GECE pixel failure ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

GECE pixel failure causes?

33 Posts
14 Users
0 Reactions
9,005 Views
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

My snowflakes will probably get a pixabulb upgrade next year. The gece's are still working. But now that everything else is pixabulb, the slower speed and stepped dimming of the GECEs is starting to stand out.

--Jon Chuchla--

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 844
Topic starter
(@ags0000)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
jchuchla wrote:
This conversation has come up a few times before. There seems to be a correlation with the vintage of the GECEs and their manufacturer. The ones manufactured from 2010-2011 by "SantasBestCraft" seem to be a lot more durable than the sets manufactured 2012-present by "Nicholas Holiday"

All of my pixels are of Santas Best Craft vintage.


Reply
imbluenote
Posts: 1615
(@imbluenote)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago

this is my 1st year with pixels, GECE specifically and i too did burn in tests etc befor cutting off the stock controller everything was fine. After set up and during final testing, i has one on a window frame that the RED was out. I spliced a new one in and good to go. I did take the bulb off the pixel and couldn't see any water entry/burn marks/etc. guess it was jsut a bad LED.

I was looking to add a pixel tree (nothing huge about 8ft) next year and still have some GECE left but it would leave me with no spares for what i am running now. So i too will probably be including pixabulbs next year though not to replace since i have plenty of spares if i go the pixalbulb route for the tree. I just hope i don't have alot of GECE failures, mine were all purchased in the last two years.


Reply
jklingert
Posts: 1767
(@jklingert)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

The GECE electronics are potted in waterproofing compound and the LED enclosure is potted in the same compound. Water is likely not a real issue with the electronics or the LED. Moisture in the globe is not an issue either, if you look closely, the GECE globe actually has several holes to drain out any moisture that gets in there. The globes are easily removable and were not meant to be waterproof.

The big issue in the end is the low cost LEDs all of the various pixel vendors use. I seriously doubt any of them really are the 50K hour lifetime like they state. I am running 800+ GECE pixels for the 4th year, and their failure rate has been comparable to the other pixels I am running. The most common failure mode for a GECE is one color dying before the rest. One member even went so far as to do a formal failure mode analysis of one node that failed differently and it was a bad solder joint in the pixel, not water.

I went with the GECE long before the pixabulbs were available. Given a choice now, i would go with the pixabulbs. I personally like pixels with a globe lens on them. The key to good pixels is the waterproofing, the board and connections need some form of epoxy coating and not just injection molding. Far too many people have been burned by regular injection molded LEDs and the injection molded Technicolor pixels.


Reply
Posts: 347
(@dougd)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I built 2 pixel trees last using 832 GECE pixels on each tree for a total of 1664 pixels. By the end of the season I had maybe 10 that were acting up in one way ot another. Percentage wise that not to bad. But on the mega trees they stood out like a sore thumb and of coarse they fail up high where repairs are very hard.

With that in mind for this year I decided to keep the pixels low. I wrapped my 24 6 foot trees with 64 GECE's each and 16 3 foot trees with 32 GECE's. So far this year I have had only 2 act up. Go figure, as soon as I set up a situation where I can fix them they are doing quite well. Wrapped on trees they are also less noticeable when they do fail.


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago
jklingert wrote:The GECE electronics are potted in waterproofing compound and the LED enclosure is potted in the same compound. Water is likely not a real issue with the electronics or the LED. Moisture in the globe is not an issue either, if you look closely, the GECE globe actually has several holes to drain out any moisture that gets in there. The globes are easily removable and were not meant to be waterproof.

The big issue in the end is the low cost LEDs all of the various pixel vendors use. I seriously doubt any of them really are the 50K hour lifetime like they state. I am running 800+ GECE pixels for the 4th year, and their failure rate has been comparable to the other pixels I am running. The most common failure mode for a GECE is one color dying before the rest. One member even went so far as to do a formal failure mode analysis of one node that failed differently and it was a bad solder joint in the pixel, not water.

I went with the GECE long before the pixabulbs were available. Given a choice now, i would go with the pixabulbs. I personally like pixels with a globe lens on them. The key to good pixels is the waterproofing, the board and connections need some form of epoxy coating and not just injection molding. Far too many people have been burned by regular injection molded LEDs and the injection molded Technicolor pixels.

When I said globe, I was talking about the flat dome over the electronics that's under the faceted lens. (Not the faceted bulb looking lens itself) I observed condensation under this dome which is supposed to be sealed on about 40% of the pixels I had to repair.
Of the 350 GECEs I used I had to replace at least 100 pixels over 3 years. That's an awful rate if you ask me. Its much worse than any other pixel product I've used.

I'd agree about the remaining 60%. Its either poor solder joint, or cheap led component that partially failed.

-- Jon Chuchla --

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 4092
(@skunberg)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I have about 200 GECEs 2 seasons zero failures.


Reply
Posts: 44
(@scottn3xcc)
Trusted Member
Joined: 13 years ago

This is my first year putting out GECEs and I am trying to figure out my wiring scheme to outline my roof lines. I see people complaining about these pixels "pinking out." I'm not seeing any pinking issues, but I am concerned about the pixels being undervolted and causing failures. Is there any consensus about "how low is too low" voltage wise?

I have a 40 string of these on the test bench running with a lower than normal voltage power supply. (5.5v with a diode drop, so 4.75v supply) I am seeing 3.9v on the "far end" and I see no signs of pinking. Should I be concerned with running the last bulb off of only 3.9v?


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

If the voltage is too low they either won't work or will look pink. If you're not seeing that you don't have the problem. There's no danger of damaging the pixels by undervoltage. The just won't work properly.

--Jon Chuchla--

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 44
(@scottn3xcc)
Trusted Member
Joined: 13 years ago

That's good to know. Thanks Jon.

I got my first 80 pixels up on the garage and I think they look pretty good.


Reply
Page 2 / 4
Share: