1pet2_9 wrote:I should probably add that I used my K32 in 5V mode--not 12. It sounds like the concern is that ground bounce from a power cycle slowly erodes at the K8, and that would involve the regulator. K8's don't cost that much, so I don't think the risk level is high. I do a staggered power cycle on my display, mostly to not risk tripping the GFCI. Any such bounces would probably trip the GFCI first. But also, I just like to turn on my stuff that looks good in the daytime first, and turn off my noisy stuff late at night first.
Ground bounce on what line relative to what caused by what phenomenon? One little widget that I designed before I decided to go back to using AC strings is a 6N137-based high-speed optical coupler to completely isolate the controller (ground, power and data) from the pixels and their power source.
Hi Algerdes, I have been using BBB's for a long time and if FPP continues to allow you to copy FPP to the internal eMMC this should keep your FPP running properly.
As you stated the reason most people are worried about rPi is that it doesn't have this capability and the microSD memory can become corrupted from power issues. With that said your show playlists, songs, video, and images could be at risk so you should keep a backup handy to copy to a new replacement microSD and run it out to the controller if there is an issue.
I'm sure you will be happy with the new gear, I purchase some Kulp boards and had one of my K8-B-Scroller running for about 60 days through power outages and storms with no issues. Plus the BBB's I have had running my two main P10 panel screens for years have been rock solid.
Just remember that you have a few extra steps when you have to do a fresh install on some FPP upgrades, but those steps are easier then they have ever been.
I solved this issue in my system and have had ZERO problems powering my rPis off every night. It is not the power ON that is an issue. It is the power OFF while the OS is still logging things to the SD card that causes corruption. My show stops running at 22:00 every day. My PIs all have a cron job that runs at 22:15 that shuts down the PI. Then at 22:30 my home automation automatically turns off the power to the show via smart sockets (A timer works as well). At 16:30 my home automation powers up the show and everything is automatic from there.
Because the PIs are in a "shutdown" state at the time power is removed, the SD cards are not being accessed, the PI buffers have been flushed and the file system on the SD card is in a stable state.
MartinMueller2003 wrote:I solved this issue in my system and have had ZERO problems powering my rPis off every night. It is not the power ON that is an issue. It is the power OFF while the OS is still logging things to the SD card that causes corruption. My show stops running at 22:00 every day. My PIs all have a cron job that runs at 22:15 that shuts down the PI. Then at 22:30 my home automation automatically turns off the power to the show via smart sockets (A timer works as well). At 16:30 my home automation powers up the show and everything is automatic from there.Because the PIs are in a "shutdown" state at the time power is removed, the SD cards are not being accessed, the PI buffers have been flushed and the file system on the SD card is in a stable state.
I would imagine that it's also a good idea to minimize the logging functions that write to the card, too. Personally, I've never found them very helpful anyway: if the show is running properly that's my indicator that things are okay.
I always set up a cron to do a polite shutdown several minutes before a power down. I did notice that is harder to do when running FPP, so maybe that is the root of some of...whatever problems people are facing. If it's intermittent bad sectors on your card, that is a known problem when you don't nice shutdown your Pi.
