dirknerkle wrote:I haven't looked at the communication cabling needs for the other Renard boards (non SS type) yet. The XBee is essentially a wireless serial device, so it fits very nicely with the serial communications signal between the computer and the SS board. If the computer-to-Renard cabling or the Renard-to-Renard cabling is the same, it ought to work because the in/out RJ45s on the Ren-WC board are serial.The XBee's maximum throughput specs tout 256kbs, but the serial configuration options only go to 115,200. I believe DMX has a higher throughput need than XBee can accommodate so the Ren-WC converter probably isn't going to be a very successful solution for DMX.
The same concept (e.g. a plug-in wireless converter) could likely be done with a wireless radio chip that has higher throughput, but I haven't looked into all the chips available to accomplish that. XBee radios actually communicate with one another right out of the box -- talk about easy! I was after a very easy, quick method to make wireless available to a lot of users for precious little hassle, and all things considered, very little money.
So in using this we do not need to reflash the PICs as we can transmit the Renard 1 protocol wirelessly. This is pretty cool. Thanks for the answer.
If we hard-coded the channel addresses in the Rens - which is obviously more work and not as flexible - it sounds like we could use broadcast mode correct and get around the end-to-end delay? I realize this would not be as popular but perhaps an option.
Aurbo99 wrote:Do the XBee's work behind plate glass windows? or are you running a TX antenna out side so its line-of-sight?Will the XBee receive ok if its inside a PVC or ABS weather proof box? (I live in wet/snowy climate so this is important)
I think line-of-sight means that the fewer obstructions, the better. It's a 2.4ghz RF radio signal, not an infrared or light beam that really would rely on the literal concept of "line-of-sight." My next testing (hopefully next week) will include testing for transmission range through windows, from inside enclosures, and your idea about PVC pipe is a good one -- I'll try that too. My instincts tell me that anytime you have zero obstructions (other than air) you'll get better performance than when you put things inside enclosures. That must be why they build television and radio antennas outdoors 😉
1 Xbee to TX
1 XBee RX for EACH Ren board or just 1 XBee RX and adjust your sequencing to account for the 6ms delay to each board inline?
There's some confusion here so I must not have explained it very well in the PDF. The short answer is that the radio essentially replaces the cat5 wiring. But just like Renard SS's operate using cat5, the output from one SS has to go into the input of the next SS.
The Ren-WC on the first SS controller receives the initial transmitted signal from the computer and injects it into the IN jack of the SS. The SS processes it as if it came via cat5 wire and what's leftover goes out the SS's OUT jack. The Ren-WC takes the output from the OUT jack and retransmits it to the next one, just as if the out jack was connected to the next SS controller's IN jack.
I'm interested in this as it may remove a LOT of cat5 cable running round my yard.I've already laid out my electrical conduits under my lawn with GFCI plugs hidden behind the trees, each outlet is capable of 15amps each x 8 outlets, short extension cords under 10 feet each are enough to reach any part of my display this year.
There is enough room to run a few cat5 cables in the conduit as well and I originally planned of having the power and signal reside inside some 10"x10" junction boxes with water tight glands to run cat5 and power out to the SSR's (I'm running non-SS Ren's this year but would love to switch to the SS's)Just want to make sure I'm not still running a cat5 cable out my computer and require it to sit outside in line-of sight just so I can air-jump 15 feet and call it wireless.
If its what I hope it is, I can see a few 8"x8" electrical boxes (water tight) mounted on some plywood yard art like presents or small figures with the Xbee facing the house, hammer the yard art in nice and deep with rebar for security.
Sounds like you have a lot of stuff going on there!!! My initial goal with this was simply to control lights in both the front and back of my house and eliminate a long cat5 cable run (300+ feet), but it expanded into the idea of controlling a neighbor's lights across the street. I don't know yet the limit of how many XBee radios can be in a chain -- theoretically a lot more than the 6radios I have to play with. I don't know yet the transmission distance that will be achieved, but when the manufacturer's specs say that the "pro" version has the ability to go up to a mile, it leads me to believe than 100 yards ought to be very workable. But because of the configuration flexibility I've tried to create, six radios potentially means that five SS boards could be controlled either simultaneously (where all SS controller react to the same set of Vixen channels) or in a daisy chain fashion (where each SS controller has its own range of Vixen channels).
Lots of balls in the air!!!! 😯
If you are doing testing, might also consider "surrounding" the units with lights. I see these as being useful near the base of mega trees, or hidden in a group of mini trees. Wouldn't want the reciever to be able to turn the lights on, but then the interference caused by all of the lights to not let it recieve anything else.
deplanche wrote:If you are doing testing, might also consider "surrounding" the units with lights. I see these as being useful near the base of mega trees, or hidden in a group of mini trees. Wouldn't want the reciever to be able to turn the lights on, but then the interference caused by all of the lights to not let it recieve anything else.
Fantastic suggestion, thanks!!! 😀
That's the kind of thing that would be really easy to overlook -- and with vision like mine... well... bifocals came to me a lonnggggg time ago... 😉
budude wrote:If we hard-coded the channel addresses in the Rens - which is obviously more work and not as flexible - it sounds like we could use broadcast mode correct and get around the end-to-end delay? I realize this would not be as popular but perhaps an option.
It sounds like a job for a virtual Renard who’s only job is to pretend that it’s one or more boards. You just plug it into the input of your board and all previous channels are ignored. Then you could transmit in broadcast mode and all Renards would appear to be serially connected.
Boy that would surly simplify things.:D
dirknerkle wrote:Fantastic suggestion, thanks!!! 😀That's the kind of thing that would be really easy to overlook -- and with vision like mine... well... bifocals came to me a lonnggggg time ago... 😉
You'd have a mini-Faraday cage...
ErnieHorning wrote:It sounds like a job for a virtual Renard who’s only job is to pretend that it’s one or more boards.

(I had nothing else to do at work today...)
Or alternatively a new version of the Renard PIC firmware with an 'address' so that each instance can be distinguished from other instances.
Edit - however, I would not want to have to deal with the confusion that this would cause for newbies...
Edit - on second thought, this is more or less what the DMX version of the Renard firmware does...
Edit - on examining the thread more closely, this has already been mentioned.
Wireless is cool and has a certain BLING factor but think about it. $32.00 per field module plus $32.00 for the transmitter. $64.00 will buy a whole bunch of cat5 cable.
Wireless is really useful for going across the street or like inside my rotating Christmas tree. On your model train as it goes around the yard?
Before you decide to go 100% wireless, think about it, no doubt it has its place.
