12v vs 5v Mega Tree...
 
Notifications
Clear all

12v vs 5v Mega Tree?

30 Posts
16 Users
0 Reactions
15.2 K Views
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
Topic starter
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago
[#41539]

Given the power consumption of 12v, I was leaning toward 5v pixels again for my 24 strand 180 mega but I thought I would pose the poll and see where the chips lie. I know there is quite a bit of power waste due to resistors and such with 12v and a slight reduction in visible light output when compared to 5v pixels But 12v seems better for power injection meaning a simpler wiring setup and fewer connections to fail. So I thought I would see what others are thinking and using. Last year I used 5v and 12v supplies because the tree pixels are 5v but the star modules are 12v. The pixels from the old tree are not likely to be used on the new tree even if it stays 5v this year. I will likely recycle them into something else though.

I will be making a portable hole and a pushup pole. I will be using boscoyo strips. I am looking at 4" spacing on the pixels. My thoughts are wondering between 50 and 60px per leg which will run 16' or 20' legs. However I am not opposed to going 60 pixels at 3" spacing for 15' legs with a higher light density. The star is staying the same and is made from 12v 3 led modules.

If the decision is 12v pixels, this would eliminate the need to run power to the top for the star. I am also trying to decide between bullet and square pixels.

I will be shifting from a J1sys controller to a F16v2 this year so I have a hell of a lot more pixel driving capability than last year. While I was limited to 170 per output on the J1sys, I can put 4, 6 or even 8 strands per output on the F16 considerably reducing the feed lines. Yes, I can put more, but then I would be worried about the refresh rate and being easily divided into 24 strands. The prospect of going from requiring 12 outputs for the tree (the whole controller!) on the J1 down to 6 or 4 or (gasp!) just 3 on he F16 will vastly improve construction, setup and reduce cabling. And, of course, let me plug in more blinkies!

My mindset is the tree will initially be a pumpkin for debut for Halloween this year. I am still finalizing the design but the concept is to have the PUP collapsed and have the strands draped around hoops to form a squashed ball (pumpkin) in lieu of a cone (tree). I am thinking a wire frame "stem" for the top when its set as a pumpkin and that will be replaced by a star before being converted to a tree and the PUP extended up to full height.

So, what do yall think, should I go with 5v bullets, 5v square, 12v bullets, or 12v square?


29 Replies
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Let me say this, I use 12v except on my p10 stuff. Yes 12v isn't as "efficient", but unless your show is massive you aren't going to see a huge difference on your power bill between the two. Before switching to all rgb, I used ac leds. My power bill didn't change at all. If you run a static show on all white, maybe you will see a difference.

James

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk


Reply
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
Topic starter
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Phrog30 wrote:Let me say this, I use 12v except on my p10 stuff. Yes 12v isn't as "efficient", but unless your show is massive you aren't going to see a huge difference on your power bill between the two. Before switching to all rgb, I used ac leds. My power bill didn't change at all. If you run a static show on all white, maybe you will see a difference.

James

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

Generally I don't care about the power bill. If I did, I wouldn't be putting up a show, I would hang some static ornaments in the tree and call it a day 🙂 My efficiency concerns were more about the quantity and distribution of 12v PSUs rather than spinning the kilowatt wheel of misfortune. IIUC, each 12v PSU can't support as many pixels as 5v PSUs. So it was the necessary need for more PSUs and subsequent enclosures and of course 120v supply lines for them.


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

You mentioned power waste, thus my response was based on that. If your concerns are quantity and distribution, then that sounds like you just need to make a decision.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 3735
(@algerdes)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Even with all the discussion here about using either voltage, and good arguments for the use of either, I am standardized on 12v ws2811.

We have 7 trees. 6 of which are bullet loaded. (The 7th is a pex tree with 30/10 strips loaded.) The shorter trees use 50 pixels @ 3" spacing (16 strings each tree for 180 degrees). The taller use 66 pixels @ 3" spacing (Last year 16 strings, but this year will go to 24 each tree and moving up to 210 degrees). All of them are "folded" once, making each drop off of the controllers pushing between 100 and 132 pixels. We have no "pink" (when on full white) and we only feed one line from the controller to each.

We have used a single power supply (350watt @ 12 volt) for each tree in the past. This year we are doubling up on power supplies per tree. (We have additional props - near each tree - to be run off each controller.)

I like the refresh rates with the number of pixels we have per output on the controllers. Though it has been awhile since I ran any physical tests on longer lines, I still believe that the greater the string length, the longer it takes to refresh each line. Besides, not having to power inject is a big plus.

Like most things up here in DIY land, this is all dependent on the user's experience. No one way is the "right way". That is what makes this stuff so much fun. 🙂


Reply
Posts: 1168
(@keith-r)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
algerdes wrote:Even with all the discussion here about using either voltage, and good arguments for the use of either, I am standardized on 12v ws2811.

+1
Pixabulbs on the eaves, around the garage, and windows. WS2811 square nodes (16 x 50) on two trees this year, each with one power supply. Makes it easy to set up and spares to switch out. I agree that not having to power inject is a big plus.


Reply
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
Topic starter
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Phrog30 wrote:You mentioned power waste, thus my response was based on that. If your concerns are quantity and distribution, then that sounds like you just need to make a decision.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

No problem and I appreciate the input. I just wanted to clarify that I wasn't referring to power bill issues but rather the potential need for additional PSUs that was on my radar screen for 12v.


Reply
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
Topic starter
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago
algerdes wrote:erience. No one way is the "right way". That is what makes this stuff so much fun. 🙂

Yep, there is no ONE way. THats why I threw up the poll to see what others thought about 12v -vs- 5v in my situation.

So what about square vs bullet?

I am seeing square for about $1.30 more per strand (50x12v) than bullet pixels. Gut feeling telling me to order a bunch of the square ones for the new tree. I have never used square nodes but with the wires entering and leaving the pixel from the side rather from the back (like bullets) seems more logical and worth the 3 cents per pixel.

Are the square nodes indeed better for trees? Or is it a waste of money?

I am also liking they are available with all black wire which will blend with the boscyo strips. I haven't checked the multi-color wire to see if it fluoresces under blacklight (UV) but I am betting the black definitely won't. I run a heck of a lot of UV for halloween so I have to be careful with what is exposed to it and thus ruin effects. Extension cords are the worst and I end up taking a UV flashlight to the stores when I need more cables.


Reply
Posts: 1049
(@phrog30)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago

I use bullets everywhere, including my trees. I find them a waste, but that is my opinion.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk


Reply
Wolfie
Posts: 2225
Topic starter
(@wolfie)
Noble Member
Joined: 11 years ago

As I said I will be using the boscyo strips. Bullets do fine in them. So to squares.

Under normal tree setups either would do just fine. But, I am making a mult-purpose item here, both a pumpkin and a tree. The strips will lay against hoops to form a ball. What do you think the bullets will do when the strips are laid over the hoops compared to the square bullets? My thoughts are that the intra-node wires will force the bullets to flex. While the square nodes shouldn't. What is your opinion on this?

Since its an atypical install I was looking for other's thoughts on it.


Reply
Page 1 / 3
Share: