12v vs 5v Mega Tree...
 
Notifications
Clear all

12v vs 5v Mega Tree?

30 Posts
16 Users
0 Reactions
15.2 K Views
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

The squares will do better in your situation then. The wires on the bullets will probably make things bulge.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk


Reply
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
Topic starter
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Phrog30 wrote:The squares will do better in your situation then. The wires on the bullets will probably make things bulge.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

That was my thoughts too but I have never owned any square pixels so I wasnt sure the price increase would be worth it or not. I didn't want to put undue stress on the wires on bullets and break the seals which would ultimately result in failed pixels. Thats one reason I was leaning toward the squares. Its an extra $40 on 30 strips (24 plus 6 spares). A price I am willing to pay if it indeed is a better option but I don't want to throw money away needlessly.


Reply
Posts: 8517
(@angus40)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Wolfie wrote:As I said I will be using the boscyo strips. Bullets do fine in them. So to squares.

Under normal tree setups either would do just fine. But, I am making a mult-purpose item here, both a pumpkin and a tree. The strips will lay against hoops to form a ball. What do you think the bullets will do when the strips are laid over the hoops compared to the square bullets? My thoughts are that the intra-node wires will force the bullets to flex. While the square nodes shouldn't. What is your opinion on this?

Since its an atypical install I was looking for other's thoughts on it.

Square nodes seat in a level fashion compared to bullets . I would go with the square in your build scenario .

I like the bullets for trees and the squares for any straight line prop that is placed against a backing of sorts , wall -roofing -wire type frame etc .

good luck with your choice .


Reply
Posts: 255
(@rogerh)
Reputable Member
Joined: 12 years ago

The 5v pixels are nice for a megatree because you can power inject at the bottom leg of the strings. I personally am saving my 12v strings for long runs that I don't want to power inject at the end. I'm recycling part of last years show into a 180 megatree 40x12. That's 12 ten foot 1/2" emt segments that will clip onto 2 half rings.(Top & bottom).


Reply
beeiilll
Posts: 869
(@beeiilll)
Prominent Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I have tinkered with both the square and bullet and prefer the square ones myself. I agree with Angus40 that the square will lay out better against any form of backer.
I have not built a pixel tree yet but will use the square for it as well since the wires coming out the ends of the pixels works better for me than the bullets but that can also just be a personal preference as well.
I use all 5 volt but just decided to do so to keep things all the same and power injection is not a big deal to me. I can see the "advantage" of 12 volt being longer runs but I have the string of pixels going along anyway so adding a power injection wire or two along the line is no big deal.
RogerH is also correct in that 5 volt works if you want to power inject at the bottom which is what I plan on for my tree as of now. Otherwise I would just run an extra power supply or two and larger gauge wires up to the top of the tree and inject there as well if it becomes necessary.

All pretty much comes down to whatever you want to do.


Reply
Posts: 4092
(@skunberg)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I try to use 5 volt but I've got 7 volt gece, 12 volt items and 24 volt floods. So I believe that you will limit you display if you limit your voltage. I try to plan by prop rather than what I'm using elsewhere.


Reply
Posts: 3735
(@algerdes)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Wolfie wrote:Yep, there is no ONE way. THats why I threw up the poll to see what others thought about 12v -vs- 5v in my situation.

So what about square vs bullet?

Square get used on mounted/strapped to pvc, etc Props. . All the trees are bullet using Boscoyo strips.


Reply
Posts: 2507
(@mrgrumpy)
Famed Member
Joined: 12 years ago

I don't watch the power meter either, but maybe a tree hugger at heart . . efficiency means a lot to me - so 5V it is, when possible. I fully understand power injection and have no problem laying it out . . I typically use more injection points than needed....and I use bigger than needed cabling.

If I ever grow my mega tree to where I need top injection, I'll run Pos & Neg welding cable (per power supply) up the center of the pole, to a power distribution point on top.
hahaha . . maybe the efficiency will pay for some of my upgrades.

I'm not without 12V. I have several meters of 12V strips.


Reply
Posts: 598
(@nutz4lights)
Honorable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

5v on my 20' megatree. 50 square pixels up, 50 square pixels down. 100 pixels per output. Data + power at pixel 1, power injection at pixel 100. 2400 pixels total, two 350w power supplies. Was running off of two p12 controllers but now will run off one f16v2.

Louie

Sent from my SM-G928V using Tapatalk


Reply
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
Topic starter
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Skunberg wrote:I try to use 5 volt but I've got 7 volt gece, 12 volt items and 24 volt floods. So I believe that you will limit you display if you limit your voltage. I try to plan by prop rather than what I'm using elsewhere.

I don't plan on eliminating 5v across the whole display. I am talking JUST the tree here. With a 12v topper, that means I have to run 12v to the top if all the other pixels are 5v. Thats one thing I am wanting to eliminate. My current tree (poorly designed) has power injection stupidly at the top (thats the way I enhereted it). If I go 12v, then I can run 100px without need of PI. If I go 60px per I will need to test if I can get 120 without PI. If I group up 4 into a single data out, I can PI on the second pair. Half the cables then since I have to cascade data from strand 2 to 3, I can PI at that point.

nutz4lights wrote:5v on my 20' megatree. 50 square pixels up, 50 square pixels down. 100 pixels per output. Data + power at pixel 1, power injection at pixel 100. 2400 pixels total, two 350w power supplies. Was running off of two p12 controllers but now will run off one f16v2.

Sounds like your tree is similar to my old one. But I don't know why you needed two P12's nor do I understand how you could get 100px running on 5v. About all I could get was about 65 before it started to pink. And a 24 strand tree should have run just fine off a single P12 which is what I had for my 24 strand tree. And the star (35px) was tagged onto the last output of the P12.

My gut is telling me to go with 6 outputs on the F16, each running 4 strands (200px) and 12v pixels. That takes me down from 12 data lines to only 6. It also removes all the PI from the top and allows me to get the PI on the bottom (where it belonged in the first place). This is also symmetrical in that each data line (which will also carry power) will have a companion PI line so I can bundle those two together for neatness on the ground.


Reply
Page 2 / 3
Share: