Notifications
Clear all

Pcb software

23 Posts
16 Users
0 Reactions
16.3 K Views
intwoit2002
Posts: 412
Topic starter
(@intwoit2002)
Honorable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
[#24655]

I know this has been asked before. Currently I am using ExpressPCB which works well but is costly.

Does anyone want to share information on what they are using for layouts. Eagle is nice but has a size limitation. I don't want to spend $500 for something that I may use only a few times.

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Al


22 Replies
LabRat
Posts: 2981
(@labrat)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago

I use Eagle. Yes there is a size limitation. So far I have not run into it. (I've got to the max size for two of my projects, and had some space to spare. (eg. LED floods)).
There is a "hobbyist" version available, for a decent entry fee, that doubles the board space, and goes to 6 layers. (I have yet to try it).

User interface is not completely intuitive... but once you get the hang of it... boards can be put together quite quickly. Avoid the auto-router... never found it useful.


Reply
RobG
Posts: 1255
 RobG
(@robg)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago

Personally, I am very happy with Eagle and I don't think I would switch to anything else right now.


Reply
ErnieHorning
Posts: 4434
(@erniehorning)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
LabRat wrote:I use Eagle. Yes there is a size limitation.

I use it too. I find that it’s pretty well supported on the net in that you can find library parts very easily.
The limitation is not the board size though; it’s the maximum the center of the part pin can be. The boards outline and part silkscreen is not included in this size limitation.


Reply
Posts: 2216
(@ctmal)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

The last board I did was in Kicad. It's not hard once you get used to it. I'll probably try DesignSpark for my next one...it's been updated since I've last used it.
Neither of them have any restrictions and both are free.


Reply
mrpackethead
Posts: 2289
(@mrpackethead)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I use Eagle for designing my commercial and play projects. I do have the professional unlimited version, so i'm not restricted to having to the 100x80mm 2 layers. Its unique in that it runs across Linux/Macos/Windows, whereas many of the other systems only run on one O/S.
Theres 'moderate' numbers of component libraries out there. And in general it does a good job. THeres a few quirks that you need to learn like all things, but for most people it will get you through it and there are some good introductory tutorials.

You've got good control of the CAM process, so its easy to setup outputs to a variety of formats ( eg, gebers ).. But i also use it to create files for my pcb mill.

The auto-router is a waste of time, you'll typically end up with a pile of track that you need to rework..

I'm however in the process of moving to a more professional system, thats got more integrated design tools. However its a big investment and theres a lot to choose from. Eagles got me through for the last 4 years, and i've designed 4 layer boards on it, with 3000 nets. so it does get you there.


Reply
dmcole
Posts: 2196
(@dmcole)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I tried Eagle and couldn't get the hang of it. I tried a couple of others and found them wanting as well.

I finally settled on DipTrace on Windows and while I didn't like the latter part, I lived with it for a while.

About two years ago the company figured out a one-click install Wine port to Unix/Linux and, lo and behold, Mac OS as well (Intel processors only). I had to run it on my laptop (I was still on PowerPC on the desktop) for six months before I broke down and bought an Intel desktop machine. Now I can actually sit in front of the OS I use 12 hours a day to create electronics.

I find it intuitive and easy to use for schematics and but the board-making process left somethings to be desired: the parts library is limited and even when they're there, they're hard to find. When they're not there and you post to the support forum looking for a part, you're shouted down: "Draw it yourself!"

I have created one board with DipTrace and to say it was a failure is an understatement. I brought the schematic across to the PCB module and couldn't make heads-nor-tails of the result. I redrew the PCB from scratch (bad idea) and left out a handful of connections.

So, while I remain happy with DipTrace as a schematic-drawing tool, I am less sold with it as a PCB tool. I do plan to try making another board with it before I go elsewhere, though.

YMMV.

\dmc


Reply
CaptKirk
Posts: 2200
(@captkirk)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

I would love to see "the failure" that was generated by Diptrace (like a board PDF?) just to see what that looks like!


Reply
Andy.wpg
Posts: 523
(@andy-wpg)
Honorable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
intwoit2002 wrote:I know this has been asked before. Currently I am using ExpressPCB which works well but is costly.

Does anyone want to share information on what they are using for layouts. Eagle is nice but has a size limitation. I don't want to spend $500 for something that I may use only a few times.

I actually use Express PCB, then print out the layers on clear stock and use that to photo-etch boards. Works great


Reply
Posts: 2168
(@djulien)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Andy.wpg wrote:I actually use Express PCB, then print out the layers on clear stock and use that to photo-etch boards.

+1 for ExpressPCB. (simple, easy to learn, no size limit, etc)

However, I now print to PDFs (using PDFCreator) and then run them thru Pdf2Gerb to generate Gerbers, then send them out somewhere. BTW this technique can also be used to run a CNC machine from an ExpressPCB design.

don


Reply
Page 1 / 3
Share: