Pixel Controller Th...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Pixel Controller Thread

23 Posts
11 Users
0 Reactions
7,997 Views
Posts: 79
Topic starter
(@nailhead-ford)
Trusted Member
Joined: 11 years ago
[#41443]

So I have been browsing http://nutcracker123.com/nutcracker/rgb_controllers/ and was looking at the number of universes some of these controllers can do. I have been running a couple of SanDevices e682s with no trouble. The Falcon F16v2 and PixLite 16 MKII caught my eye since they can handle 10,880 and 16,320 pixels respectively. Not looking for a power injection conversation, I understand that fully. Has anyone driven 5000+ pixels on a single one of these controllers? Any issue? Looking to build a large pixel matrix and large megatree and was hoping that one of these could be a solution.

Thank you,
Kevin


22 Replies
Posts: 46
(@russellmcfarland)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago

Controllers were just discussed exhaustively here: http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?42956-Intro-to-pixels-help

If you want to save yourself 20 pages of reading, buy the Falcon F16v2. 🙂 It was the winner.


Reply
Posts: 79
Topic starter
(@nailhead-ford)
Trusted Member
Joined: 11 years ago
russellmcfarland wrote:Controllers were just discussed exhaustively here: http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?42956-Intro-to-pixels-help

If you want to save yourself 20 pages of reading, buy the Falcon F16v2. 🙂 It was the winner.

Thank you russell

Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 8
(@aussiedoug)
Active Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Sorry, but the f16 V2 board was the “winner” in what way exactly? Just because the user ended up choosing it for his particular application? Do you really think that the Falcon controller is always the best fit in all cases?

I don’t think you can say that one controller is perfect for every person and use to the exclusion of all others. Many of the reasons you may think the Falcon controller is better may not even actually be relevant to Kevin.

For example, do you need to control multiple different types of pixels off the one controller (E.G. WS2811 and LPD6803 simultaneously)? Do you need to use virtual strings (E.G. add null pixels mid string or change RGB order in the middle)? If not, then why is the Falcon a better fit for that purpose? Well…it’s probably not. The PixLite controller is cheaper and drives more pixels, so I think it would be better – for that particular case.

Do you need to control a very complex array of different types of pixels all connected together in series? Such as using strings of pixels from different manufacturers where the RGB order is different and you need to change color mid string? Then maybe the Falcon is a better fit for that application because you can’t change RGB order mid string on the PixLite.

That being said, you can change RGB order on each output separately on a PixLite controller. So that is really an incredibly specific scenario where you need to change RGB order in the middle of the output. How often does that happen? P.S. You can easily change the RGB order of an element mid string in any good sequencing software too, so even then it’s certainly not a reason to discount any of the other pixel controllers. Never-the-less, points to Falcon for being able to do it at the controller level, if you want to do it that way instead.

From my point of view, the only 2 deal breaking differences between the 2 controllers are number of pixels (PixLite winner) or being able to control different types of pixels off the same controller (Falcon winner). Beyond that the main consideration is price (PixLite winner at least while the pre-sale is on). The other features are nice to have but you don’t actually NEED them in the majority of circumstances.

So all I’m saying is I don’t think it’s as cut and dry as you make it out to be in terms of which controller is the “winner”. Falcon users love the Falcon products and that’s great, so do PixLite users (like me)! But I think it’s important to consider what your application is and what your budget is when choosing a controller.


Reply
Posts: 46
(@russellmcfarland)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago

Yes. I think that the F16V2 is the superior option in most all cases. That's just coming from an end user. I don't sell this stuff and have no personal ties or allegiance to any vendor.

The Pixlite budget argument kills me. The original poster is asking how to drive over 5000 pixels (which is going to be well over $1500 worth of lights, cabling, and props). Do you really think he would chose a much less popular platform over $50? I'm all about saving money, but if he is that deeply invested in Pixels, I wouldn't let $50 drive my decision making on which controller to buy. Price was the one thing that most Pixlite fanboys in the other post liked to cling to first.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

When in the 16 output market, I think the better choice is always going to be the Falcon. I use and have several PixLite boards. They are the smaller 4 output footprint. My only complaint with the Falcon board is the size, it's just too big for my taste. One thing to note on the PixLite stuff is location. If you order straight from Advatek, they are in Australia. When you order they are shipped from a warehouse in the states. But need to make a return or repair, you are going to spend $30 to ship back. Total turnaround is around a month. Ask me how I know. If you live in the states, support the local guys.

James


Reply
Posts: 79
Topic starter
(@nailhead-ford)
Trusted Member
Joined: 11 years ago

Let me clarify my initial question "Has anyone driven 5000+ pixels on a single one of these controllers? Any issue?"

I plan on running only 2811s, bullets and possibly some strips (not decided on the trees if strips or bullets, that is more of a PS discussion). All the neat features like Renard outputs, changing pixel types in a string, and other features are not really relevant for me in my proposed application. I am looking at a pure horsepower and load performance discussion. In the next couple of seasons I plan on adding a giant matrix and a giant megatree or two. These elements only will be the sole purpose for this controller. Making this investment, I want to make sure I get something properly capable.

For example I am looking at insight and experience like the following. Sure can technically drive 10k pixels, but if you have 4k pixels firing at once I noticed a processing latency begins that you must account for it in your sequencing. Or, I am running 10k pixels on and it runs just as smooth as I am testing a new sting of 50. Or something in between.


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

I bet there aren't many that would use that many pixels on a single board. I only run about 200 pixels per output, but out of curiosity I did a test where I had 400 pixels on an output. I didn't notice any difference or see any lag. So, if I did that across all 16 outputs that would be 6400 pixels. On the pixels I use, 200 pixels on full white would be approx 8A. So, 400 pixels would be around 16A. At 400 pixels you are going to exceed the current limit on the output. So while the board can handle the amount of pixels you want (data wise), you are going to have to find ways around the current limit. Most people are going to distribute across a few boards.

There are other considerations, length between output and first pixel, pixel vendor, etc. For your needs, either Falcon or PixLite will do what you want.

James


Reply
Posts: 79
Topic starter
(@nailhead-ford)
Trusted Member
Joined: 11 years ago

Thanks James. I already did the back of the napkin current measurements and determined I would not power my pixels through the board and would run an external fused distribution setup. That is If I could truly drive these elements with a single controller and not element specific controllers.

Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 8
(@aussiedoug)
Active Member
Joined: 12 years ago
nailhead_ford wrote:Let me clarify my initial question "Has anyone driven 5000+ pixels on a single one of these controllers? Any issue?"

I haven't quite made the 5000 pixels but am certainly close on the PixLite16. My matrix is 30 x 150 pixels so running 300 pixels of 15 of the outputs & on the other output I am running 8 x 25 pixel arches. No issues with latency at all.
I am running all my power through it's own fuse board so nothing runs through the PixLite at all. It's a much safer way & reduces so many the chance of breaking the control boards.

(edit)The mini trees on the right are running off a PixLite 4 on 2 outputs at 675 pixels each output.

Here is a video for you to have a look.


Reply
Page 1 / 3
Share: