulting measurements.
If however he had them connected directly to the supply with no added lead wires beyond the factory lead wires, and the supply was adjusted for 12v than we have an equal (almost) reference for the data comparison. That would mean for someone that does as I do, (puts a DC converter right at the input of anything pixel), the numbers would be fairly accurate for current draw calculations.
The conditions surrounding info like this can be important especially if someone is using this data to model future props and they are "close" to limits.
Caveat: If he is using 12v pixels with on board regulators per pixel, the numbers would not vary so much with a small voltage drop, but will make some difference in the current draw.
If however they are using a single WS2811 for example, driving 3 LED packs in series and there are no on board regulators, It would make a difference. (found that out the hard way BTW). I know this is most likely not the case here because he is saying "stings" and not "strips".. but having complete data is a good thing.
