Yes, this has been discussed in length and a few videos on it each with their own opinion.
I am revamping my idea for this year and think of making 3 singing elements and the rest of the lights will be steady.
I believe since these singers are small and not competing against brighter lights.
I'm thinking I can get away with 5v pixels. Current count is 515 between the 3 singers.
I think the gutter will hold for additional singers and still steady lights.
Thoughts??
You did not mention what type of pixel you are using. Assuming WS281x. A WS281x pixel running in 5v and another running at 12v will have NO brightness differences. The WS281x line of products are all 5v devices. The 12v version has components that drops the 12v to 5V for use by the pixel. So choosing 5v because you dont need the brightness is not a valid consideration.
Yes this will work.
Other than that you get back into the classic 5v vs 12v discussion.
I still have both 5 and 12 and I'll just cut it short and tell you it's a bad idea. I have to think about it every time I do setup. What voltage is in that area? I have spares I want to put into a new prop but do I have the right voltage? It's just more to keep up with. I used 5v pixels on my porch where I have a large snowflake, some mini x-mas trees, sconces and garland. One of these days I'll get rid of them. I initially thought I'd reserve black wire for 5v and use green and white for 12v. One day a vendor screwed up and sent me a bunch of 12v black pixels. Now I have to look carefully at all of my spares...
All of my bullet nodes are 5v. I have a few 3:1 strips and they are all 12v so mine is easy. Yes you need to be careful. Connecting a 12v pixel to a 5v psu causes no harm. the other way around costs you money. Pick a voltage and stay consistent.
This question has been asked over and over.
It's one of those 'religious' discussions.
You will hear pluses and minuses on the use of both types.
It's really a question of what power supplies do you want to use, do you care about efficiency, How much does pixel cost come into the equation, Do you care about how much and how often you power inject, what gauge wire are you willing to run, how far is the the first pixel from your power supply, and probably more things I can't recall.
You will find folks that say use only one type and others that run a mix of both. They run a mix for all the reasons listed above OR perhaps they got a really good deal on 5V pixels at some point.
The variations are endless, like everything else in this hobby !
Thankfully, you didn't ask who makes the best pixel controller. 😆
Just remember this... whatever you decide will be the best decision for YOU ! There is no one perfect choice.
