Stand alone control...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Stand alone controller

14 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
5,362 Views
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

I haven't been around in a long time... To make a long story short - the economy of the area I live in has resulted in me delaying the process of purchasing a house for the past few years, and I don't feel comfortable with a home purchase around here any time soon. No home to decorate = Christmas lighting stuff has all gotten deprioritized. I've been mostly doing Android hacking lately (I'm a CyanogenMod maintainer for a few devices now...), but getting back to topic:

If based on the RPi, the architecture could probably be easily ported to a variety of other embedded Linux hosts such as the BeagleBone, or possibly (as an extreme example that tempts me to play with) something like a ZedBoard.


Reply
Posts: 238
(@ronp5683)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago

Zedboard. Last time they put a processor in an FPGA it did not sell.

Zedboard $400, single price for IC, $275.

Raspberry PI $35, FPGA board off e-bay $20.

Do the math.


Reply
Posts: 112
(@rogelio)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I know the Lynx Conductor will do it.


Reply
Posts: 597
(@entropy)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
ronp5683 wrote:Zedboard. Last time they put a processor in an FPGA it did not sell.

Zedboard $400, single price for IC, $275.

Raspberry PI $35, FPGA board off e-bay $20.

Do the math.

Their Virtex-5 approach was EXTREMELY expensive. Even the lowend chips were pushing $1000+, and they were also extremely difficult to work with - among other things, the PPC cores had to have all of their support logic wired up in the FPGA fabric. I know someone who had to work with the FX130T - it was a nightmare. In the Zynq, there's a reasonably complete CPU subsystem that will fully boot Linux without a single bit of programmable logic, and the PL portion can be configured from the ARM host after boot time (this was NOT even remotely possible with the V5 PPC approach).

That said, the Zedboard would be only for extremely high channel count displays and "just because I want to play with the thing" hobbyists.

Either way, the ideal would be a standalone package for embedded Linux-on-ARM that could target, from lowend to extreme high end:
Raspi
BeagleBone
Raspi + external FPGA
BeagleBone + external FPGA such as a Papilio (I still want to try this, I just haven't had the time)
Zedboard (massive overkill, it tempts me just for the extreme overkill silliness)


Reply
Page 3 / 3
Share: