Help me check my math, please.
Right now, I have a 20-foot mega tree that holds 192 strands of 100-light incan minis (64 white, 64 red, 64 green). I turn these on in my show in different combinations. When multiple colors are enabled, the tree becomes really "full", which I like.
Transitioning to pixels would be way cool, but the cost looks exceedingly high at this point. Suppose I use something like these, priced at around $22/strand. 50 lights total, with 120mm distance between lights. Stretched taught, the lighted length becomes roughly 19.5 feet. I've got 18.5 feet in distance from the top of my mega tree to the base ring at the bottom, so one strand should be sufficient from top to base.
At the base, the incan mini colors are spaced at roughly 6" apart (I alternate wrapping at the base of white-red-green, each 2" apart). I like that depth, so I'll need 64 strands of WS2811 mini pixels.
64 strands * $22/strand = $1,440
I'll need controllers for the tree, and I like the E682 device from sandevices. Each one can connect 16 strands, so I'll need 4 of those.
4 E682 kits * $109/kit = $436
I'll need power supplies for the mini pixels as well. Will these from Ray Wu do the trick?
64 power supplies * $11.39/supply (includes shipping) = $729
So, all in is roughly $2,605.
Yikes. Really?
You could do a half mega tree and that price would probably drop by well... half... 🙂
64 strands is a lot. I have seen some great pixel trees that have 24-32 strands. Start off with that and double it after year 1 if you don't like it.
dougd wrote:64 strands is a lot. I have seen some great pixel trees that have 24-32 strands. Start off with that and double it after year 1 if you don't like it.
64 strands is a lot. I'm not knocking a lower strand counts, just that I don't care for trees that are so sparse.
However, I'm also considering how "effective" a full-circular tree with strands of lights looks with pixels. The depth is important to me, and I'm not looking to create a tree that simply has effects on the front-facing side.
I would start off with the lower strand count, but then I'm "sorta pregnant", and I likely won't be happy with a half-full tree.
Seems like a lot of power supplies. I'm not positive on this, but if you figured .3W per pixel * 3200 pixels=960 watts. You could probably get 4 PS's from DIY led express for 30 bucks a pop. That would drop your power supply tally from 729 down to around 120.
All in all it's still a lot of money, but you gotta pay to play!
Rob
Just brainstorming here (I don't even have a megatree in my plan for 2013 since most of my 2013 funds are for starting up this "mess"!!!..
If you want a fuller tree, but the benefit of pixels, maybe go with 24 or 32 channels of pixels for the effects, but keep part of the current in cans?
I could see a case where 32 white, 32 red, 32 green, 32 pixel could really pull off some cool stuff.
Going from incandescents to LED's is an expensive proposition any way you cut it. Say you want RGBW in discrete LED's, for 70 ct strings you're looking at roughly $40 per "superstring" (one red, green, blue, and white bundled together), or $2,560; You'd need 64 x 4 channels = 256 channels, or roughly 11 SS24's, or some combination of Ren64's, etc. Go with $100/ pc for the SS24's, that's another $1100 or so. Throw in $200 for spt2 and vampire taps, and you're up around $3,860.
The only saving grace with discrete LED's is that you can do it gradually, i.e. get two colors this year, then two next year, and spread the cost out, whereas with pixels it's get it all pretty much now. I will say that if I hadn't already bought the discrete LED's for my megatree and minitrees in years past, I would lean towards pixels instead of discrete LED's, especially if the Chinese pixels ordered from Ray Wu become more robust or another type of pixel is introduced to the market. You can do so much more with them vs discrete LED's.
edit: costs above figured on 64 strings, as per the OP's design.
edit #2 : The main driver behind my going with LED's was because I was quickly reaching the limit of my AC outlets on the front of the house, and didn't want to install a sub panel just for Christmas lights, plus the longevity of the LED's vs incandescents.
i agree with the others that 64 string seems like alot...but that is personal preference.
As Bud stated you can get buy with fewer (but larger) PSs as the e68x will power the strands, you don't need a PS per string.
one other thing to maybe help cut some money is each e682 will handel 1020 pixels per the manual. if you keep is to 3 e682's (and not 4) you could do 64 strands of 47 or 61 strands of 50. you might have to do some power injection depending on set up.
But by far and away the pixels are going to be the biggest chunk on a 64 strand tree.
bud29 wrote:Seems like a lot of power supplies. I'm not positive on this, but if you figured .3W per pixel * 3200 pixels=960 watts. You could probably get 4 PS's from DIY led express for 30 bucks a pop. That would drop your power supply tally from 729 down to around 120.All in all it's still a lot of money, but you gotta pay to play!
Rob
I used one 250W PS this year to drive 16 LPD6803 strings of 50 - i think it was about 30 bucks. Guessing power requirement is about the same for the strings you reference, so I would agree that you don't need this many Power supplies. Also, I guess you will plan to use some of the same structure, but don't leave that cost out of your calcs - the structure can be costly.
About your pricing, I don't know if your numbers were figuring in shipping but the WS2811's run closer to $17/18 a string and are likely to drop to $15 soon. Also, I'd use the square base pixels on a megatree as I think they are easier to mount than the round ones. If your ordering enough strings the shipping cost won't be that bad.
