Great. I just decide and build hardware to eliminate most cabling in my renard system by going DMX and you guys come up with a wireless solution. I am going to have to strangle someone, lol.
That has to be one of the simplest solutions to date. Great work!
Interesting....very interesting! 🙂
Does this only with with the Renard SS's? I thought all the Renards could be reprogrammed to run using DMX for communications...
I just re-read the pdf, and have one more comment/question. Why not make eMode selectable with a jumper (shunt) instead of soldering in a jumper wire?
Macrosill wrote:Great. I just decide and build hardware to eliminate most cabling in my renard system by going DMX and you guys come up with a wireless solution. I am going to have to strangle someone, lol.
What are friends for?!?!?
The first time I heard of DMX I thought it was some kind of new sport bicycle. 😉
Virtus wrote:Does this only with with the Renard SS's? I thought all the Renards could be reprogrammed to run using DMX for communications...
I haven't looked at the communication cabling needs for the other Renard boards (non SS type) yet. The XBee is essentially a wireless serial device, so it fits very nicely with the serial communications signal between the computer and the SS board. If the computer-to-Renard cabling or the Renard-to-Renard cabling is the same, it ought to work because the in/out RJ45s on the Ren-WC board are serial.
The XBee's maximum throughput specs tout 256kbs, but the serial configuration options only go to 115,200. I believe DMX has a higher throughput need than XBee can accommodate so the Ren-WC converter probably isn't going to be a very successful solution for DMX.
The same concept (e.g. a plug-in wireless converter) could likely be done with a wireless radio chip that has higher throughput, but I haven't looked into all the chips available to accomplish that. XBee radios actually communicate with one another right out of the box -- talk about easy! I was after a very easy, quick method to make wireless available to a lot of users for precious little hassle, and all things considered, very little money.
oldcqr wrote:I just re-read the pdf, and have one more comment/question. Why not make eMode selectable with a jumper (shunt) instead of soldering in a jumper wire?
I like that idea, too -- right now it's a real estate problem. The XBee Pro chip is about 1/4" longer than the normal XBee chip and I haven't found just the right spot for a jumper to accommodate both chips. The darned XBee 2mm header pins are so close together that trying to snake a trace between them is iffy at best for a home-etched board. And my goal is to try to put everyting on one side to make home etching easier.
Good idea though -- it's most definitely on the list! Thanks!
Edit: Thanks also for the better screen marking idea for the 100uf electrolytic. It's always odd to me how the square pad for some components is the + side while for others it's just the reverse. Don't know if that was Thomas Edison's idea or not but...(lol)
So if I understand this correctly;
With the Ren's you place them in the yard and run your cat5 from the board to the SSR's (unless your running the SS version with which your running the power lines)
The XBee eliminates the cat5 cable from the computer to the Ren's as long as they are in direct line of sight.
Do the XBee's work behind plate glass windows? or are you running a TX antenna out side so its line-of-sight?
Will the XBee receive ok if its inside a PVC or ABS weather proof box? (I live in wet/snowy climate so this is important)
1 Xbee to TX
1 XBee RX for EACH Ren board or just 1 XBee RX and adjust your sequencing to account for the 6ms delay to each board inline?
I'm interested in this as it may remove a LOT of cat5 cable running round my yard.
I've already laid out my electrical conduits under my lawn with GFCI plugs hidden behind the trees, each outlet is capable of 15amps each x 8 outlets, short extension cords under 10 feet each are enough to reach any part of my display this year.
There is enough room to run a few cat5 cables in the conduit as well and I originally planned of having the power and signal reside inside some 10"x10" junction boxes with water tight glands to run cat5 and power out to the SSR's (I'm running non-SS Ren's this year but would love to switch to the SS's)
Just want to make sure I'm not still running a cat5 cable out my computer and require it to sit outside in line-of sight just so I can air-jump 15 feet and call it wireless.
If its what I hope it is, I can see a few 8"x8" electrical boxes (water tight) mounted on some plywood yard art like presents or small figures with the Xbee facing the house, hammer the yard art in nice and deep with rebar for security.
I have a question from the PDF as well. You mention repeater mode...
Does this mean xbee is a point to point device where the receivers are in a "string" passing the serial signal from one radio to the next? Or can one transmitter send the signal to several receivers, thus elminating the 6ms cumulative "lag" as the signal is passed from REN to REN to REN? So if I plant my transmitter in the middle of the yard, will it be able to transmit out to all the REN's?
BuzzKill wrote:I have a question from the PDF as well. You mention repeater mode...Does this mean xbee is a point to point device where the receivers are in a "string" passing the serial signal from one radio to the next? Or can one transmitter send the signal to several receivers, thus elminating the 6ms cumulative "lag" as the signal is passed from REN to REN to REN? So if I plant my transmitter in the middle of the yard, will it be able to transmit out to all the REN's?
It can be configured either way. In point-to-point mode it passes the serial data from one to the next. In repeater mode, the board takes the output from the SS's RJ45 that's intended to go to the next SS and retransmits it to whichever next Ren-WC is in the line. Because it's coming from the SS board's output, the 2nd SS takes whatever was passed on from the first one. Therefore, each link in the chain encounters a slight delay as the signal is gathered by the Xbee, retransmitted, received and then decoded by the next receiving Xbee. If you had four SS24s connected via cat5, there is still a lag between the time the first board gets the signal and the last one (it's very short of course because electricity is very fast!) because the signal has to be processed through the first board, then the 2nd, then the 3rd before the 4th even sees it. The Xbee is slower than raw electricity because it has to convert the serial signal to its internal data packet, transmit it to the next one where the receiver has to reassemble the data packet into serial data again...hence the 6ms performance delay.
In global broadcast mode, it sends the same signal out to all radios simultaneously instead of having to pass through multiple stages. It'd be the same as if you connected the computer's outbound serial data to a splitter and connected 4 SS boards to the splitter: each one gets exactly the same data at the same time, and none of it has already been processed and passed through an SS board prior to receiving it. Therefore, logically, if your show had only 24 total channels and you had four SS24 boards, you could set a single transmitter in the middle of the yard and broadcast all 24 channels to each of the 4 SS24 boards and each board would respond identically and simultaneously because none of them are aware of each other -- they all look at the data as if each is the first SS. But because an Xbee still takes 6ms to receive and process a signal, each Xbee would use the same amount of delay to receive and process the signal so the SS could react to it.
The Ren-WC does not use addressing in terms of Renard channels: it uses addressing as it relates to the XBee radios themselves and whether two or more radios are configured to receive the same signal simultaneously or whether they receive it and forward it to a specific one in the chain that is intended to be the next one, thereby reprocessing the serial signal before it gets to the next controller.
Edit: From my experience, Renard SS boards are not addressable but instead, they decode the signals on their own in board sequence order so that the first SS board in the chain takes the first set of channels (depending on how many channels the board has), the next SS in the series takes the next set, etc. until no more channels are left. This tells me that the Renards provide some sort of filtering on their own -- they don't react specifically to channel numbers as much as the PICs take "the next 8 channels," whatever channel number they are, and then sends the "leftover" signals on to be decoded by the next PIC. This is why the basic board is an SS8, an SS16 is simply two PICs and an SS24 has three PICs. If the first transmitting module is connected to the computer, it is therefore sending out everything, just as if the commands were coming through a cat5 wire. The Ren-WC design relies on the SS boards themselves to do the filtering just as they normally do, and it's up to the user to configure the radios to recreate the proper order for the SS boards to process the commands.
