Triac Question
 
Notifications
Clear all

Triac Question

9 Posts
4 Users
0 Reactions
3,684 Views
Mudsculpter
Posts: 1220
Admin
Topic starter
(@mudsculpter)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago
[#18621]

If I were only powering strings of LEDs in my display, is there a reason why I should not use a triac such as this?
I would like some supporting info why I should/should not use. Its is 4 amp but I am not powering vast strings of anything.

BTB04-600SL


8 Replies
rstehle
Posts: 4348
(@rstehle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I don't believe this triac has the isolated tab that we use. Could be a 'shocking' experience..........:whtf:

Mudsculpter wrote:If I were only powering strings of LEDs in my display, is there a reason why I should not use a triac such as this?
I would like some supporting info why I should/should not use. Its is 4 amp but I am not powering vast strings of anything.

BTB04-600SL


Reply
Mudsculpter
Posts: 1220
Admin
Topic starter
(@mudsculpter)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Ahh,.. wasnt thinking. thanks...


Reply
rstehle
Posts: 4348
(@rstehle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Other than that the specs look fine. Might be OK for 12 or 24 volt operation, but I wouldn't recommend them for 120 volt operation due to the shock hazard. :happycrying:


Reply
Mudsculpter
Posts: 1220
Admin
Topic starter
(@mudsculpter)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Given the nomenclature
BT A 06 - 600 BW (RG)

and

A = insulated
B = non insulated
06 = 6A
600 = 600V
800 = 800V

B = 50mA Standard
C = 25mA Standard
BW = 50mA Snubberless
CW = 35mA Snubberless
SW = 10mA Logic Level
TW = 5mA Logic Level

Why would one use a CW version over a TW version of this triac

The 511-BTA04-700T used previously in Franks ren24 BOM differs from the BTA06-600CW used in the SS8/16/24 BOM in that it has a 15mA holding current where the latter carries a 35mA rating. Is this important?

How about this one? In many ways it is very similar to the 511-BTA04-700T that was used before it went obsolete.

511-BTA06-600T


Reply
Wayne J
Posts: 7789
(@wayne-j)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 20 years ago

what exactly is your goal?


Reply
Mudsculpter
Posts: 1220
Admin
Topic starter
(@mudsculpter)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago

To replace 120 failing triacs in my ren24s from a group buy that I participated


Reply
EasyGo
Posts: 93
(@easygo)
Trusted Member
Joined: 16 years ago

I've tried more than a dozen different triacs over the last year (with minimum gate currents of 5 mA to 50 mA), and the ONLY one I tried that didn't work satisfactorily was a BTA24-600CW... the only problem with it was that LEDs still glowed when it was off. Despite the 5-uA leakage rating at 25C, I had to put a 22K load resistor on it to get the LEDs to turn off. Of course, a 25-amp triac is beyond overkill on a 2-amp or 4-amp printed circuit board anyway.

My tests were done using PWM firmware on either a Renard 24SS or else with a Renard 64XC and SSRez SSR. If PWM firmware were not being used, the holding current would be much more important (especially with LEDs).

To answer your "C" versus "T" question: of more concern is the dV/dt rating of the triac, which affects the noise immunity (all those other triacs switching on and off makes lots of electrical noise on the power line, and that fast-changing voltage across a triac can cause it turn on without any intentional gate drive). In general, the higher the minimum gate current, the more noise immune. The snubberless (W) series generally are more immune compared to standard triacs with the same minimum gate current rating. I'm sure this is why Wayne switched to CW triacs on the SS boards.

Unfortunately, the Lite-On MOC3023's that we use have a dV/dt rating of something like 210 volts/uS (most other brands are lots worse), so using a triac with a huge 1500 V/uS rating won't buy us much more immunity since the MOC itself will become the weak link in the circuit configuration normally used.

Jon

*edit* I see Wayne was answering you while I was typing a long message, so I'll let him speak for himself, ha..


Reply
Mudsculpter
Posts: 1220
Admin
Topic starter
(@mudsculpter)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago

ooops..


Reply
Share: