GECE pixel failure ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

GECE pixel failure causes?

33 Posts
14 Users
0 Reactions
9,004 Views
Posts: 844
Topic starter
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
[#34449]

California is suffering through a bad drought. The moment I began to setup my show it started raining and it hasn't stopped since. (I should have setup my show earlier this summer to mitigate the drought...)

As in every previous year, I painstakingly tested every pixel before erecting my megatree. I've learned not only to test individual RGB operation, but also "off", and addressing, and a few other patterns that will make problems evident.

Standing out in the incessant rain, I turned on the megatree at midnight last night for a first test, after inspecting and cleaning every connector. Ugh. I have two bad pixels: one with dead Red at the highest row on the tree (in the back) and another stuck on white at dead center front - very distracting and also too high to reach. I'll have to borrow a bucket truck to fix it unless I want to lower the tree and reconstruct it.

Question: is there any consensus on what causes the GECE pixels to die? Is there any data on how long these pixels last if used with the standard controller and power supply? After infant mortality (discounting any sets that have bad pixels when first turned on) I would expect that the LEDs and controllers in the pixels would have 10k+ hour average lifetime. I am using non-standard (and higher voltage) power supplies, my own controller, and running the pixels at a refresh much greater than stock. I'm wondering if I'm seeing a standard failure rate (any what is causing it?) or if my aggressive refresh or other modifications is causing the failures. I haven't seen one failure that is (obviously) due to water penetration, and I'm excluding that for the purpose of this inquiry.

While mostly a guess/intuition, I suspect that failure due to heat is the major cause of failures. Anyone have other information? Thanks.

Edit: Just wanted to clarify two points: 1) while another interesting discussion, I'm not meaning to compare GECE failure rates to other pixels; 2) what I find so annoying is that the pixels were all tested (bad ones replaced) immediately before putting up the megatree. Upon first power-up, two were bad. What happened?


32 Replies
Posts: 503
(@iflights)
Honorable Member
Joined: 14 years ago

Can't help with the heat question and its relationship to failure of GECE because I'm in Michigan. But, I can say that most of my GECE 50px strings used outside in rooflines and in trees that are still working perfectly after 3 years with PS @ ~5.8 vdc & E68X controllers. The only thing that has been negative is that UV is slowing discoloring the clear plastic. There's going to be failures, and in my case, strings get repaired and are used the following season on bushes, and easier to access props just in case.

if the pixel is still sending data downstream, you don't necessarily have to repair those pixels which are too high, just take that pixel out of your sequences, which has always been my worse case backup plan.


Reply
Posts: 313
(@ee351)
Reputable Member
Joined: 13 years ago

I don't think pixel failures are limited to geces. I have been using them for a fourth year and probably had about a dozen die over that time frame (out of 450). I too live in california. I've read plenty of posts on this board regarding pixel failures of many different types. Overall I'm quite pleased with the geces I've bought over the years.


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I had a lot of failures with GECEs. In fact I've sold off all of my GECEs with the exception of 5 36 pixel snowflakes. For whatever reason these seem to be holding up ok. But they're under my eaves so maybe that helps.

My problems usually ended up being one of two things. Poor factory solder joints, or water intrusion. If I popped off the bulb cover, I'd usually see condensation under the plastic dome. If I didn't see condensation, I'd often be able to tap on the dome, and it would start working, at least temporarily. For me (in Chicago) the failure rate was somewhere in the 5-7 per week range. And this would be every week, all season long. It got to be too much for me to bear. I've since switched to pixabulbs. I have yet to replace a single pixabulb. I did a phased upgrade. I did all of my rooflines last year, and my ground stuff this year. The ones on the roofline made it thru that whole crazy winter last year without a single failure. It was the most harsh winter we've seen in a long time. less than 10 degrees for over 3 months straight. Some were frozen solid in ice for months. The display was up from early October thru early April due to the crazy weather. Bottom line was lots of GECE failures, and zero pixabulb failures


Reply
Posts: 844
Topic starter
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
iflights wrote:Can't help with the heat question and its relationship to failure of GECE because I'm in Michigan.

To clarify, when I mentioned heat I meant heat dissipation (due to faster refresh and/or power supply) not ambient temperature.

But, I can say that most of my GECE 50px strings used outside in rooflines and in trees that are still working perfectly after 3 years with PS @ ~5.8 vdc & E68X controllers.

I'm running 6.0v. I seem to replace 5-10 pixels per year of 3200 total.

The only thing that has been negative is that UV is slowing discoloring the clear plastic.

Yes, I see that also - especially when the sun shines...

if the pixel is still sending data downstream, you don't necessarily have to repair those pixels which are too high, just take that pixel out of your sequences, which has always been my worse case backup plan.

Good idea. Unfortunately I'm in a bind as I have a standalone system reading sequences from an SDcard which I can't change. Still, that's a good idea.


Reply
Posts: 844
Topic starter
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
jchuchla wrote:I had a lot of failures with GECEs.
...
My problems usually ended up being one of two things. Poor factory solder joints, or water intrusion. If I popped off the bulb cover, I'd usually see condensation under the plastic dome. If I didn't see condensation, I'd often be able to tap on the dome, and it would start working, at least temporarily.
...

I guess that's the obvious, likely answer. What I find so perplexing is that between the time I tested all the lights and the time I turned them on last night, the only thing that happened to them was moving them to a vertical orientation and having them sit in three days of heavy rain - not in puddles but suspended in the rain (heavy even by non-California standards). There's not even much chance of stress on the wiring, as the GECE light strands are mounted to shipping strapping for support. There is virtually no strain on the connections or entry/exit points of the wires into the pixels.

However, what is counter to this idea is that I see no evidence of water intrusion. No fogging, nothing visibly wrong under the clear plastic.


Reply
Posts: 313
(@ee351)
Reputable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
ags0000 wrote:To clarify, when I mentioned heat I meant heat dissipation (due to faster refresh and/or power supply) not ambient temperature.

I'm running 6.0v. I seem to replace 5-10 pixels per year of 3200 total.

Yes, I see that also - especially when the sun shines...

Good idea. Unfortunately I'm in a bind as I have a standalone system reading sequences from an SDcard which I can't change. Still, that's a good idea.

Man, with that many pixels you're bound to have some failures regardless of the pixel type.


Reply
Posts: 313
(@ee351)
Reputable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
jchuchla wrote:I had a lot of failures with GECEs. In fact I've sold off all of my GECEs with the exception of 5 36 pixel snowflakes. For whatever reason these seem to be holding up ok. But they're under my eaves so maybe that helps.

My problems usually ended up being one of two things. Poor factory solder joints, or water intrusion. If I popped off the bulb cover, I'd usually see condensation under the plastic dome. If I didn't see condensation, I'd often be able to tap on the dome, and it would start working, at least temporarily. For me (in Chicago) the failure rate was somewhere in the 5-7 per week range. And this would be every week, all season long. It got to be too much for me to bear. I've since switched to pixabulbs. I have yet to replace a single pixabulb. I did a phased upgrade. I did all of my rooflines last year, and my ground stuff this year. The ones on the roofline made it thru that whole crazy winter last year without a single failure. It was the most harsh winter we've seen in a long time. less than 10 degrees for over 3 months straight. Some were frozen solid in ice for months. The display was up from early October thru early April due to the crazy weather. Bottom line was lots of GECE failures, and zero pixabulb failures

This doesn't surprise me, pixels exposed to one year in that climate would be worse than 5 years of the mild winter climate where I live.


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I'm not really sure what the visual signs of water intrusion would be in your environment. Around here, moisture usually comes with big temperature shifts, and it's also pretty common to see a 20-30 degree difference between day and night temps. So around here, there's almost fogging visible if there's any moisture present under the dome. it is entirely possible that

Mine were also well supported. They were mounted to 3/4" PVC pipe with two wire ties per bulb.

This conversation has come up a few times before. There seems to be a correlation with the vintage of the GECEs and their manufacturer. The ones manufactured from 2010-2011 by "SantasBestCraft" seem to be a lot more durable than the sets manufactured 2012-present by "Nicholas Holiday"


Reply
Posts: 503
(@iflights)
Honorable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
jchuchla wrote:
This conversation has come up a few times before. There seems to be a correlation with the vintage of the GECEs and their manufacturer. The ones manufactured from 2010-2011 by "SantasBestCraft" seem to be a lot more durable than the sets manufactured 2012-present by "Nicholas Holiday"

I acquired most of my strings during the summer of 2011. So that's an interesting note.

I put the excess bulbs in string in the gutters to hide them. Never had a failure that looked like water intrusion.

P.S. My GE 36px snowflakes are also going strong.


Reply
Page 1 / 4
Share: